The July 12 kidnapping by Hezbollah of Israeli
soldiers Ehud Goldwasser and Eldad Regev in a raid
from Lebanon into northern Israel led to an
Israeli-Hezbollah war. Israeli forces have moved into
Lebanon and 150 to 200 missiles have been fired into
Israel by Hezbollah daily — nearly 4,000 total.
Civilians and soldiers have died; billions of dollars
worth of infrastructure have been destroyed on both
sides.
Hope for a cessation of hostilities, in the form of a
rare post-Sept. 11 Franco-American draft resolution,
to be voted by the United Nations Security Council,
was short-lived. It called for “a full cessation of
hostilities” with “immediate cessation by Hezbollah of
all attacks and the immediate cessation by Israel of
all offensive military operations.” The positioning of
a French-led multinational force in southern Lebanon
as a buffer with Israel, to allow Israeli withdrawal;
the implementation of the 2004 U.N. Security Council
Resolution 1559.
But neither the Israelis nor Hezbollah accepted a
cease-fire.
The Beirut Aug. 7 emergency session of foreign
ministers of Arab League’s 20-member countries
rejected the Franco-American cease-fire plan and
backed Lebanese Premier Fouad Siniora’s demand for
immediate Israeli withdrawal and offer to send 15,000
Lebanese troops to occupy southern Lebanon, long a
Hezbollah stronghold.
Israel’s U.N. Ambassador, Dan Gillerman, expressed
skepticism: When the Lebanese “had the power and the
authority” to do that for years and were unable to do
it, isn’t it “terribly naive” to expect them to do it
“now against the wishes of Hezbollah?”
Israel shuffled the command at the Lebanese front and
shot down a Hezbollah drone said to be capable of
carrying 90 pounds of explosives. The Israeli Cabinet
approved a wider ground war for the next 30 days and
announced it will stop military operations and
withdraw when a multinational force is in place to
halt Hezbollah missile strikes into Israel.
The Lebanese say a peace deal is possible only with a
full Israeli withdrawal.
While France’s U.N. Ambassador Jean-Marc de la
Sabliere said, “We have to take into account the
concerns of all” and John Bolton, the U.S. ambassador
to the United Nations said, “We have to be thinking of
ways to take their views into account,” President
George W. Bush spoke to reporters in Crawford, Texas,
about the Franco-American draft resolution that was
rejected, urged its quick approval, and asserted,
“It’s time to address root causes of problems.”
The Aug. 7 USA Today editorial, “World leaders press
on, but path to peace is uncertain,” observed how
“entirely different” Bush’s view of “root causes” of
the conflict — Hezbollah’s “rogue
state-within-a-state” in southern Lebanon and
Hezbollah’s deliberate provocation of Israel — is
“from what Israel’s enemies view as root causes: the
very existence of Israel and its occupation of
Palestinian territories.”
In the Aug. 3 Washington Post’s “An Appeal for
Leadership, Why Hasn’t the World’s Lone Superpower
Stopped This Tragedy?”, Turkey’s deputy premier
Abdullah Gul wrote that “the inability” of the world
community to end the Israeli-Hezbollah hostilities and
the tragedy in Lebanon “raise questions about the
United States and its proud legacy of leadership for
freedom and justice.”
On the same page, retired chief of staff of the
Israeli Defense Forces in 2002-2005, Lt. Gen. Moshe
Yaalon, currently a fellow at the Washington Institute
for Near East Policy, wrote in “The Rules of War” that
the Middle East conflict is “about much more than”
Israel and Hezbollah: It’s about “the need to
distinguish combatants from noncombatants.”
Israel’s enemies, who call for its destruction, use
civilians as human shields, build headquarters in
densely populated areas, embed fighters in towns and
villages, and place missiles in private homes, Yaalon
asserted, and terrorists “are fanatics” but “not
idiots.”
“If the terrorist tactic of using human shields helps
them achieve their goals, they will utilize it. If it
undermines their goals, they will abandon it.” So, the
civilized world must condemn and take action against
those “employing such measures.”
In the Aug. 9 Post’s “End This Tragedy Now, Israel
Must Be Made to Respect International Law,” Lebanese
Premier Fouad Siniora repeated calls for “an
immediate, unconditional and comprehensive cease-fire”
so that “the root causes of this war — Israeli
occupation of Lebanese territories and its perennial
threat to Lebanon’s security, as well as Lebanon’s
struggle to regain full sovereignty over all its
territory — be addressed.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published August 16, 2006