The “clash of civilizations” within the Muslim world
— between majority traditional Muslims, who believe
and practice Islam as a religion of peace, and the
small but growing numbers of radical Islamists, who
use Islam for political purposes — developed for too
long outside of the attention of the non-Muslim world
and has contributed to world’s disharmony now in play.
In a world of 6.7 billion people, about 1.5 billion
are Muslims, of whom less than 400 million are in the
Arab world. Their perception of Americans and the
West, and the perception of Americans and the West of
Muslims and their religion, dictate the tenor of the
world we live in.
In the last few decades, Islamists embracing Wahhabism
have expanded beyond the Middle East, recruited and
indoctrinated believers from the traditional Muslim
population — first against Western values as a threat
to Islam, and now on a radical opposition to Western
influences.
New America Foundation senior fellow Robert Wright’s
“Books on Anti-Americanism, They Hate Us, They Really
Hate Us,” in the May 14, 2006 New York Times, spoke of
“the deep and diffuse roots of current
anti-Americanism” that has “no easy fix.”
Reviewing “America Against the World” by Andrew Kohut,
director of the nonpartisan Pew Research Center, and
Bruce Stokes, a columnist; and “Friendly Fire” by
Julia Sweig, a Council on Foreign Relations senior
fellow, Wright wrote, “(George W.) Bush isn’t the only
one to blame for the world’s dim view” of America.
Pew’s survey of more than 91,000 respondents in 50
countries showed the world was “pushed away” by
American “exceptionalism — our individualism and
go-it-alone attitude,” and by critics’ exaggeration of
“Americans’ pervasive religiosity and deep
patriotism.”
“We’re not obnoxiously evangelistic,” wrote Wright,
“just obnoxiously self-involved,” hence, even if “the
real America” is reflected by someone other than Bush,
“we’ll still be in trouble.”
For Sweig, “Americans think of themselves as kings and
queens of the world’s prom”; are not good at “seeing
ourselves as others see us”; and have a longstanding
“near inability” to see American power “from the
perspective of the powerless.”
Kohut and Stokes noted that since the early 1980s, the
Gallup polls showed “international resentment of
American culture (movies, McDonald’s) and business
practices (long work hours).”
“America has been alienating people for decades,”
wrote Wright.
In “Islam, a Religion of Violence?” in the April 2
Townhall.com, a Roman Catholic and conservative author
lamented how “many people, both on the left and on the
right … blame Islam for the sins of Islamic
radicalism.” In the medieval period, “Islamic
tolerance contrasts favorably with Christian
intolerance,” he posited; “Attacks on the Muslim
religion as violent” and on Muhammad as a “forerunner
of Islamic terrorism” yields the “predictable effect
of unifying traditional Muslims and radical Muslims.”
At the University of Cambridge, Asma Khalid argued in
the April 23 Christian Science Monitor’s “Why I am not
a moderate Muslim,” that the “middle way” concept is
central in Islamic tradition, and “Islam is a path of
intrinsic moderation, wasatiyya.” She refused the
label “moderate Muslim” as it implies orthodoxy as
backward and violent, whereas “I am a Muslim who
embraces peace.”
The WorldPublicOpinion.org’s surveys of Dec. 2006 to
Feb. 2007 in Egypt, Morocco, Pakistan and Indonesia,
released last week, show Muslims strongly disapprove
of attacks “by groups that use violence against
civilians, such as al-Qaida,” as “violating the
principles of Islam.”
Maybe a general belief in non-violence explains why,
on average, fewer than one in four Muslims believes
bin Laden was behind such unthinkable, un-Islamic 9/11
attacks.
While three out of four Muslims want “sharia” in
Muslim countries, and to “keep Western values out,”
two-thirds would like to “unify all Islamic countries
into a single Islamic state or caliphate.”
Dan Murphy’s “Poll: Muslims show only partial support
for Al Qaeda’s agenda” in the April 25 Monitor, quotes
Stephen Weber, who helped to conduct the polls, that
while caliphate and sharia “resonate with (Islam’s)
deep-seated values and cultural history … (Muslim)
publics don’t necessarily have a desire for every
particular, such as cutting off hands.”
The polls also show on average 79 percent of Muslims
think America seeks to “weaken and divide the Islamic
world,” and on average 74 percent of Muslims want
American bases and military forces removed from “all
Islamic countries.” There is a substantial variation
among respondents in different countries favoring
attacks on American troops in Iraq and Afghanistan,
however: eight in 10 Egyptians approve of attacks,
Indonesians oppose attacks.
But 75 percent of Muslims see globalization as a good
thing; an overall 67 percent of Muslims see “a
democratic political system” as a good way to govern
their country; and 82 percent of Muslims agree that
“people of any religion should be free to worship
according to their own beliefs.”
What radical Islamists preach and practice, and how we
deal with radical Islam, will dictate the kind of
world your children and their children, and mine, will
live in.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published May 2, 2007