Fred Hiatt’s column, “Victims of a Stalled Revolution,” in the March 7 Washington Post told the story of 6-year-old Charm Tong, who was sent across the Burmese border into Thailand by her parents because of the Burmese army’s notoriety “for raping girls as young as 4.”

Tong, of the Shan nationality, is now 23 and an activist. She re-emerged to tell stories of rape and murder of Shan girls, whose bodies were dumped; of villages destroyed and livestock slaughtered; and of families forced into relocation camps.

Hiatt lamented that U.S. economic sanctions on the Rangoon military regime have their effectiveness undermined by: the Japanese and the Europeans, “who cluck disapprovingly” but want commercial ties to resource-rich Burma; China and India, who want Burma inside their spheres of influence; and U.N. Secretary General Kofi Annan, whose envoy couldn’t even get a visa into Burma for more than a decade and who “expresses concern from time to time.”

In the March 5 New York Times, Nicholas Kristof’s column, “When Rapists Walk Free,” told a story of a Pakistani appeals court in Punjab, which set free five men who gang-raped a woman, Mukhtaran Bibi, also known as Mukhtar Mai, 33.

Mai was sentenced in June 2002 by the Meerwala tribal council to be gang-raped on charges that her 13-year-old brother had sexual relations with a woman from a prominent family. Mai called the charge a cover-up for the powerful Mastoi clan.

“I will fight a legal battle to death,” she vowed. She wanted the rapists hanged.

As Mai’s plight captured world attention, Pakistan President Gen. Pervez Musharraf ordered the men arrested. Fourteen men were charged and the council leader, a member, and four men were convicted and sentenced to death in August 2002 for gang-rape.

Mai was compensated with some $8,000, which she used to create two schools, one for boys and one for girls, in her village

But on March 3, Pakistan’s high court overturned the death sentences, ordered five men freed and reduced the sixth man’s sentence to life in jail. All are Mai’s neighbors. Human rights groups protested and Pakistani women rallied and called for Mai’s protection.

On March 11, Pakistan’s Federal Sharia Court, the highest court, threw out the decision to release the five men on the grounds that a lower appeals court had no jurisdiction to rule on the case.

But who really knows what will happen to Mai?

I had a hard time fitting the two stories into the limited space a newspaper column allows, with space left to relate them to Anne Applebaum’s “Writing Women Into a Corner” in the March 16 Washington Post, a column about a growing dispute initiated by a USC-tenured professor, Susan Estrich, to get the L.A. Times to print more opinion pieces by women.

Applebaum viewed Estrich’s “conversation” as “seriously bad for female columnists and writers,” because now every woman who gets her column published must wonder if that is because of her knowledge or her gender.

Maureen Dowd’s “Dish It Out, Ladies,” in the March 13 New York Times, spoke of “male bloggers” and “male TV shouters” who predominate, and how she felt like she was in a “Godfather” movie — “shooting and getting shot at.”

Georgetown University professor Deborah Tannen’s column, “The Feminine Technique,” in the March 15 L.A. Times, described how “little boys set up wars and play-fights. Little girls fight, but not for fun.” She questioned why the “one way” to write columns is “the way it’s always done, the men’s way.” She suggested that “attack-dog journalism” is neither the only way nor the best way.

She quoted University of Virginia Center for Politics director Larry Sabato — that people tend to think “if you’re not an attack dog, you’re a lap dog.” But Tannen asserted there is “a third way: a watchdog. And a dog who is busy attacking is not watching.”

Meanwhile, Harvard president Larry Summers is still in hot water for his “women” remarks.

In Burma and in Pakistan, as in many other parts of our world, women struggle even more profoundly. The civil rights they seek are framed in an entirely different context.

A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., retired from the University of Guam where he taught political science for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.

 

Originally published March 23, 2005