In my column, “U.S. should ‘remember 1975′; we don’t
know how Iraq will evolve” (March 28 Pacific Daily
News), I wrote of British writer William Shawcross, a
Vietnam war critic and author of the Pulitzer Prize
nominated-book, “Sideshow: Kissinger, Nixon and the
Destruction of Cambodia,” who was critical of how
Washington expanded the war into Cambodia to
“extricate” itself from Vietnam.
Extrication became a goal in and of itself, replacing
the original rationale for the war to fight communist
expansion.
Shawcross quoted President Nixon’s national security
advisor Henry Kissinger in “Sideshow”: “Look, we’re
not interested in Cambodia … only … in it not
being used as a base (by the Vietnamese Communists).”
Kissinger later confirmed in his own book, “White
House Years” that “Cambodia was not a moral issue” for
the United States in obtaining “our exit from
Vietnam.”
While the extent of the devastation Pol Pot and the
Khmer Rouge would spread across Cambodia could not
have been predicted, the ruthlessness of the Khmer
Rouge was not unknown prior to the Americans’ exit.
They left anyway. In Shawcross’s words, “two million
of the seven million (Cambodian) people died, either
murdered by the Khmer Rouge or from starvation and
disease.”
Plenty has been written on Cambodia’s killing fields:
Not a family has been spared injury or loss.
Shawcross pleaded that America should not abandon Iraq
the way she did Cambodia in 1975.
Of e-mails I received after the Shawcross article, a
reader commented, “History is not a favorite subject
of Americans — unfortunately.”
If history is not a guide and its lessons are
discarded for the present, on what basis do we move
toward the future?
Reasonable arguments abound, from reasonable people,
for and against America’s involvement in the Iraq war.
In my March 21 column, “When it comes to Iraq war,
both supporters and critics show bias,” I referenced a
social psychologist who said, we “are really bad about
putting ourselves in other people’s shoes,” and are so
unaccepting of others who act “in good faith” but see
things differently from us.
I studied arguments from both sides of the political
spectrum. The March 16 Los Angeles Times editorial,
“From the terrorist’s mouth,” reminds us however we
disagree, “there is a movement that has declared war
on the U.S. and the West . . . its existence is
undeniable.”
The March 18 Washington Post editorial, “Lessons of
War,” argues, “What matters most is finding the best
policy now — doing whatever can be done to help Iraq
and safeguard U.S. interests in a vital region.”
The Post posits we don’t know how events in Iraq will
evolve, and “We will never know what might have
happened had Saddam Hussein and his sons been left in
power.” It notes the “easy way out” by blaming Bush,
Cheney, or Donald Rumsfeld, but argues, “Wars unleash
unpredictable and ugly forces” and “the (Iraq) war
might have spun out of control even under wiser
leadership.”
“It would almost be comfortable if Mr. Bush had ‘lied
the nation into war,’ as is frequently charged,” says
the Post. But, “The best postwar journalism instead
suggests” that Bush, his team, and the Central
Intelligence Agency, “exaggerated, cherry-picked and
simplified but fundamentally believed … the
catastrophically wrong case” the U.S. presented to the
United Nations.
The March 31-April 6 London Economist’s front page,
titled cover, “Besieged,” shows an armed President
Bush, Secretary of State Rice, and Vice President
Cheney in camouflaged uniforms behind sandbags on
White House lawn. The accompanying article,
editorializes, “Many people” may rejoice seeing Bush
and Cheney “ducking for cover.”
“But regardless of what you think about this most
inept of presidencies,” the editorial continues, “the
current civil war in Washington has the marking of a
tragedy — both for America and for millions of people
around the globe.”
The Economist encourages Congress to “Carry on
overseeing” and advises, “But hands off Iraq.”
“Sooner or later, America will leave Iraq,” says the
Economist, “But it is essential that it leaves in the
right way.”
Last September, America’s 16 spy agencies presented in
a National Intelligence Estimate two bad choices for
America: “perceived jihadist success (in Iraq) would
inspire more fighters to continue the struggle
elsewhere”; and “should jihadists leaving Iraq
perceive themselves, and be perceived, to have failed,
(America’s spy agencies) judge fewer fighters will be
inspired to carry on the fight.”
Perhaps it should be recalled that when Americans left
former French Indochina in 1975, the North Vietnamese
victors were happy to see Americans scramble to take
off in helicopters from Saigon’s building rooftops.
The war was “over” for them.
Will the movement — “Whatever you call it,” says the
Times, “militant Islam, Islamic fascism or a clash of
civilizations” — “that has declared war on the U.S.
and the West” cease its warring activities as American
and “coalition” troops withdraw from Iraq?
The soul of Islam is being wrested from the majority
of traditional Muslims by a small but growing
influential minority of radical Muslims who quoted the
Koran to justify about “slaying the infidels” —
another topic that Americans must be concerned about
while Bush and the Democratic Congress are entrenched
in Washington’s own “civil war.”
How will the war in Iraq “end?”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published April 11, 2007