In 27 days, we’ll know if Congress will remain
Republican-controlled, or not. Until then, politicians
are posturing for votes.
A recent New York Times-CBS News poll found a great
majority of Americans see members of Congress
negatively — too tied to interest groups, having no
understanding of average Americans’ needs and
problems. Only 25 percent approved of Congress.
Americans are polarized and partisan.
Democrats and Republicans used the National
Intelligence Estimate to spar with each other; Bob
Woodward’s book, “State of Denial,” accuses the White
House of misleading the public on the Iraq war — his
earlier books had left no such impression. President
Bush, who branded Democrats as “cut-and-run,” told the
public in Stockton, Calif., if they don’t think the
government “should be listening in on the terrorists,
then “to vote for the Democrats,” but if they want the
government to “continue listening in when al-Qaida
planners are making phone calls into the United
States, then you vote Republican.”
Who is spinning, and shouldn’t voters be confused?
Lee Hamilton, the 9/11 commission vice chair, spoke
frustratedly on CBS News’ “freeSpeech” about “partisan
finger-pointing” and the “endless political posturing
and accusations about how the other guy is to blame.”
On Sept. 26, Anatoly (Natan) Sharansky, a former
Soviet dissident who spent nine years in a Soviet
gulag and 400 days in jail cells, also spoke on CBS:
“Maintaining our principles in the face of terror is
sometimes dangerous. Abandoning those principles would
be even more dangerous.”
He thinks those who have used Abu Ghraib or Guantanamo
Bay to brand America as being “no different” than the
Soviet Union, Nazi Germany, or the Saddam Hussein
regime “have lost all sense of moral clarity.”
Because “America is different,” he said. Americans can
protest and not be jailed, U.S. courts can uphold
civil rights, the U.S. press can expose injustice,
Americans can hold leaders accountable. “America is
different because America is free,” he said, and he
urged Americans to “remember the profound moral divide
that separates the free world from the world of fear
and work to advance the very principles you so rightly
cherish at home.”
In “Blinded by Hindsight,” in the Oct. 1 New York
Times, Richard A. Clarke summed up the “partisan
rewriting of history” and the “heated, partisan
exchange of accusations of who did what when” by
saying that, “In short, both (Clinton and Bush)
administrations failed” and the “finger-pointing and
hunting for scapegoats … won’t rectify those
failures, or help us avoid future ones.”
In the Oct. 2 Washington Post’s “Iraq War Naysayers
May Have Hindsight Bias,” Shankar Vedantam noted how
“antiwar liberals” savored the “four most satisfying
words, ‘I told you so,'” after the release of the NIE
report. “Only … that isn’t quite true,” and he
refers to what psychologists call “hindsight bias —
the feeling, after an event happens, that we knew all
along it was going to happen.” Hindsight is
“self-serving” and “gives people a false sense of
security.”
In the Post’s “The Big Question Democrats Are
Ducking,” David Ignatius lamented that, even among
mainstream Democrats, “the focus is ‘gotcha!’ rather
than ‘what next?'” He sees Democrats wanting to treat
Iraq as “George Bush’s war and wash their hands of it.
… But the damage of Iraq can be mitigated only if it
again becomes the nation’s war — with the whole
country invested in finding a way out of the morass
that doesn’t leave us permanently in greater peril.”
Then comes “If I Had One Wish,” in the Oct. 4 New York
Times, by Pulitzer Prize winner Thomas Friedman: “For
the sake of the country, I really hope the Republicans
lose the House and the Senate to the Democrats — by
one seat in each chamber,” so that Democrats “will
have to govern from the center — to look for
bipartisan fixes” which is “the only way” to fix
America’s major issues.
He wrote of “the grotesque incompetence” the
“Bush-Cheney-Rumsfeld-Rice team” has exhibited in
Iraq, “a war that was not preordained to fail, but was
never given a proper chance to succeed — it makes
this country look like a banana republic.”
Seeing how unfairly and harshly the Iraq burden falls
on the “U.S. military troops and their families,”
Friedman noted the saying that after a while, pet
owners start to look like their pets: “Well, we’re
starting to look like Iraq — a bunch of warring
political tribes incapable of acting in common for the
greater good.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published October 11, 2006