The March 12 Washington Post column by Shankar
Vedantam on an Illinois State University researchers’
study, how Iraq war supporters and critics “have come
to believe entirely different narratives about the war
— and about each other,” offers us much to learn
about ourselves.
Statistical findings show, social psychologist Glenn
- Reeder of ISU says, that we “are really bad about
putting ourselves in other people’s places,” looking
at things the way they do, and are unwilling to accept
that others are acting “in good faith if they reach a
conclusion that is different than ours.”
The study finds large numbers of people on both sides
claim they know “the motives” of those who disagree
with them.
Vedantam said: “When was the last time you heard
people say that those who disagree with them on the
Iraq war are well-meaning, smart, informed and
thoughtful?”
Both war supporters and critics suffer from an
identical bias: If you agree with a group, you see it
as “motivated by ethics and principle.” If you don’t,
you see it as “motivated by narrow self-interest.”
Thus, a large percentage of war supporters see
President Bush as “aiming to do good,” while only a
small percentage of war critics do; a large percentage
of war critics see Bush’s “hidden motive,” while only
a small percentage of supporters do.
Assuming what we believe about Bush’s motives is true
and what our opponents believe is false, Vedantam
warned, other studies “suggest people ought to be
cautious about such conclusions.” We are seen as “less
informed” if we disagree with a group and “better
informed” if we do. Even if opponents are
“knowledgeable,” their conclusions are still seen as
“self-serving and biased.”
Harvard Business School researcher Robert J. Robinson
and his colleagues say in a study that “Partisans
within ideological groups” see themselves as
“atypical” in their moderation, freedom from bias and
capacity to see things as they really are, “even if
that reality proves to be ideologically inconvenient
or ‘politically incorrect.'”
Vedantam wrote, “If you believe that you are a patriot
but that those who disagree with you about the Iraq
war are self-interested zealots intent on destroying
America, what can you possibly have to discuss with
them?”
The “they-are-bad-we’re-good” concept is polarizing
and destructive. Can someone be 100 percent bad, 100
percent of the time, someone asked somewhere before.
Psychologist Reeder, who has “very strong beliefs”
about the Iraq war,” told himself not to get “too
heated” about the war, as he might fall victim to the
very biases he studies. He declined to say where he
stands on the war, but asserted, “if partisans on both
sides” of the war think he disagree with them, then “I
have done my job.”
Last week, two major newspapers on the West and East
Coast, both critical of President Bush’s Iraq policy,
editorialized about the Democrats’ Iraq plan.
The March 12 Los Angeles Times’ “Do we really need a
Gen. Pelosi?” sees the House Democrats’ plan to force
Bush to withdraw American troops by 2008 as “an unruly
mess: bad public policy, bad precedent and bad
politics.” It says, “Bush’s wartime leadership does
not aspire much confidence,” but, “members of Congress
need to act responsibly, debating the essence of the
choice the United States now faces — to stay or go —
and putting their money where their mouths are. But
too many lives are at stake to allow members of
Congress to play the role of Eisenhower or Lincoln.”
“Congress should not hinder Bush’s ability to seek the
best possible endgame to this very bad war,” says the
Times; “If the legislation passes, Bush says he’ll
veto it, as well he should.”
A day later, the March 13 Washington Post editorial,
“The Pelosi Plan for Iraq. It makes perfect sense, if
the goal is winning votes in the United States,” sees
the plan as seeking to impose “detailed management on
a war without regard for the war itself,” ignoring the
Iraqis’ future, mandating military steps according to
an “inflexible timetable conforming to the need to
capture votes in Congress or at the 2008 polls.” It
charges: “Ms. Pelosi’s strategy leads not toward a
responsible withdrawal from Iraq but to a
constitutional power struggle with Mr. Bush (that)
would serve the interests of neither the Democrats or
the country.”
Foreign Policy Magazine’s online article, “What Iraq
Tells Us About Ourselves,” by retired Army Col. W.
Patrick Lang, Jr., a professor of Arabic at West
Point, says, “The Bush administration, the Iraqi
people, and the Iranian meddling have all been blamed
for the mess in Mesopotamia. But the American people
themselves are the true root of the problem.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published March 21, 2007