I was positive that President George W. Bush held a
teleconference with U.S. soldiers in Tikrit, Iraq, on
Oct. 13 — until I saw on my TV screen how Allison
Barber, deputy assistant secretary of defense for
internal communication, coached a soldier to answer
Bush as reporters listened in and a television camera
rolled.
This staged “live” videoconference was caught on
camera at the same time a Wall Street Journal/NBC poll
found Bush’s overall job-approval rating has fallen to
39 percent, and a mid-September USA Today/CNN/Gallup
Poll has found that only one in three Americans
approve of Bush’s handling of Iraq.
I pulled out the July 10 Washington Post’s, “A Hawk
Questions Himself as His Son Goes to War,” by Eliot
Cohen, director of strategic studies at the Johns
Hopkins University School of Advanced International
Studies. I dusted off the 19-page transcript of
Cohen’s discussion about the column on July 31 with
C-SPAN host, Brian Lamb. Thus, this column.
Cohen is a military historian, a professor who taught
at the Naval War College and ran seminars for general
officers on how to think strategically. He advocated
the war in Iraq. He is a father of four. His oldest
son, a graduate of Harvard, got his parachute wings,
went through Ranger school, and was prepared to head
to Iraq to lead an infantry platoon “on some mean
streets somewhere.”
Cohen never discouraged his son from joining the
service, nor did he push him into it. His son knew he
was going into harm’s way. Cohen is “proud and
scared;” his wife is “scared and proud.” Like other
American families, they just grit their teeth and get
through it and try to be supportive of their son.
I cannot do justice to Cohen’s sentiments by
attempting to summarize them in this brief space, but
I strongly recommend that you seek out both the column
and the discussion on C-SPAN yourself.
Disbelief, alarm, disdain
Reflecting on the Iraq war, Cohen expressed his
“disbelief” that it should take so long to call the
Iraqi insurgency by its name; “alarm” at the failure
to promote able and talented officers at wartime speed
and sweep aside the incompetents; “incredulity” at
seeing medals and awards given to those who were there
“when things went badly wrong;” “disdain” for the
officer who cannot admit that American soldiers have
tortured and killed; “contempt” for war opponents’
“ghoulish glee” and war proponents’ “blithe disregard”
of the bungles; a “desire — barely controlled — to
slap the highly educated fool” who said “mistakes
happen in all wars” and that one shouldn’t get excited
over the casualties.
Cohen views the “true arguments for war” as deeper
than Saddam Hussein’s possession of weapons of mass
destruction, weapons inspections broken down, failed
sanctions or Saddam’s failure to alter his regime’s
character and ambitions. A policy of isolating Iraq
only made people suffer. U.S. accommodation to “thugs
and kleptocrats” to maintain order also failed.
Cohen believed that Bush was right to think that
Saddam’s ouster could change the pattern of Middle
Eastern politics. He told C-SPAN that while he is
critical of the Bush administration on many things, he
remains “tepidly optimistic” about the war.
Because he did not know what he knows now about “just
how incompetent we would be at carrying out” the task
of war, he would have to answer “with an unhesitating
yes” to the question of whether he supports the war.
He doesn’t believe that there is anybody in Iraq who,
just by their DNA, “doesn’t have some sort of
aspiration to be free.”
While acknowledging the shaky public support for the
war, Cohen made clear that, “If we fail in Iraq — and
I don’t think we will — it won’t be because the
American people lack the heart, but because leaders
and institutions have failed.”
“The scholar in me is not surprised when our leaders
blunder, although the pundit in me is dismayed when
they do,” he wrote. “What the father in me expects
from our leaders is, simply, the truth — an end to
happy talk and denials of error, and a seriousness
equal to that of the men and women our country sends
into the fight.”
Cohen told C-SPAN he was speaking to the president, to
his senior subordinates, to the congressional
leadership, and that “I really don’t care” if they are
upset with him.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published October 19, 2005