In a few weeks, voters go to the polls and elect their
representatives to Congress. In post-Sept. 11 America,
the war on terror and the Iraq war are uppermost on
their minds, and their perspectives should logically
influence their votes.
The recently released conclusions of the nation’s 16
spy agencies in a National Intelligence Estimate, that
the Iraq war is “breeding a deep resentment … and
cultivating supporters for the global jihadist
movement,” among other bleak findings, has reinforced
Democrats’ assertions that President George W. Bush’s
foreign policy is in shambles.
Viewing “selective” leaks of a classified document as
politically motivated, and pressured by some
Republican supporters to declassify the report, Bush
ordered the 3-page-plus “key judgments,” or
conclusions, of the 30-page NIE report released so
that “the American people and the world will be able
to see the truth and precisely what that document
says.”
The Sept. 28 Washington Post editorial calls the
declassified portions of the NIE report “a clear,
reasoned and sobering account of the Islamic extremist
threat,” and “a good estimate” that “ought to
enlighten the campaign debate.”
Until Election Day on Nov. 7, there is time to
“enlighten” or “inflame” the debate — there’s plenty
to “spin.” The key judgments in the NIE give both
political sides ammunition for charges and
counter-charges.
How many voters will have bothered to read the
consensus view on two important issues affecting our
lives and the future of our children, and will seek to
understand more about them before they vote? Last week
I wrote in this space that voters have a choice in
their future democracy — a choice that each of us
should exercise every two years.
The consensus report draws severe conclusions:
Islamist “jihadists, although a small percentage of
Muslims, are increasing in both number and geographic
dispersion”; the “Iraq conflict has become the ’cause
celebre’ for jihadists”; “the Iraq jihad is shaping a
new generation of terrorist leaders and operatives.”
The NIE report warns of “increasing attacks worldwide”
if the trend of bad news continues.
These conclusions contradict Bush’s victory claims,
and Democrats have charged that his Iraq policies have
made America “less safe” and not “safer.” The
consensus report also gives credence to Bush’s
argument that Iraq is al-Qaida’s central front and
that an early withdrawal from Iraq will not bring an
end to the terrorist threat to the United States.
The report says: “perceived jihadist success (in Iraq)
would inspire more fighters to continue the struggle
elsewhere.” And, “should jihadists leaving Iraq
perceive themselves, and be perceived, to have failed,
(the 16 intelligence agencies) judge fewer fighters
will be inspired to carry on the fight.”
Hence, Bush’s “stay the course” policy.
Jessica Stern, a terrorism expert and a lecturer at
Harvard’s John F. Kennedy School of Government, told
the Christian Science Monitor, “I don’t think we have
good choices in Iraq.”
I wrote a few times in this space my view that in this
war on terrorism we must look beyond the Iraq war. The
consensus report sees the Iraq war as only one of four
factors “fueling the spread of the jihadist movement.”
The other three are “entrenched grievances, such as
corruption, injustice,” and a “sense of powerlessness”
felt by some in the Muslim world; the slow pace of
“reforms” in many Muslim nations; and “pervasive
anti-U.S. sentiment among most Muslims.”
The NIE report speaks of the need to expose and
exploit the jihadist movement’s “vulnerabilities” to
slow its spread: Its “greatest vulnerability” is the
“vast majority of Muslims” who don’t like the
jihadists’ “ultra-conservative” methods and their
violence. The report sees the “Muslim mainstream …
as the most powerful weapon in the war on terror” and
that the progress of “democratic reform efforts in
Muslim majority nations” and “coordinated multilateral
efforts” are ways to combat the spread of the
movement.
The Sept. 2-8 London Economist, which preceded the
release of the NIE conclusions, editorialized that,
“Islam had its deadly and inchoate grievances before
the Iraq war and before Sept. 11” and that “mass
terrorism by Islamist extremists remains a danger. To
say that America’s mistakes have increased the threat
is not to say that America caused it.
“The world must still strive to destroy al-Qaida and,
even more, the idea it represents,” the editorial
said, “But it had better do so with cleverer means
than those Mr. Bush has used so far.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published October 4, 2006