In my Dec. 15 column, “University education should be
a sharing of ideas, despite viewpoint,” I shared my
ideas of what a university should be and suggested
that the role of teachers is to share knowledge and
inspire students.
Last July 20, David Brooks’ column, “Learning to
Think, and Live,” in The New York Times, revealed how
students in a Yale Grand Strategy course, taught by
John Lewis Gaddis, Paul Kennedy and Charles Hill, were
applying the theories of Thucydides, Kant and Sun Tzu
to modern foreign policy crises. Brooks, who also
taught at Yale, found his students to have “a special
reverence for Hill,” a Renaissance man, a career
foreign service officer who knew and had used power,
and applied literature and philosophy to everyday
problems.
Brooks spoke of students going to Hill outside class
to seek guidance, and how Hill made time for them. One
student joined the Marines after graduation; some
rebelled against Hill’s self-confident opinions. But
others were very drawn to Hill.
Brooks, who noted students were drawn to “a teacher
who is not a lifelong academic, but who was active in
the real world,” lamented American universities
“operate too much like a guild system, throwing plenty
of people with dissertations at students, not enough
with practical knowledge.” He regretted that many
universities have become “professionalized
information-transmission systems,” and he wished to
see more scholars like Hill, Gaddis and Kennedy, who
teach students to be generalists, to see the great
connections, rather than the “squirrel-like
specialization” encouraged by academia.
I think Brooks presented many valid points. I am
reminded of American poet Henry Wadsworth Longfellow,
who wrote: “A single conversation across the table
with a wise man is better than 10 years’ mere study of
books” and an English proverb, “An ounce of practice
is worth a pound of precept.”
On April 10, my wife and I returned from joining some
half-million visitors to see the spectacular cherry
blossoms along the Tidal Basin in Washington, D.C., to
find a column, “Hey, Profs, Come Back to Earth,” in
The Washington Post. It spoke of university professors
and administrators from the left and the right leading
“political correctness and posturing” to “dizzying
heights in the land of the ivory tower.” Its author,
Steve Goodman, is a Washington-based educational
consultant who advises college-bound students and
their families.
Goodman wrote of how many middle-class parents are
frustrated by and resentful of the “sky-high tuition”
for colleges that are said to offer their children “a
menu of questionable courses and politically absurd
campus climates that detract from the quality of a
university education.”
Goodman recalled that in the 1980s many of his
students told him that only an Ivy League school would
satisfy them. But today, he wrote, many aren’t sure
that the Ivies are worth the money, and the “vast
majority” are eager to find a school that will help
them advance in their intellectual and professional
lives. Goodman added: “There is a world of difference
between challenging students to think more broadly and
trying to shoehorn them into a more narrow spectrum of
thought, which many parents feel is happening.”
On April 19, the president of Christopher Newport
University in Newport News wrote a column in The
Washington Post about the Times of London’s global
ranking of 200 best universities, based on a survey of
1,300 academics in 88 countries. The survey found
Harvard still holding the top place, while the world’s
second best was not Oxford, Yale or Stanford, but the
public, state-sponsored University of California at
Berkeley.
While public universities in Alabama, Arizona, Texas,
Maryland, Michigan, Virginia, among others, ranked
among the global elite 200, he warned that their
future is “in doubt.” The social compact that
supported higher education is being dismissed, he
contended, and state appropriations for higher
education have declined sharply between 1997 and 2002.
The column argued that states should grant public
universities “greater authority” to make decisions and
to be accountable for greater efficiency and academic
performance.
America’s technological, economic and military place
in the 21st century world is determined in large
measure by the value of today’s university education,
the column contended.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published May 11, 2005