British writer William Shawcross, a strong critic of
America’s Vietnam War role and author of “Sideshow:
Kissinger, Nixon and the Destruction of Cambodia,”
which was nominated for a Pulitzer Prize, wrote in the
March 3 London Times’ “Remember: for Cambodia, read
Iraq,” how “Given the catastrophe of the communist
victories” in Indochina, “those like myself who were
opposed to the American efforts … should be very
humble.”
Singapore’s Lee Kuan Yew sees America’s long presence
as having allowed other states in the region “time to
build up their economies,” fight poverty and resist
communist encroachment, argues Shawcross, so American
efforts were not a “sheer disaster.”
“In Indochina the majority of Western journalists
(including myself) believed that the war could not and
should not be won,” he writes. The anti-war sentiment
then was: Ending the war meant ending human suffering
albeit Pol Pot’s radicalism was known.
So, in March 1975, Congress rejected President Gerald
Ford’s $222 million request in supplemental military
aid for Phnom Penh as the Khmer Rouge were at its
gate. Ford told Congress, “All American troops have
come home (and) will not go back,” and his
administration wanted Phnom Penh to have “the means to
resist,” to ensure a political settlement.
Shawcross recalls the day the Khmer Rouge victors
demanded that all Cambodians taking refuge in the
French Embassy surrender — “Many were murdered at
once as ‘Western agents'” — and trucked out of
Cambodia “the foreigners, including (New York Times
reporter Sydney) Schanberg.”
Schanberg’s account appeared on the May 9, 1975,
Times’ front page: “All of us were wrong,” he wrote
about human suffering that was played out before his
eyes.
Today, Vietnam War critic Shawcross quoted Iraq
al-Qaida’s Musab al-Zarqawi, who said before he was
killed: “The shedding of Muslim blood is allowed in
order to disrupt the greater evil of disrupting
jihad.”
As Khalid Sheikh Mohammed declared his role in 9/11
and 30 other terror plots, and himself “at war” with
America and the West, the March 16 Los Angeles Times
editorialized: “Whether you call it militant Islam,
Islamic fascism or a clash of civilizations, there is
a movement that has declared war on the U.S. and the
West. … It is neither a figment of President Bush’s
imagination nor a byproduct of the Iraq war. …
Americans disagree about how to engage that enemy, but
its existence is undeniable.”
“Remember 1975,” pleaded Shawcross.
For him, “there was no vast mass murder” in Vietnam
and Laos, only “cruel gulags” from which millions of
people fled, mostly to America; but Cambodia had her
“killing fields” where up to “two million died, either
murdered … or from starvation.”
A story on Cambodia should be retold.
On April 12, 1975, at 7 a.m., Cambodian leaders
learned through a letter from U.S. Ambassador John
Gunther Dean that anyone wishing to leave Cambodia
could bring immediate family members (wives and
children) to the embassy to depart “two and a half
hours from now,” at 9:30 a.m.
Cambodians decided at a high-level meeting to decline
Dean’s offer. Prince Sisowath Sirik Matak, one of
seven Cambodian leaders on the Khmer Rouge’s death
list, sent a hand-written reply that reached Dean at 9
a.m. The letter read: “Dear excellency and friend: I
thank you very sincerely for your letter and for your
offer to transport me toward freedom. I cannot, alas,
leave in such a cowardly fashion.
“As for you, and in particular for your great country,
I never believed for a moment that you would have this
sentiment of abandoning a people which has chosen
liberty. You have refused us your protection and we
can do nothing about it. You leave and my wish is that
you and your country will find happiness under the
sky.
“But mark it well that, if I shall die here on the
spot in my country that I love, it is too bad because
we are all born and must die one day. I have only
committed this mistake of believing in you, the
Americans.
“Please accept, excellency, my dear friend, my
faithful and friendly sentiments.”
Dean left by helicopter on April 12, 1975. Matak
walked out of the French Embassy on April 17 and
surrendered to the Khmer Rouge, conscious of his fate.
Matak may be just a name; Cambodia, a place; two
million dead, a number. But there are lessons from
this tragedy.
As America marked the Iraq War’s fourth anniversary,
the March 18 Sunday Washington Post’s “Lessons of War”
editorialized: “It’s tempting to say that if it was
wrong to go in, it must be wrong to stay in. But how
Iraq evolves will fundamentally shape the region and
deeply affect U.S. security.”
That means how Iraq evolves will affect you and me.
For the Post, “Walking away is likely to make a bad
situation worse. A patient, sustained U.S. commitment,
with gradually diminishing military forces, could
still help Iraq to move in the right direction.”
Nobody knows how Iraq will evolve, but “history’s
judgment in five years or 10 may look very different
than today’s,” says the Post.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published March 28, 2007