Fareed Zakaria, an Indian-born American citizen who is
international editor of Newsweek, warned in the Nov.
22, 2004, column, “Rejecting the Next Bill Gates,”
that the decline in foreign students in the United
States since the Sept. 11 attacks is America’s great
loss.
Missed opportunities to educate the world’s young
scholars — who themselves miss opportunities to learn
American values and ideas — cannot be replaced.
Zakaria just spent much of December traveling around
Asia. In “We All Have a Lot to Learn,” in the Jan. 9
Newsweek, Zakaria says he was struck by Asia’s
“relentless focus on education.”
Pulitzer Prize winner Thomas L. Friedman has quoted
Microsoft chairman Bill Gates, who warned that in 2001
that India “graduated almost a million more students
from college” than the United States did, with twice
as many students with bachelor’s degrees as the United
States and “six times” as many graduates in
engineering.
Zakaria says “it makes sense” because many Asian
countries that have “no natural resources, other than
their people, making them smarter is the only path for
development.”
He sees China as “moving fastest.” Chinese officials
talk of future growth and refer to an “almost tenfold”
increase in spending on colleges and universities in
the past 10 years. Zakaria reminds that East Asia tops
“virtually every global ranking of students in science
and mathematics.” As he said earlier, “Americans don’t
do science anymore.”
My Dec. 14 column, “The U.S. melting pot of success
shrinks with foreign student numbers,” referred to
America’s immigrants’ children acing science classes
and how many of America’s top scientists and
mathematicians are foreign-born.
So when Zakaria was in Asia, he sought out Singapore’s
minister of education, Tharman Shanmugaratnam. Zakaria
wanted to know why Singapore is No. 1 in the global
science and math rankings for schoolchildren who test
brilliantly, but 10 or 20 years later finds few of
them are “worldbeaters anymore.” Zakaria says
Singapore has “few truly top-ranked scientists,
entrepreneurs, inventors, business executives or
academics,” whereas American kids who “test much worse
in the fourth and eighth grades” do “better later in
life and in the real world.”
Why?
Shanmugaratnam distinguished between American “talent
meritocracy” and Singaporean “exam meritocracy.” He
confessed that Singaporeans do not test well in areas
of “creativity, curiosity, a sense of adventure,
ambition,” while America has “a culture of learning
that challenges conventional wisdom, even if it means
challenging authority.” Shanmugaratnam said, “These
are the areas where Singapore must learn from
America.”
Zakaria says Singapore now is focusing on factors
other than raw testing skills to select top students,
but that “culture is hard to change.” He writes about
a friend’s son who was applauded and encouraged when
he spoke up in an American school, while he’s seen as
“pushy and weird” in Singapore. “The culture of making
learning something to love and engage in with gusto is
totally absent.”
Yet, Shanmugaratnam said, the U.S. education system
“as a whole has failed.”
He argued that unless Americans are “comfortable
middle class or richer, (they) get an education that
is truly second rate by any standards.” This means,
Shanmugaratnam said, “the talent of poor, bright kids”
who don’t go to school is “never really accessed” and
the teaching methods of bringing everyone along in
class means that “the bright ones are never pushed.”
“In Singapore we get the poor kid who is very bright
and very hungry, and that’s crucial to our success,”
Shanmugaratnam affirmed.
Whereas Friedman speaks of the world that is “flat,”
the Singaporean minister remarked that, “From where I
sit, it’s not a flat world.” The world is “one of
peaks and valleys.” He believes the peaks in America
“are getting higher. But the valleys are getting
deeper.”
And so, Asia’s best acknowledges there are areas in
which Singapore needs to learn from America. As
Zakaria writes, we all have a lot to learn from one
another:
“Asian Learning, American Learning.”
Would parents, educators, and politicians on Guam
benefit from both experiences?
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published January 18, 2006