If men were angels, there is no need for government,
said one of America’s founding fathers, James Madison.
But government is made of men and fallible men make
mistakes. Costly mistakes have been made in the war on
terror. Yet that does not mean the war on terror is a
“bumper-sticker slogan.”
The March 16 Los Angeles Times editorialized, “There
is a movement that has declared war on the U.S. and
the West,” and “Whatever you call it, … its
existence is undeniable.”
An October 2004 ABC News broadcast of a videotape
showed a man wearing dark glasses, his face hidden
behind an Arab headdress, reiterating al-Qaida
leaders’ “weighty words, … that what took place on
Sept. 11 was but the opening salvo of the global war
on America.” He declared, “My fellow countrymen, you
are guilty, guilty, guilty, guilty. … After decades
of American tyranny and oppression, now it’s your turn
to die.” He promised American streets would “run red
with blood.”
He was not a Saudi, not a Pakistani, but a U.S.
citizen, born in 1978 in Orange County, Calif. He’s
known in the tape as Azzam al-Amriki, or Azzam the
American.
His father, Philip Pearlman, was an agnostic who made
a name in the 1960s’ psychedelic rock culture,
converted to Christianity and changed his name to
“Gadahn” — from the Biblical figure, Gideon — before
the masked man was born and named Adam Gadahn. His
paternal grandfather was a surgeon of Jewish heritage,
his paternal grandmother was an editor for The
Chronicle Christian Newspaper.
Growing up, Adam Gadahn rejected the Christian concept
of the Holy Trinity, explored Islamic Web sites,
frequented a mosque and embraced Islam in 1995, at age
- Soon he was drawn into a circle of anti-Western
angry young men, most from Pakistan.
He disappeared in 2004 and is believed to be in
Pakistan.
In a July 7, 2006, al-Qaida tape on the Internet,
Gadahn was shown unmasked, and again in a Sept. 2006
videotape, “Invitation to Islam,” when he reiterated
al-Zawahiri’s offer to Americans to convert to Islam
to avoid bloodshed. Gadahn called on “Zionist crusader
missionaries” and “the crusader-in-chief George W.
Bush” to “abandon their unbelief and repent and enter
into the light of Islam,” or face attacks. The May 4-6
USA Today/Gallup Poll revealed more than half of
Americans surveyed think “new terrorist attacks” like
the 9/11 attacks would occur whether the U.S.
withdraws its troops from Iraq or not; 59 percent said
they wanted a timetable for U.S. troops home
regardless.
In a May 29 videotape on the internet, Gadahn,
unmasked and wearing a white robe and turban, tells
Americans to “Pull every last one of your soldiers,
spies, security advisors, trainers, attaches, … out
of every Muslim land from Afghanistan to Zanzibar.” He
promises that “failure to heed our demands” means
America and Americans will “experience things which
will make you forget all about the horrors of
September 11th, Afghanistan and Iraq and Virginia
Tech.”
Of course, al-Qaida leaders know their demands will
not be met by any U.S. administration.
A conservative think tank, The Jamestown Foundation,
self-described as “utilizing indigenous and primary
sources” and delivering material “without political
bias, filter or agenda,” published on June 5 in its
Terrorism Focus, “Al-Qaida’s American Recruit Releases
Something Entirely New,” written by Michael Scheuer, a
22-year veteran of the Central Intelligence Agency and
chief of the bin Laden unit.
Scheuer sees Gadahn as “the sledge that drives home
the spike of bin Laden’s messages for Americans.” The
videotape, he says, “suggests that (bin Laden and
al-Zawahiri) “ordered Gadahn to make a last warning to
Americans before al-Qaida attacks inside the United
States.” The “die has been cast,” Gadahn said in the
tape, “(it’s) your end, not ours.”
In his first book, “Through Our Enemies’ Eyes: Osama
bin Laden, Radical Islam, and the Future of America,”
Scheuer, who speaks of the motives and determination
of radical Muslims to destroy America and the West,
argues that Americans must stop dismissing militant
Muslims as “extremists” or “religious fanatics” and
must see the enemy as they see themselves — highly
trained, motivated and enraged by what they see as the
West’s injustice and aggression. Scheuer says whatever
will happen to bin Laden, dangers by radical Islamists
will persist, and Americans must be prepared for a
long, protracted war against terrorism.
In his second book, “Imperial Hubris: Why the West is
Losing the War on Terror,” Scheuer listed a number of
Islamic grievances against the West: support for
Israel and indifference to Palestinians, presence of
troops in the Arabian Peninsula, occupation of Iraq
and Afghanistan, support of countries that oppress
Muslims (Russia, India, China), pressure to keep oil
prices low, support for dictatorships.
Editorial reviews in Amazon.com summarize Scheuer’s
thesis: America needs to “proceed with relentless,
brutal, and, yes, blood-soaked offensive military
actions until we have annihilated the Islamists who
threaten us.”
In “Iraq pullout not as easy as it sounds,” in the May
16 Pacific Daily News, I quoted John Dillin of the
Christian Science Monitor: “If this fight is worth
doing, if America truly has an unquestionable moral
imperative to win, then wage it with everything you’ve
got. Otherwise, why is America (in Iraq)?”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published June 20, 2007