Different world public opinion surveys show the United
States’ world standing is at a perhaps unprecedented
low level at a time when vigorous economic growth
rates are occurring, particularly in China, India, and
other Asian countries, and in many developing
countries in general.
The intensified decolonization process following World
War II brought about “the rise of the rest” in the
world as new political, economic, industrial,
financial players.
Australian Reg Little projects a “Confucian-Daoist”
millennium. Kevin Hassett acknowledges “China’s growth
as impressive” but cites a study that found “it may
well be at least 50 years before (China) catches up to
the U.S.” He argues, the U.S. economy continues to be
“positively awe-inspiring compared with the
competition.”
Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong of Singapore, who said
in his April 11 speech that the “whole continent” of
Asia is “on the move,” also cautioned, Asia’s journey
in the “direction of knowledge, scientific excellence
and innovation … will not always be a smooth
journey.”
“Not all Asian countries will effortlessly adapt” to
the new global environment, he said.
Environment of inquiry
The premier views China and India as having “deep
talent pools with huge numbers of extremely able and
bright people,” but Chinese and Indian universities
“have not yet succeeded in … (creating) the
environment of open inquiry and experimentation,
conducive to, and indeed essential for, cutting-edge
research and major breakthroughs.” Asian researchers
“have yet to win Nobel Prizes in the sciences, or
Fields Medals in mathematics.”
“The intellectual ferment and exchange required to
challenge great minds to do great things is not yet
there,” Loong affirmed.
In the May-June issue of Foreign Affairs Magazine,
Fareed Zakaria of Newsweek writes in “Is America in
Decline? Why the United States Will Survive the Rise
of the Rest,” that higher education is “the United
States’ best industry.”
The U.S. system “may be too lax when it comes to rigor
and memorization, but it is very good at developing
the critical faculties of the mind,” he writes.
Chinese delegations have gone to Singapore regularly
to study Singaporean management, as I wrote in this
space before. But Zakaria reminds us that Singaporean
officials also visited U.S. schools “to learn how to
create a system that nurtures and rewards ingenuity,
quick thinking, and problem-solving … to figure out
how to get their children to think.”
The United States remains “the most attractive
destination” for foreign students and takes in 30
percent of the total number of foreign students
globally, he says.
“What distinguishes economies today are ideas and
energy. A country can prosper if it is a source of
ideas or energy for the world,” he writes, and the
U.S. can continue to be the world’s most important
source of “new ideas, big and small, technical and
creative, economic and political,” but it “has to make
some significant changes.” “The test for the U.S. is
political,” he affirms.
He counsels Americans to recognize “the reality” that
in the 21st Century world, the distribution of power
other than military is “shifting, moving away from
U.S. dominance,” and the “post-America world” is
“defined and directed from many places and by many
people.”
There are “downsides” for America to having been “on
top for so long,” he says; the U.S. has not even
noticed that there is better cell-phone service and
faster and cheaper computer connectivity in “most of
the rest of the industrialized world.”
“Americans … have never developed the ability to
move into other people’s worlds,” Zakaria laments.
Accepting the U.S. economic problems as “real,” he
rejects they are the product of “deep inefficiencies”
within the economy or the reflection of a “cultural
decay,” but the “consequences of specific government
policies.”
The U.S. “has developed highly dysfunctional
politics.” Its political system of “shared power,
overlapping functions, and checks and balances” has
been “captured by money, special interests, a
sensational media, and ideological attack groups,”
producing “ceaseless, virulent debate about trivia —
politics as a theater — and very little substance,
compromise or action.”
“A can-do country is now saddled with a do-nothing
process, designed for partisan battle rather than
problem-solving,” Zakaria affirms. Yet, he reminds,
the U.S. system has been known to be “flexible,
resourceful, and resilient, able to correct its
mistakes and shift its attention.”
Immigration
The “United States’ advantages today are in large part
a product of immigration,” Zakaria says; the country
“is demographically vibrant.” Without immigration, the
U.S. GDP growth over the last quarter century would
have been the same as Europeans, he argues. It is the
United States that “is creating the first universal
nation, made up of all colors, races, and creeds,
living and working together in considerable harmony.”
“The United States’ potential new burst of
productivity, its edge in nanotechnology and
biotechnology, its ability to invent the future — all
rest on its immigration policies,” Zakaria writes.
The 25-page analysis concludes, “The world is
changing, but it is going the United States’ way. The
rest (of the world) that are arising are embracing
markets, democratic government (of some form or
another), and greater openness and transparency (a
world) in which American ideas and ideals are
overwhelmingly dominant.”
“The United States has a window of opportunity to
shape and master the changing global landscape, but
only if it first recognizes that the post-American
world is a reality,” Zakaria posits.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.