When English philosopher and leader of classic
conservatism Edmund Burke (1729-1797) spoke of
existing institutions and traditions as products of
hundreds of years of trial and error, and of society
as a partnership including “those who are living,
those who are dead, and those who are to be born,” he
also counseled that changes must be gradual, natural
and slow to avoid instability.
Burke is one of my favorite philosophers. His widely
quoted comment is, “All that is needed for the triumph
of evil is for good men to do nothing.”
On April 30, the New York Times’ front page presented
an article, “Abduction, Often Violent, a Kyrgyz
Wedding Rite,” from Bishkek, in central Asia’s
Kyrgyzstan, accompanied by a photo of lovely Ainur
Tairova, 28, who was kidnapped by several friends of a
man she had met a day before. The men duped her into
their car and drove her to the man’s house.
“I was angry and felt betrayed,” Tairova said, but she
married the man because once a woman is kept in a
man’s home overnight, she becomes a “tainted woman.”
A graduate student who helped kidnap a woman for his
brother was quoted by the Times, “Men steal women to
show that they are men.” A Kyrgyz maxim goes, “Every
good marriage begins in tears.”
The Times said more than half of Kyrgyzstan’s married
women were kidnapped from the street by their husbands
— who were following the “ala kachuu,” or “grab and
run,” custom — and surveys show an increase of
abductions in the last 50 years. At least a third of
Kyrgyzstan’s brides “are now taken against their
will.”
Many women “fight fiercely” against kidnapped
marriage, but some 80 percent of women kidnapped
eventually relent, often at their own parents’ urging.
The head of Kyzyl-Tuu village, near the capital,
kidnapped a 20-year-old university student who
“resisted for hours,” but she “stayed because I was
scared, not because I liked him.”
The custom, which dates back to the 12th century, was
illegal under the Soviet Union and then in the 1994
Kyrgyz criminal code, but most people don’t know this
and the law “rarely has been enforced,” the article
said.
Honor killings
On May 6, the Washington Post’s front-page article, “A
Killing Commanded by Tradition,” reported about a
25-year-old married Afghan woman, Amina, who was
discovered in her lover’s nearby hut and was sentenced
to death by neighbors in Badakhshan province. Amina’s
husband, from an arranged marriage, had been absent in
Iran for four years, and reportedly “had sent no word,
let alone money.”
While versions vary how Amina was killed, Amina’s
bruised corpse was returned to her parents. Villagers
were said to be “unanimous” that Islam dictates
Amina’s lover, an unmarried man, must be lashed and
Amina stoned to death. Her mother condemned her as a
“criminal and a sinner who brought dishonor on my
name.”
Her father’s original anger, however, gave way in time
to sorrow. He doubted not that Amina deserved to die,
“This is what Islam commands us.” But he regretted
that it was that villagers killed her, not him.
I searched the Internet for “honor killings” and found
more than I could read. The Feb. 12, 2002, National
Geographic News said, “Hundreds, if not thousands, of
women are murdered by their families each year in the
name of family ‘honor’.” It listed countries engaged
in the practice. An advocacy director of Human Rights
Watch said the practice “goes across cultures and
across religions;” an Amnesty International human
rights activist said, “Females in the family —
mothers, mothers-in-law, sisters and cousins —
frequently support” the killings. “It’s a community
mentality.”
Not in Koran
The article insisted, “There is nothing in the Koran
… that permits or sanctions honor killings.” It
quoted Pakistani professor of women’s issues, Tahira
Shahid Khan, who wrote in 1999: “Women are considered
the property of the males in their family irrespective
of their class, ethnic or religious group. The owner
of the property has the right to decide its fate.”
“Offenses” for honor killings include marital
infidelity, pre-marital sex, flirting or even failing
to serve a meal on time. Amnesty reported a husband
murdering his wife based on a dream that she had
betrayed him.
And so, we find ourselves in the 21st century, where
traditions persist, and life continues. Some
traditions, it would seem, are not worth keeping.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published June 15, 2005