Pacific Daily News readers who posted online asking
where the “moderate” Muslims are, why they have been
quiet, may not have read enough.
Born and raised a Muslim, I have written in this space
since Sept. 11, 2001, about Islam and radical Islam.
Had it not been for the struggle for Islam’s soul
between majority traditional Muslims, who believe and
practice Islam as a religion of peace, and the small
but growing numbers of radical Islamists, who chop
heads and limbs, bomb mosques, schools and markets, I
wouldn’t feel a need to write about Islam.
My God says: “You shall have your religion and I shall
have my religion” (109:6), and He instructs Prophet
Muhammad: “(O Muhammad) remind, for you are one to
remind, you are not their overlord” (80:21-22), and
“you are not to overawe them by force” (50:45).
As radical Islamists have hijacked Islam and speak in
Islam’s name, it is a tactical mistake to neglect
traditional Muslims, attack Islam, stereotype Muslims
as murderers, echo Islamists’ voices and views, and
thereby legitimize Islamists. It’s arrogant for
non-Muslims to claim to know the “true” faith of the
world’s fastest-growing religion better than the
believers, as if 1.5 billion Muslims are all nuts.
The Koran describes Muslims as “those who restrain
anger and pardon people; Allah loves the doers of good
(to others)” (3:134); and teaches, “when you hear
Allah’s verses rejected and mocked at (by people), do
not sit with them until they enter into some other
discourse” (4:140).
Last Sept. 18, I watched a Canadian feminist Muslim
speak on CBS’s “freeSpeech.” Born in Uganda to Muslim
parents of Egyptian and Indian descent, Irshad Manji
and family fled to Canada when she was 2, as Idi Amin
expelled South Asians. Her book, “The Trouble with
Islam Today: A Muslim’s Call for Reform in Her Faith”
is published in 25 languages.
As tension raged after Pope Benedict’s speech at
Regensburg University about a 14th century Byzantine
emperor’s castigation of Prophet Muhammad’s teaching
as “evil and inhuman,” Manji said on CBS, “As a
faithful Muslim, I do not believe the pope should have
apologized” for what he said, because, “Actually, he
called for dialogue with the Muslim world.”
“To ignore that larger context and to focus on a mere
few words of the speech is like reducing the Koran,
Islam’s holy book, to its most bloodthirsty passages,”
Manji declared. “We Muslims hate it when people do
that. The hypocrisy of doing this to the pope stinks
to high heaven.”
“Yet some Muslims have gone further,” Manji charged,
and cited West Bank churches being firebombed, the
London protesters’ banner “Islam will take Rome,” and
the Catholic nun who was murdered in Somalia.
“Coincidence? I think not,” she affirmed.
The Koran teaches Muslims to think, and “to reflect
far more than to retaliate,” she said; “God told the
Prophet Muhammad to ‘read.'” She urged Muslims to
“Read the pope’s speech — in its entirety — and
you’ll see that his message of reason, reconciliation
and conversation would make him a better Muslim than
most of us.”
Meanwhile, the March 1, 2006, National Review Online
published “A Muslim Manifesto” by Mustafa Akyol, a
writer and journalist based in Turkey, and Zeyno
Baran, a political economist at The Nixon Center. The
10-paragraph manifesto ends with “we strongly disagree
with and condemn those who promote or practice tyranny
and violence in the name of Islam.”
In the Dec. 30, 2005, Wall Street Journal’s “Right
Islam vs. Wrong Islam,” Abdurrahman Wahid, former
president of the world’s largest Muslim nation,
Indonesia, spoke of Osama bin Laden obtaining a
“religious verdict, … justifying the use of nuclear
weapons against America and the infliction of mass
casualties.”
Wahid asked, “Can anyone doubt that those who joyfully
incinerate the occupants of office buildings, commuter
trains, hotels and nightclubs would leap at the chance
to magnify their damage a thousandfold?” He asked the
world to “set aside our international and partisan
bickering, and join to confront the danger that lies
before us.”
In the May 23, 2006, Washington Post’s “Extremism
Isn’t Islamic Law,” Wahid posited that “Western
involvement in this ‘struggle for the soul of Islam’
is a matter of self-preservation for the West.”
Someone said people needed images of traditional
Muslims speaking out.
Frank J. Gaffney, Jr., who partnered with veteran
film-maker Martyn Burke to direct and produce “Islam
- Islamists: Voices from the Muslim Center” for the
Corporation for Public Broadcasting’s “America at a
Crossroads,” had sharp words for CPB in the Apr. 13
National Review Online’s “PBS at a Crossroads, Why is
a film on moderate Islam being suppressed?” and in the
April 30 Townhall.com’s “Where are the liberal
non-Muslims?”
The film wasn’t aired, because, Gaffney charged, CPB
judged it “unfair” to “conservative imams” and
Islamists, “shown denouncing, threatening and, in one
case, proposing to murder the moderate Muslims (in the
Gaffney and Burke) profile.”
Gaffney claimed the film “features compelling stories
of anti-Islamist Muslims who have had the courage to
stand up” to Islamists.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published May 9, 2007