Last week I presented in this space the “productive thinking” concept by Tim Hurson of a firm (www.thinkxic.com) that provides training, facilitation, and consultation in productive thinking and innovation to global corporations.

Hurson’s philosophy — that “your future will depend less on what you know and more on what you think,” and “it’s not what you know but how you think” – is summarized in five words: “Think better to do better.”

Hurson reminds his readers, as I quoted last week, that “truly focused thinking … is hard work.”

Really so hard that so few people are actually engaging in it? Reading the list of “mental activities” necessary for “focused thinking,” I can see why.

Earlier, I presented the philosophy, which I also espouse, from the Foundation of Critical Thinking (www.criticalthinking.org): “The quality of everything we do is determined by the quality of our thinking.”

Hence, the Foundation preaches “high-quality thinking”in order to attain a high-quality life.

Increasing each individual’s awareness of all that there is to learn, unlearn, and relearn to enable us to improve ourselves and for society to be at peace is what I have hoped to achieve through teaching and writing.

Martin Luther King Jr., advocate of direct action as a route to social change, asserted, “Nothing pains some people more than having to think,” and lamented it’s rare to find people “who willingly engage in hard, solid thinking.” His remarks were an outline of the imperative more fully expressed by Hurson and the Foundation.

Albert Einstein’s words, “Great ideas often receive violent opposition from mediocre minds,” reflects the common — and not inaccurate — view that humans are creatures of habit, or as Hurson repeats in his book, “Think Better,” that humans are “creatures of pattern.”

Hurson distinguishes between a “monkey mind” (a runaway mind like a troop of monkeys that cannot stay on one branch long and swing to another), a “gator brain” (a gator fights, flees, freezes as instinctive reactions to sensory input), and a “human brain” (cerebral cortex that allows rational thought and logic). He posits, “Human beings are far more skilled at following old patterns than at thinking new thoughts.”

Generally humans fear failure, have low tolerance for risk, are obsessed with “labels,” and constantly look for answers to remove “ambiguity” from their lives.

“Both biologically and socially, we are conditioned to jump to conclusions,” Hurson asserts.

Productive thinking

This is not productive thinking, which should have critical and creative components, he says. He calls it “reproductive” thinking, which is “essentially … repeating the past: doing what you’ve done before and thinking what you’ve (thought) before.” His advice: Don’t do this!

Hurson says “patterned thoughts box us in and hold us back from being as creative as we could be.” In other words, we become prisoners of patterning.

To illustrate how this is so, he suggests we imagine and draw the essential features of aliens from outer space to see how many draw aliens whose features include the conventional eyes, ears, mouth, legs we know exist on earth. That’s how conventional humans are.

Hurson asks what’s to prevent us from “imagining an energy creature, a vapor creature, a bodiless creature … and so on”? Indeed, humans would like “explanations.” But Hurson says it’s “okay with ambiguity (which) means being open to the possible.”

“Productive thinking requires us not to rush to answers but to hang back, to keep asking new questions, even when the answers to the old ones seem so clear, so obvious, so right,” and “to resist the urge to answer, the urge to know,” he said.

The irony of the urge to know is that it stops productive thinking cold: “People who ‘know’ can tell you all the things that can’t be done and why, … don’t need to learn because they already have the answers.” But, there’s a difference between knowingness and knowledge, he writes: “Knowingness is sealed; nothing can get in. Knowledge is open.

Knowingness sees challenge as a threat. Knowledge sees challenge as an opportunity. Knowingness is a portcullis that helps us feel secure. Knowledge is a road to new horizons.”

Knowing a lot is a good thing. But unless we can relate what we know so much about to other situations and events — or make those “unexpected connections” that form the heart of the productive thinking process — this knowledge is not as useful as it should be. I am a comparativist by training and by profession.

Hurson reminds us in his book “Stay in the Question” the difference between “settling on an answer” and “settling for an answer.” Not rushing to answers takes us to the “vast panorama of possible answers” as a “hundred billion neural connections” in the brain produce “ideas and inspirations and insights.”

The Foundation of Critical Thinking advises against “aimless thinking” and to ask only “essential questions” — not “peripheral” ones — for answers in “what is necessary, relevant, and indispensable to a matter at hand” that’s being examined.

It’s not knowingness or how much we know, but what and how we think that represent the “basics” to understanding and building a future that we can imagine.

A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the University of Guam, where he taught political science for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.

Originally published February 20, 2008