New York Times columnist Thomas Friedman, a critic of
Bush, pronounced June 13 in “Between Dust and
Deliverance,” that “bin Ladenism, and its various
jihadist offshoots” are “nothing more than a death
cult.” He talked about a suicide bomber attacking a
funeral procession for local contractor Allawi
al-Isawi and killing 27 people.
“A Muslim suicide bomber blew up a Muslim funeral. Is
there anything lower?” he asked. “But that is what bin
Laden and the jihadists have become: utter nihilists,
responsible for killing more Muslims than anyone in
the world today and totally uninterested in governing,
only in making life ungovernable.”
Why do people still use the words “Muslim suicide
bomber?” The world’s traditional Muslims would affirm
that suicide has no place in Islam; one who commits
suicide goes to hell. And I can’t see how a bomber who
explodes a bomb to kill so many is not called a
premeditated murderer; that’s what a murderer does.
What radical Islamists wanted is to give themselves
legitimacy.
The March 18 Chronicle Review’s “The Clash of
Civilizations” by University of Chicago professor
Martha C. Nussbaum observed, “While Americans have
focused on President Bush’s ‘war on terror,’ Iraq, and
the Middle East, democracy has been under siege” in
India where, until spring 2004, its parliamentary
government was controlled by “right-wing Hindu
extremists who condoned and in some cases actively
supported violence against minority groups, especially
Muslims.”
Nussbaum’s thesis is, the “real ‘clash of
civilizations’ is not between ‘Islam’ and ‘the West,’
but instead within virtually all modern nations —
between people who are prepared to live on terms of
equal respect with others who are different, and those
who seek the protection of homogeneity and the
domination of a single ‘pure’ religious and ethnic
tradition.” There is “a clash within the individual
self, between the urge to dominate and defile the
other and a willingness to live respectfully on terms
of compassion and equality, with all the vulnerability
that such a life entails.”
So, Western and non-Western nations need to examine
themselves, “looking for the roots of domination
within and devising effective institutional and
educational countermeasures.” Domination lies deep in
the “human personality,” she contends.
But, let’s return to Friedman. His May 2 column, “The
Hail Mary Pass,” speaks volumes. He suggested that
Bush address an Arab regional conference in Egypt by
acknowledging that he was sorry but that he “honestly
believed that Saddam had weapons of mass destruction”;
that Bush is “most sorry, though, because my bungling
of the war has prompted all of us to take our eye off
the ball. I messed up the treatment so badly that
people have forgotten the patient really does have a
disease.”
Friedman, knowledgeable about the people, culture and
politics in the Middle East, wanted Bush to admit to
mistakes and to tell Arabs “to stop fixating on me and
look at what is happening in your backyard: the forces
and pathologies that brought us 9/11 are still there
and multiplying.”
“Friends, we are losing in Iraq,” Friedman urged Bush
to say. “But whom are we losing to? … We are being
defeated by nihilistic Islamic suicide bombers, who
are proliferating across the Muslim world … who blow
up mosques, markets, hospital emergency wards and
girls’ schools . . . They will kill any number of
Muslims to ensure that we fail (in Iraq).”
He goes on to say that Bush needs to say, “You may
think that I’m more dangerous than bin Laden and that
a strong America is more dangerous than al-Qaida.
You’re wrong. If we are defeated in Iraq, they’ll come
after you. They already are. And if we’re defeated in
Iraq, you’ll no longer have to contend with a world of
too much American power. You’ll have to contend with a
world of too little American power. You will not like
it.”
Friedman wanted Bush to tell Arabs, “Don’t let your
anger with me blind you to your own interests”; to
tell Arab leaders, “get off the fence … the
alternative is much worse”; and to tell Europe, China
and Russia, “Get off the fence — I can’t stabilize
Iraq without your help. … But unless we — the world
of order — all pull together now, the forces of
disorder are going to have their way, and there is no
wall that will protect you.”
At a time when America’s reputation in the world sinks
low, Georgetown University’s Center for Strategic and
International Studies’s Michael J. Green’s “America’s
Quiet Victories in Asia,” in the Feb. 13 Washington
Post, argued that despite the setbacks in the Middle
East, America “has a winning hand in Asia and needs to
play it.”
He referenced the Association of South-East Asian
Nations’ new governing charter in Cebu, Philippines,
that speaks of “the active strengthening of democratic
values, good governance, rejection of unconstitutional
and undemocratic changes of government, the rule of
law, and respect for human rights and fundamental
freedoms” as necessary for building peace and
stability.
He sees this “Asian embrace of democracy” as America’s
“greatest source of soft power,” and urges America not
abandon her commitment to supporting democracy there.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published June 27, 2007