I have received unsolicited e-mails from someone
familiar from Guam. One arrived in my box on Election
Day, entitled “Double Outhouse and Props 5,” with
three words — “This is timely!” — to introduce a
photo, and an ending — “This pretty much says it
all.”
At quick glance, I thought it was about the sender’s
humor, but I decided it wasn’t.
Earlier that same morning, before I went the election
precinct to vote, I sipped my coffee at breakfast and
commented to my spouse, “Whoa, you oughta read this!”
I read aloud part of the Washington Post’s “America’s
Crisis of Confidence, Survey Finds Doubts About
Leaders, and Nation’s Safety,” which was about a new
study, “National Leadership Index 2006,” sponsored by
the U.S. News and World Report and Harvard
University’s Kennedy School of Government’s Center for
Public Leadership.
“Americans have lost faith in the people who lead
their federal, state and local governments, and in
businesses, churches and schools,” the Post’s article
reads. “America is in trouble,” the newspaper quoted
the Leadership Index study, and listed findings that
place the “press” at the bottom of the public
confidence list at 2.38 on a scale of 1 (no
confidence), to 4, (a great deal of confidence).
That’s below the executive branch at 2.54 and the
Congress at 2.55. Ranked highest on the list is the
military, at 3.18, followed by the medical leadership
at 3.08 — a little more than “moderate amount of
confidence.”
After the vote, I went to Google, read and learned.
According to the leadership index report, more than
seven in 10 Americans across the United States “agree
or agree strongly” that there is a “leadership crisis”
in America today. Last year, nearly three-quarters of
Americans said, “unless our leaders improve, the U.S.
would decline as a nation.”
Director of the Center for Public Leadership David
Gergen said the American public is “even more critical
of the nation’s leaders in 2006” than after last
year’s failures of Katrina and “fear for the country’s
future.” Todd Pittinsky of the Kennedy School of
Government, who analyzed the leadership index data,
affirmed the American people “have high expectations
for their leaders,” who are found in “many critical
areas” to be “falling short of the mark.”
The leadership index says Americans are most critical
of their leaders’ “ethics” — only 38 percent see
today’s leaders as having high ethical standards; and
nine out of 10 Americans see their leaders as spending
“too much time attacking members of the other party.”
I connected the dots and appreciated the depth of the
“double outhouse” e-mail, and perhaps the very feeling
of the sender as well. The photo in the e-mail is a
roofed wooden two-story outhouse, with a ladder on one
side leading from the ground to a stand that separates
the top structure from the lower one. A sign on the
upper door reads “Politicians,” and the sign on the
bottom structure reads “Voters.” Gross, but
meaningful.
On Nov. 7, the American voters gave their verdict.
Many turned out at the polls and voted to give the
House to the Democrats, and the Senate, too.
While the Nov. 9 Washington Post’s “Election ’06”
reported “After minutes upon minutes of
soul-searching, Republicans are now in recrimination
mode,” in “Republicans’ Angry Factions Point Fingers
At Each Other.” The Post’s editorial, “The ‘Thumping’
of the GOP,” notes how President George W. Bush and
future House speaker, Rep. Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.),
said many of “the right things” immediately after the
elections and suggests “the greatest opportunities for
real bipartisan cooperation may involve not Iraq but
domestic issues, including a comprehensive immigration
compromise.
It’s hard not to hear the people’s voice.
Another Post editorial, “A Better Way,” quoted Rep.
Harold E. Ford Jr.’s concession speech in his failed
Democratic bid for the U.S. Senate, pleading for a
bettering of the American political process: “What
people want more than anything and what I heard and I
know candidates all around the country heard … (was)
a hunger, and they sensed a great appetite on the part
of the American people for something much better and
far more dignified and greater than what we’d given
them.”
The Post concluded, “Once the votes are counted,
memories fade — until the next election cycle. Mr.
Ford laid out a challenge to both the winners and the
losers to figure out ‘a better way.’ That’s not a bad
start for a Democratic agenda.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published November 15, 2006