In December, I reviewed George F. Will’s “Academia, Stuck to the Left,” and the London Economist’s “America’s one-party state: If you loathe political debate, join the faculty of an American university.”
Both articles argued that America’s universities, theoretically committed to “diversity in race, skin color, ethnicity” and “sexual orientation,” are in fact under “liberal” or “leftist” domination that quashes non-liberal points of view.
On Jan. 28, the Los Angeles Times published an op-ed column, “The Left Loses College Kids,” by Brian C. Anderson of the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research, a conservative think tank. The column is a short version of “On Campus, Conservatives Talk Back,” published in the Winter 2005 City Journal quarterly.
Anderson claimed that “the left’s long dominion over the university — the last place on Earth that the left’s power would break up … is beginning to loosen.” He says the change is not coming from the faculty (of whom Democrats outnumber Republicans at least 7 to 1 in the humanities and social sciences) or the administrators, but from the “self-organizing right-of-center students themselves.”
“Never has the right flourished among college kids as it does today,” he asserted.
Anderson pointed out that the surge of student protests that roiled American campuses throughout 2003 and into 2004 was not against the Iraq war; and that students at UCLA, Michigan, and many other schools sponsored “bake sales to protest … affirmative action,” which they see as rewarding people “differently based on race.”
Anderson presented statistics that showed college Republicans have tripled their chapter representation on campuses, from about 400 campus chapters six years ago to 1,148 today, with 120,000-plus members (compared with the college Democrats’ 900 chapters with 100,000 members). In 1995, UCLA’s Higher Education Research Institute reported 66 percent of freshmen wanted the wealthy to pay higher taxes, while only 50 percent do today. Two-thirds of students in the early 1990s supported abortion while just over half do today.
He referred to the late-2003 Harvard Institute of Politics study that showed college students “had moved to the right of the overall population,” with 31 percent identifying themselves as Republicans, 27 percent Democrats and the rest independent.
University of Pennsylvania professor Alan Kors was quoted speaking about “a natural and healthy tendency” among students to question their teachers’ piety — the “pieties, dogmas and set of assumptions being taught on college campuses” that have been found to emanate from the far left “for so long.”
According to Anderson, “the leftism that so angers students includes the ‘hey ho, Western civ has got to go’ theories that inform college courses from coast to coast.”
A Harvard junior, Jordan Hylden, reportedly said that a student “who doesn’t buy” into “the West-is-the worst” line can have “an awful time” in school because “only the ‘right’ … ideas get a hearing.”
Anderson claimed some conservative students “keep their real views to themselves and parrot the ‘correct’ line, fearing that otherwise they’ll get a low grade.”
He quoted a Princeton freshman about his term paper: “I radically altered my position to make it more in line with what my professor’s beliefs are on (same-sex marriage) and many others.”
But have conservatives and right-wing faculty not engaged in similar methods, and have liberal students not kept their real views to themselves, as well?
Anderson said a 2003 Independent Women’s Forum survey found that anywhere from one-quarter to one-third of students had felt forced to check “their intellectual and philosophical honesty at the door in order to get good grades.” He used an American Council of Trustees and Alumni’s survey that found “half of all students — not just conservatives — at the top 50 colleges” say professors “frequently inject their political views into courses, and almost one-third think they have to agree with those views to get a good grade.”
Whatever happened to the university as a marketplace of ideas?
Anderson says today’s “professoriate remains a solidly left-wing body … and nothing is going to change that soon.”
On Feb. 1, the Times published letters from readers on Anderson’s column. Marlene Dempster from Ventura wrote: “Does it occur to (Anderson) and the born-again reactionaries on our campuses that those liberal professors are liberal because they’re intellectual?”
A.Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., retired from the University of Guam where he taught political science for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published March 16, 2005