After three years, eight months and 20 days of the Khmer Rouge’s brutal rule,
during which 1.7 million Cambodians lost their lives, the signing of
the 1991 Paris Peace Accords offered Cambodia and her people a respite
from suffering and the destruction, and the promise of a bright future.
The Paris Conference’s Final Act, signed on Oct. 23, 1991, by
representatives of 18 governments (Australia, Brunei, Cambodia, Canada,
China, France, India, Indonesia, Japan, Laos, Malaysia, the
Philippines, Singapore, Thailand, Soviet Union, United Kingdom, United
States, and Vietnam with the participation of officials from Zimbabwe
and Yugoslavia representing the non-aligned movement and the United
Nations Secretary-General and his representative) contains a
comprehensive political settlement of the Cambodian conflict: a
settlement that provides for a constitution based on democratic
principles; the recognition of the sovereignty, independence,
territorial integrity and inviolability, neutrality and national unity
of Cambodia; and provisions for the rehabilitation and reconstruction
of the country.
The accords offered a foundation for liberal democracy and for human rights and freedom of the Cambodian people.
But the accords are only words on paper. Short of implementation, they are all but meaningless.
Liberal democracy and rights and freedoms do not appear automatically. Man has
to work to bring them about. The creation of a framework incorporating
three branches of government with limits on the powers of each does not
mean a system of checks and balances is established — not if, in spite
of their institution, one man or group of men dominates, influences,
pulls strings from above.
Take the case of today’s Cambodian system of government. James Madison would
call it “tyranny” because one man, Hun Sen, the chief executive, and a
group of men, the Cambodian People’s Party, his party, control all
three branches of government, making a mockery of international norms
for an independent legislature and judiciary.
Following the signing of the accords, there were lavish self-congratulations and
the touting of Cambodia’s transformation as a “success story.” Yet, the
Cambodian People’s Party, brought to power by Vietnam’s 1978 military
invasion, and propped up, since the 1979 routing of Pol Pot by
Vietnam’s troops, busily built its party power structures, organization
and discipline, and forcefully pushed party interests ahead of the
nation’s interest.
The first UN-supervised 1993 general elections gave the mandate to govern
to the democratically elected victor, Prince Norodom Ranariddh, but the
CPP and Sen demanded that Sen, who lost the elections, be made co-prime
minister of Cambodia, and that existing governing state institutions be
co-governed.
And so, the country had a two-headed government, two armies, two systems,
two policies. The 1997 military coup launched by Sen killed many and
sent Ranariddh and his loyalists fleeing the country. This happened
before the eyes of state signatories of the accords and of the United
Nations.
American civil rights leader Martin Luther King Jr. said: “The ultimate tragedy
is not the oppression and cruelty by the bad people but the silence
over that by the good people.” And British political philosopher Edmund
Burke said: “All that is needed for the triumph of evil is for good men
to do nothing.”
Nearly 18 years after the accords, Cambodia has not become a liberal democracy
nor do her people enjoy fundamental rights and freedoms. The failure
has been a collective one, with Cambodians unable to work together and
signatory governments’ Cambodia fatigue leading them to want a
semblance of political stability, even if they must turn a blind eye to
rights violations.
It’s in human nature in general to deny one’s culpability in an unpleasant
situation and to blame others for it. Yet each day that passes is one
more day too many for the Cambodian people and their country to be
denied what the accords promised.
Furthermore, an issue that could result in a hot war between Cambodian and Thai
troops, neighbors to the west, over the Preah Vihear temple, has been
left unsolved as soldiers eyeball each other, their fingers on the
trigger, separated by only a few hundred yards. The accords’ signatory
states agreed to the maintenance, preservation and defense of
Cambodia’s sovereignty, territorial integrity and national unity. What
does a bubbling conflict mean to them?
For the moment, absent open warfare, the world is content to let Cambodia
remain under the control of a corrupt dictator. Still, in an
authoritarian atmosphere, stable commerce cannot be expected to
flourish; the economy will continue to benefit the few and consign the
majority to the poverty that has become their norm.
There cannot be liberal democracy where fundamental rights and freedoms are
not allowed. Innovation must be encouraged. “Outside the box” thinking
must flourish; people must have the hope that the power to improve
their circumstances is within their grasp.
After Cambodians learn to reconcile with one another, unlearn a culture that
harbors generational memories of slights and disrespect, and move
forward with self confidence, they may recall Buddha’s teachings and
practice them. At that juncture, the world community may feel it is in
its interest to renew a commitment made long ago to Cambodia and her
people.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the University of Guam, where
he taught political science for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.