The May 31 Christian Science Monitor editorial, “Young U.S. Muslims: a threat?” finds non-Muslims’ reaction to the Pew Research Center’s survey results of America’s Muslims — the survey I examined in the May 30 Pacific Daily News — not helpful to America’s national security.
Pew finds “1 in 4 Muslims ages 18-29 lend some degree of support to suicide bombings to defend Islam,” but Pew researchers said they don’t know if it’s a factor “of age, of influence, of Palestinian sympathy, of disenfranchised African-American Muslims — who make up 20 percent of the Muslim public.”
The Monitor noted some media has accused Pew of “burying a troubling headline” of Muslim support for suicide bombing.
“This youthful empathy for suicide bombing … is a measure of attitude and not behavior,” posited the Monitor, and “Muslims identify with their religion about the same as American Christians do theirs” – 47 percent of Muslims identify themselves as “Muslim first” (28 percent as “American first”); 42 percent of American Christians also identify their Christian faith first.
“America needs its Muslims … for the richness they bring” and “as allies in reporting and discouraging violent Islam,” said the Monitor. It notes 76 percent of American Muslims are concerned about the worldwide rise of Islamic extremism.
“The last thing non-Muslims should do is stir up anti-Muslim sentiment and fear by parading one statistic on youths’ attitude,” said the Monitor.
Two days earlier, the May 29 Monitor’s “Bull’s-eye for amateur book critics” by A.B. Curtiss referenced “vilipendious … amateur critics whose time has come” thanks to “the ease of firing off a sentence or two on the Web” to malign bestselling authors and Pulitzer Prize winners “in five seconds.”
I wrote before in this space about the high-tech era’s “quick finger disease,” when fingers pound on a keyboard faster than the brain can think, and a “ping!” deposits a message on the Web: Voila, a writer’s value or ignorance for the world to see!
Curtiss, author of nine books and a board-certified cognitive behavioral therapist, said her “first negative review on Amazon.com felt like a dagger to the heart” as she was used to wonderful letters from readers, and now she gets insults from some who think they’re “bona fide literary critics — whether they’ve read the book or not.”
But, “it’s actually fun to read the ridiculous (reviews) aloud to disbelieving friends.” Reviews without a little “dissenting vitriol” are like “‘American Idol’ without Simon Cowell,” said Curtiss, who ended her column with, “Go ahead, make my day!”
Read a lot and learn more; that’s how we grow. Each of us has ideas, but there are ideas and ideas.
On May 28, I logged on to read what was in the liberal Slate.com Online, and then moved on to the conservative Townhall.com Online. There I read “Why Bin Laden Wants Us To Fail In Iraq.” But what captured my attention was the volume of comments on the article. That many don’t like the author doesn’t surprise me — conventionally, liberals and conservatives don’t like what the others say.
When some commentators ridiculed the conservative author’s “passionate” defense of “his” religion, Islam, I Googled to verify if the man had changed “his” religion. No, he hasn’t. He is a Roman Catholic, born in India, and his name is Dinesh D’Souza.
Some people rush to judgment, knowing little or nothing. Maybe criticizing others makes them feel good. A column in the May 24 Washington Post Metro Section, “Free Speech? Not if You Hurt Their Feelings,” is illustrative of what may be a shifting definition of free speech, something that should give each of us pause.
The “I Stand for Israel” T-shirt worn by Mia Lazarus offended the cashier at the University of Maryland’s student union’s co-op shop. She was told to find another cashier in the back for service. There, she was served.
Some called for a boycott of the co-op. An “hours-long, teary meeting” of students from both sides produced the co-op’s statement that it “respects the right of an individual worker or volunteer … to choose not to act as an agent of the store” – a client may find another clerk to service.
Store personnel and students on both sides are satisfied with the arrangement. Gretchen Metzelaars, the university’s student union director, is not. The co-op rents space from the university, it must “abide by the university’s human rights code” – no discrimination based on age, sex, race, and political beliefs.
Metzelaars says students “can’t see that this is discrimination” as “they’re more committed to their righteousness than they are to the rights of other people. The fact is, you have to serve everyone.”
The co-op thought OK, “but if someone came in wearing a swastika, we wouldn’t serve them.” Metzelaars responded, “Whoa! That’s the problem right there: Everyone gets to say what they believe, and you have to serve them.” She told the co-op if discrimination continues, it will have 60 days to vacate the union.
Are we in a world in which more are quick to judge with little or no knowledge, and with members accepting life and living, so long as feelings are not hurt?
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published June 6, 2007