Disagreements abound on how the United States should

deal with Iraq. Before the Jan. 31 Iraqi election,

former secretaries of state Henry A. Kissinger,

1973-1977, and George P. Shultz, 1982-1989, rejected

an “exit strategy” in a Washington Post article,

“Results, Not Timetables, Matter in Iraq.”

 

Sen. Ted Kennedy, on the other hand, told an audience

at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International

Studies that immediately after the election, President

George W. Bush should have started bringing U.S.

troops home, with 12,000 to leave at once and a

complete withdrawal effected by 2006.

 

In an interview with NBC’s Tim Russert on Jan. 30,

Sen. John Kerry disagreed with Kennedy.

 

The Feb. 2 New York Times editorial said it is

“exactly the wrong moment” to set “fixed

troop-withdrawal targets, as some Democrats now

propose.”

 

The Bush administration has said it wants U.S. troops

home as soon as Iraqi security forces can be trained

and ready to take over, and a constitutional

government is functioning. The Iraqis, too, have said

they want self-government and U.S. troops to go home

as soon as Iraqis are ready.

 

Responding to Bush’s State of the Union address, House

Democratic Leader Nancy Pelosi said the United States

cannot stay in Iraq indefinitely, nor should it “slip

out the back door.” She offered a “credible plan” to

transfer responsibility to the Iraqis by training the

Iraqi army, accelerating Iraq’s economic development

and intensifying regional diplomacy.

 

But what is the difference between Pelosi’s Democratic

plan and Bush’s plan, except that Bush is in the White

House?

 

A USA TODAY/CNN/Gallup Poll released on Feb. 8, with a

margin error of plus or minus 3 percentage points,

said 55 percent of Americans now believe the U.S. made

no mistake sending troops to Iraq, up from 47 in

January. The poll put Bush’s approval rating at 57

percent, up from a CBS/New York Times poll that

recorded 49 percent last month.

 

A critic of Bush’s Middle East policies, Times

columnist Thomas Friedman, wrote on Feb. 3 that the

Iraqi election has made clear the Iraq war is now

between the “fascist insurgents” and the Iraqi people,

and that it’s “not about Mr. Bush anymore. It’s about

the aspirations of the Iraqi majority to build an

alternative to Saddamism.” Friedman argued that

Americans cannot fight this war, but Arab progressives

can tell the suicide bombers they are bringing shame

to Islam. Friedman called insurgent leader al-Zarqawi

“Charles-Manson-with-a-turban,” the leader of “a

murderous death cult.”

 

In “Should We Stay or Should We Go?” in the Jan. 19

New York Times, Frederick Barton and Bathsheba

Crocker, co-directors of the Post-Conflict

Reconstruction Project at the Center for Strategic and

International Studies, and Craig Cohen, a researcher,

presented three situations under which U.S. troops

could withdraw from Iraq.

 

One, the U.S. achieves its goals and leaves triumphant

— which appears “impossible” now; two, Iraqi leaders

ask U.S. troops to leave, which is unlikely if the

U.S. is guaranteeing their security; and three, the

U.S. leaves Iraq in chaos but spins it as a win, which

would discredit America at home and abroad.

 

Barton, Crocker and Cohen then suggested: “Why not let

the Iraqis themselves decide” if foreign soldiers

should withdraw immediately and what the absence of

U.S. forces will mean for Iraqi families and nation?

“Tell them” the U.S. will hold referendums “every nine

months until they vote us out or we determine it’s

time to leave.”

 

This would affirm U.S. commitment to

self-determination; show that democratic

participation, not violence, is Iraq’s best chance at

full political independence; could help avert a civil

war; would give the U.S. “a mandate in Iraq” if Iraqis

vote for U.S. troops to remain; and would give the

U.S. an exit strategy.

 

A U.S. withdrawal after a referendum “would signal a

willingness to engage with Iraq as an ally rather than

an occupier,” they argued.

 

“Now It’s Up to Iraqis,” by Washington Post Columnist

David Ignatius, called on Shiite leaders to reassure

non-voting Sunnis and other minorities that they are

“equal citizens in the new Iraq,” and advised a

“delicate balance” of a gradual U.S. military

disengagement and an increase in the numbers and

confidence of Iraqi security forces.

 

And what do you think?

A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., retired from the

University of Guam where he taught political science

for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.

 

Originally published February 23, 2005