British historian and Harvard professor Niall Ferguson
wrote in the Feb. 26 Los Angeles Times’ article, “Why
our enemies — and friends — hate us,” that Americans
“really hate not knowing why they’re hated,” though
the simplest explanation is, “Being hated is what
happens to dominant empires.”
Empires, as seen in Robert D. Kaplan’s book, “Imperial
Grunts: The American Military on the Ground,” are
“works in progress, with necessity rather than glory
the instigator of each outward push.” They “expand by
happenstance, impelled forward by a succession of
security threats, real or imagined.”
Ferguson noted that it’s common to think that people
in a state attacked by America hate her most, but
polls show it’s not them who hate America most — it’s
people in friendly or allied countries, who do.
International editor Fareed Zakaria’s Feb. 26 Newsweek
article, “Hassle and Humiliation,” about the 2005 Arab
and American Action Forum, explains how a bungling use
of soft power sinks America’s honor.
The forum, the brainchild of former President Bill
Clinton, Jordan’s King Abdullah and Dubai’s ruler,
Sheikh Monhammed Al Maktoum, brought 100 young Arab
leaders from all walks of life to meet their American
counterparts “to begin a dialogue, build trust and
create joint projects for both peoples.”
As the young Arab leaders landed at John F. Kennedy
Airport, Homeland Security officials pulled the first
group of “mostly CEOs of large companies” out of
immigration lines, “made (them) stand for two to five
hours” and “grilled” them about why they came to
America, if they had experience with weapons, what
they thought of the Iraq war,” etc.
Zakaria wrote, “Half a day into their trip, before
they had even left the airport, they were angry and
humiliated. So much for improving America’s image in
the Arab world.”
He recalled how the “reality” of the America he
visited as a kid in the 1970s refuted America’s
enemies’ “propaganda and caricatures … but today,
through inattention, stupidity and bureaucratic
cowardice, the caricature is becoming a reality.”
The Feb. 23 Christian Science Monitor’s “The myth of
Muslim support for terror,” by Kenneth Ballen, founder
of Terror Free Tomorrow, a nonpartisan, nonprofit
group seeking policies that draw support away from
global terrorists, contrasted a Dec. 2006 survey by
the University of Maryland’s prestigious Program on
International Policy Attitudes with the TFT’s 2006
polling results from the most populous Muslim nations
of Indonesia, Pakistan, Bangladesh and Nigeria.
PIPA found “only 46 percent” of Americans surveyed see
bombing and attacks “intentionally aimed at civilians”
as “never justified” and 24 percent believe these
attacks are “often and sometimes justified,” but TFT
found 74 percent of respondents in Indonesia, 86
percent in Pakistan and 81 percent in Bangladesh see
terrorist attacks as “never justified.”
It’s understandable why polls show “nearly half of
Westerners associate Islam with violence and Muslims
with terrorists,” given that many Muslim radicals
“commit violence in the name of Islam around the
world,” but Ballen warned that stereotyping Muslims
and their religion, “affirmed by simplistic media
coverage and many radicals themselves … are
detrimental to the war on terror.”
“When the West wrongly attributes radical views to all
of the world’s 1.5 billion Muslims, it perpetuates a
myth that has the very real effect of marginalizing
critical allies in the war on terror,” he wrote.
Ballen’s TFT’s 20-plus 2005-2006 surveys in Muslim
countries show another surprise: Among the minority of
Muslims who support terrorism and bin Laden, “most
overwhelmingly approved of specific American actions
in their own countries” — 71 percent of bin Laden
supporters in Indonesia and 79 percent in Pakistan
“thought more favorably of America” thanks to her
“humanitarian assistance in their countries.”
“Muslims reject terrorism as much if not more than
Americans,” Ballen explained, and even sympathizers
with “radical ideology can be won over by positive
American actions that promote goodwill and offer real
hope.” America’s isolation of terrorists from other
Muslims should start with “recognizing that Muslims
…want peace as much as Americans do.”
The Feb. 20 Monitor’s “Global poll: There is no ‘clash
of civilizations'” on the Dec.-Jan. global survey of
some 28,000 people across 27 Muslim and Christian
nations (with a plus-minus 2.5 to 4 percent margin of
error, conducted by GlobeScan international polling
firm and PIPA for the BBC World Service) rejected the
“inevitable” clash theory between Islam and the West.
In the poll, 58 percent said “intolerant minorities”
on both sides create tensions; an overall 52 percent
of Muslims say it’s possible to find “common ground”
between Islam and the West — a belief that rises with
education, from 46 percent among those with no formal
education to 64 percent, with post secondary
education.
For world peace, we should review conventional
thoughts and facts.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published March 7, 2007