Cindy Sheehan, the “anti-war” California mom who lost
her son, Casey, in Iraq, summed up in her May 28
letter on the Web, “Good-bye America … you are not
the country that I love,” by charging, “Democrats and
Republicans play politics with human lives,” while her
son, “Casey died (in Iraq) for a country which cares
more about who will be the next American Idol,” and
has a “peace movement that often puts personal egos
above peace and human life.”
In early May, a USA Today/Gallup poll found six in 10
Americans surveyed wanted a timetable to withdraw
American troops from Iraq, regardless of what happens.
A Washington Post-ABC News poll published in the front
page of the June 5 Post, “Discontent Over Iraq
Increasing, Poll Finds. Americans Also Unhappy With
Congress,” showed President George W. Bush’s
job-approval rating at 35 percent, Congress’s
job-approval at 39 percent (down from 44 percent), and
73 percent of Americans surveyed said the United
States is “pretty seriously on the wrong track.”
Briton Gerard Baker wrote in the May 25 Times Online
that America is “in the grip of an unrelieved gloom
about its condition” and noted that “Once Americans
get into a funk, there really is no stopping them.”
But, Baker posited, America has recovered before,
“thanks to good leadership and the ingenuity of a
people whose great gift is their constant capacity to
recreate themselves.”
He asks: An inept president notwithstanding, “Who’s
betting (America) won’t do so again?”
It’s hard to miss the June 11 Newsweek cover story,
“After Bush, How to Restore America’s Place in the
World,” by Fareed Zakaria, the international editor of
the magazine that reaches 25 million readers
worldwide.
With Bush out of the Oval Office as president and
commander-in-chief in 19 months, Zakaria reasons, “We
must begin to think about life after Bush. … There
is a world beyond Iraq.”
He wrote: “For those who look at the future and see
challenges, competition and threats, keep in mind that
this new world has been forming over the last 20
years, and the United States has forged ahead amid all
the turmoil. To recover its place in the world,
America first needs to recover its confidence.”
America’s existing strengths and qualities place her
still “on top of the world,” says Zakaria, but this
same America, seen by the outside world “as too
arrogant, uncaring and insensitive,” has become “a
nation consumed by fear, worried about terrorists and
rogue nations, Muslims and Mexicans, foreign companies
and free trade, immigrants and international
organizations.”
Zakaria sees Americans’ need to “tackle the
consequences of our foreign policy of fear” — with
Republicans “whipping up hysteria” and Democrats
fearing not being seen as “tough.”
Democratic presidential candidates vowed “to attack,
retaliate and blast the hell out of, well, somebody,”
in response to another terror strike — even if there
are problems determining what are the “right targets”
to strike.
In the Sunday Post of June 3, “The ‘Blame The Iraqis’
Gambit,” a senior associate at the Carnegie Endowment
for International Peace, neocon Robert Kagan, writes
that people who “want to justify the unjustifiable and
accept the unacceptable … try all kinds of ways to
make themselves feel better about their decision.”
Whether “Bush lied us into war” as Democrats are fond
to say, or “Bush screwed up the war” as others and
Kagan himself say, “both of these excuses” tell us
nothing “about what to do now” in Iraq, Kagan argues.
This takes us to the June 3 Post editorial, “After the
Surge,” with its smaller caption, “It’s time for the
president and Congress to begin talking about a
smaller, more sustainable mission in Iraq.
“As painful and costly as the war in Iraq has been,
the United States stands to lose far more if it simply
abandons a country in the heart of the Middle East and
hands a victory to al-Qaida and other extremists,”
editorializes the Post, a critic of the Bush
administration.
Although the Post sees the administration’s “South
Korea” analogies as “misleading in some ways,” it
believes it “makes sense” for Bush to start focusing
the Iraq debate “on the need for an American presence”
beyond the current surge of troops in Baghdad and
beyond his own administration to a new one.
The Post editorial calls for establishing a new
American “mission that will be materially and
politically sustainable” and says, “Now is the time
for Congress and the Bush administration to begin
talking about what that mission should be.”
The Post endorses the Baker-Hamilton plan as the “best
formula” for a White House-Congress consensus: gradual
withdrawal of most U.S. combat troops, refocusing the
mission on training the Iraqi army, fighting al-Qaida,
and defending Iraq from neighbors’ incursions.
Americans want America’s sons and daughters fighting
in Iraq home now, but the public will likely not see
an incoming president of the United States, even a
Democratic president, pull American troops out “lock,
stock and barrel.” While this is not logistically
possible, America’s national interests seen from the
inside of the Oval Office place more constraints on a
president — more than he or she sees during a
presidential campaign.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published June 13, 2007