The controversy over the cartoons of Prophet Muhammad
published on Sept. 30, 2005, in Denmark’s
Jyllands-Posten is not going away. Muslim protesters
say they are defending the honor of the prophet. Some
have vowed to behead offenders of Islam.
Yet the Koran opens with “In the name of Allah, the
beneficent, the merciful.”
The prophet’s recorded customs, the Sunna, a basis for
the sharia, are known. Jamil Momand’s “What would
Muhammad do?” in the Feb. 9 Los Angeles Times tells
how Muhammad negotiated a treaty with Arabs who were
at war with him by not insisting that his title,
“prophet,” be placed in the document.
Faiza Saleh Ambah tells how a Saudi teacher counsels
calm to angry students in the Feb. 8 Washington Post.
Muhammad, who was bleeding and injured after being
stoned by young men in Taif didn’t exact revenge on
them because he “never returned an insult with an
insult” and “would not have been happy” to see
violence by Muslims.
Gregory Rodriguez’s, “No such thing as free speech,”
in the Feb. 12 Los Angeles Times reminds that neither
we nor the Danes live in a perfect world. Daniel
Schorr says, “Rights are best defended when employed
responsibly” and recalls Supreme Court Justice Wendell
Holmes’ 1919 ruling that the First Amendment does not
protect a man falsely shouting “fire” in a crowded
theater. In “Balancing freedom and responsibility,” in
the Feb. 10 Christian Science Monitor, Schorr
concluded, “Maybe a cartoon that may inflame millions
should be described but not shown, as a matter of
judgment and taste.”
But William Kristol’s “Oh, the Anguish!” in the Feb.
12 Weekly Standard reproduced the original Danish
illustrations and mocked a U.N. statement that “The
anguish in the Muslim world at the publication of the
offensive caricature is shared by all individuals and
communities who recognize the sensitivity of deeply
held religious belief.”
The “anguish” was phony, says Kristol. If not, when
Egypt’s major paper, Al Fagr, reprinted the cartoons
on Oct. 17, 2005, “Tens of millions of Egyptians”
would have been “so tormented” they would have
attacked Israel, slaughtered foreign businessmen and
destroyed the “pagan Sphinx” — and Egypt’s President
Mubarak would have tossed back “his $2 billion in
‘infidel’ U.S. foreign aid.”
Hassan M. Fattah’s “At Mecca Meeting, Cartoon Outrage
Crystallized,” in the Feb. 9 New York Times, described
how Danish Islamists lobbied Arab ambassadors, who in
turn lobbied Arab governments in October, to oppose
the cartoons. But, as the deputy director of the Ahram
Center for Political and Strategic Studies in Cairo
said, “It was no big deal until the Islamic
conference” in Mecca in December when Muslim leaders
decided to express “concern at rising hatred against
Islam and Muslims and condemned (the) … desecration”
of Muhammad’s image.
Harvard Law School fellow Emran Qureshi’s “The Islam
the Riots Drowned Out,” in the Feb. 12 New York Times,
presents the “cartoon imbroglio” as providing
ammunition to “two entrenched forces for censorship”
— authoritarian Arab regimes that divert attention
from their failures and Islamic fundamentalists who
seek to oust them.
The Feb. 8 USA Today’s “Cartoons spark an uproar,
radicals fan the flames” editorializes that “radical
Muslims have exploited (the cartoons) to ignite
anti-Western violence across the Muslim world.”
“Middle Eastern governments” used the clashes “as a
way to hold back pressure for democratic change.”
In the Feb. 15 New York Times’ “The Islam Gap,”
Indonesian lawyer and author Karim Raslan sees “anger
and violence (as) self-defeating” and the Middle
East’s “extensive violence and ugly rhetoric” as
revealing the “differences between the Arab-Muslim
heartland and the Indo-Malay periphery.” Despite a
“sense of solidarity” with Arab co-religionists, “the
explosiveness of the Arab street doesn’t translate,
somehow, to the tropics,” where Muslims “have a
growing suspicion that we are culturally different
from our Arabic- and Urdu-speaking brethren, perhaps
more tolerant and less emotional.”
Raslan sees as the region’s moderates Malay Premier
Badawi and Indonesian President Yudhoyono, both of
whom criticized the cartoons but did not yield to
“hotheads in both countries” who wanted to end
relations with Denmark.
The Feb. 12 Reuters reported Northwestern University
religion professor Ruediger Seesemann’s view that it
is “not the image” of Muhammad that is the problem,
“but the way it has been published — as a terrorist
with a turban shaped like a bomb.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published February 22, 2006