President George W. Bush’s October speech at the
National Endowment for Democracy was dubbed by the
Christian Science Monitor as outlining the “battle of
the 21st century.” He described a “comprehensive
strategy” to deal with Islamic radicals’ “murderous
ideology” by answering a “global campaign of fear with
a global campaign of freedom.”
To Bush, (Osama) bin Laden’s view that the Iraq war
must end in “either victory and glory, or misery and
humiliation” makes Iraq the “central front” in
al-Qaida’s “war against humanity.” His answer: “We
must recognize Iraq as the central front in our war on
terror.”
The radicals’ hatred “existed before Iraq was an issue
and will exist after Iraq is no longer an excuse,”
said Bush, who asked: “Would the United States and
other free nations be more safe, or less safe, with
Zarqawi and bin Laden in control of Iraq, its people,
and its resources?”
On Oct. 13, the Wall Street Journal editorialized that
al-Qaida’s No. 2 man, Ayman al Zawahiri, and Bush
don’t agree on much, but agree that “Iraq is the
central battlefield.” The Journal examined Zawahiri’s
letter of July 9, intercepted by U.S. forces, to
al-Qaida’s commander in Iraq, Abu Musab al Zarqawi.
The letter affirmed the “establishment of a caliphate”
and that “the mujahedeen must not have their mission
end with the expulsion of the Americans from Iraq and
then lay down their weapons.” The “ongoing mission is
to establish an Islamic state, and defend it, and for
every generation to hand over the banner to the one
after it until the Hour of Resurrection.”
The Journal saw Zawahiri “clearly worried that the
jihadists are losing in Iraq.” He advised Zarqawi to
seek “popular support” of Iraq’s Muslim masses, and of
the peoples in surrounding Muslim countries, to avoid
attacks on the Shia, which “won’t be acceptable” to
Muslims and to avoid “scenes of slaughtering the
hostages.”
The U.S. government says it “has the highest
confidence in the letter’s authenticity.”
After Bush’s October speech, the Christian Science
Monitor quoted terrorism expert Anthony Cordesman, of
the Center for Strategic and International Studies in
Washington: “I don’t think the president has ever been
anything like this comprehensive.” He saw it as a
“coherent statement of American policy (which) has
implications that go far beyond what (Bush) has said
before.”
But Georgetown University political scientist Stephen
Wayne said Bush was only articulating the rhetoric,
“It’s still terrorism, stupid, and if we don’t fight
them they’ll take over the world and the interests of
Americans will be threatened.”
New York Times columnist Thomas Friedman charged that
when a Sunni suicide bomber blew himself up, killing
25 worshippers and wounding more than 87, in a Shiite
mosque on the first day of Ramadan, the attack got
only scant attention. He chastised the “Bush team,
which has finally settled on the right rationale for
the war in Iraq — to help Arabs carve out a space in
the heart of their world where they can create a
decent, progressive future,” for not seeking a U.N.
resolution declaring “Zarqawi and his ilk war
criminals.” He called Washington’s dispatch of Karen
Hughes around the Arab world “to get flagellated by
Sunni Muslim women for how awful we are,” as “losing a
public relations war to mass murderers.”
According to the Oct. 17 New York Times, Johns Hopkins
professor Eliot Cohen thinks Bush “has been
consistent” but that the Bush team has “had people,
myself among them, beating them up for happy talk and
not making an argument” about the nature of the
struggle. Former CIA analyst Kenneth Pollack, now a
scholar at the Brookings Institution, was harsher:
“The theory that democracy is the antidote to
insurgency gets disproven on the ground every day.”
The Oct. 20 Monitor’s “Does democracy lead to the end
of terrorism?” said Bush “says it does, but experts
are increasingly doubtful.” But Harvard Professor
Joseph S. Nye Jr. argued in the Sept. 22 Monitor that
it may take a decade or more to assess the Iraq war
and its effect on the Middle East and that “over time,
the slow, steady progress of democratization and
freedom” gives hope to the moderates, and “a
democratic future will help to remove some of the
sources of rage.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published November 2, 2005