Newsweek’s international editor, Fareed Zakaria, a naturalized U.S. citizen, wrote in the April 10 Newsweek’s “To Become an American” that many Americans may not realize how they have become “enamored” with the failing European approach to immigration through “guest workers, penalties, sanctions and deportation,” failures evidenced by rioting immigrant youths in France.
He sees “disaffected, alienated immigrants, ripe for radicalism” throughout Europe and reminds Americans of a “much deeper” issue beyond economic that “defines America — to itself, to its immigrants and to the world.” If immigrants already on U.S. soil do not “have some hope, some reasonable path to becoming Americans,” this means some folks are “unfit to be Americans” and “cold feelings about America” would develop as newcomers see they are not welcome because America only wants “workers, not potential citizens.”
The Heritage Foundation’s Matthew Spalding asserts in his March 16 article, “Making Citizens: The Case for Patriotic Assimilation,” that it’s the nature of America’s founding principles that draws to her shores the downtrodden, the persecuted, and all those “yearning to breathe free.”
In George Washington’s words, “The bosom of America is open to receive not only the opulent and respectable stranger, but the oppressed and persecuted of all nations and religions; whom we shall welcome to a participation of all our rights and privileges if, by decency and propriety of conduct, they appear to merit the enjoyment.”
With very few exceptions, Spalding says, America “has always welcomed immigrants who come to this country honestly, with their work ethic and appreciation of liberty, seeking the promises and opportunities of the American dream.”
To Spalding, America’s immigration success story rests on “a deliberate and self-confident policy of patriotic assimilation — welcoming newcomers while insisting that they learn and embrace America’s civic culture and political institutions, thereby forming one nation from many peoples.” There has always been a bipartisan agreement that “those who come here should become Americans,” Spalding says.
Individuals have “a natural right to emigrate from their homeland,” but no right “to immigrate (to America) without the consent of the American people as expressed through the laws of the United States,” writes Spalding. He affirms that, “with that consent,” the American concept of naturalization “works differently than it does in other countries.”
Sure, an immigrant can immigrate to France or Germany, “but never become truly French or German,” he says.
However, regardless of “any ethnic heritage or racial background” an alien “can immigrate to the United States and become, in every sense of the term, an American.” This is possible thanks to America’s “very openness of liberty to diverse backgrounds and differences of opinion” — the political principles that make a free government.
America’s founders wanted “a certain uniformity of opinion” about America and the American Revolution in order to achieve pluribus unum, but not homogeneity — that is not conducive to a free government; they understood that diversity must yield to a level of unity that would allow “one to be made out of many.”
So, Spalding argues, immigrants must “acquire for themselves” the qualities and sentiments essential to republicanism and become “enlightened friends of liberty and partisans in America’s common experiment in self-government.”
Spalding explains assimilation as “acquiring certain habits and attitudes” while respecting differences; becoming “similar in crucial but not all respects;” consistent with the American embrace of human equality and popular consent.
“Assimilation has nothing to do with forcing a stifling uniformity of opinion and passions upon immigrants,” he says, “nor is it about destroying the ethnic heritages and cultural identities (of subgroups).” Assimilation appeals to “the common principles and mutual understandings that transcend differences and that bind us together as a people.”
While in the naturalization process, “certain meaningful elements can and should be required,” assimilation “ultimately can’t be compelled.”
Immigrants must understand the principles of a free government; learn, understand and be able to communicate in English; “get assimilated to our customs, measures and laws,” as George Washington put it, to “become one people;” engage in economic opportunity, and owe “allegiance to the American political order or regime.”
Abraham Lincoln explained that people with no blood connection to the founders can feel a part of America through “the electric cord” of the Declaration of Independence, which links the “hearts of patriotic and liberty-loving men together.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the University of Guam, where he taught political science for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published May 24, 2006