The Feb. 23 announcement by the United Arab Emirates’
Dubai Ports World that it would “not exercise control
over” or “influence the management” of six American
seaports of New York, Newark, Philadelphia, Baltimore,
Miami and New Orleans on March 2 gives President
George W. Bush a respite as Democrat and Republican
lawmakers joined forces to oppose the deal.
Bush’s approval rating has been down; he threatened to
veto a bill opposing the deal, despite the probability
of a congressional override. The Feb. 24 Christian
Science Monitor’s “Port flap serious test for Bush”
added the public element: “Both parties in Congress
call for more oversight — and this time, the public
seems to agree.”
Dubai Ports World acquired the British Peninsular &
Oriental Steam Navigation Company, which operates
ports in 18 countries, for $6.85 billion. Dubai Ports
World said it will close its deal with P&O March 2,
but offered to refrain from managing the U.S. seaports
— for now.
While lawmakers in the Armed Services Committee
blasted administration officials from Defense,
Homeland Security, State and Treasury departments for
rushing to approve the sale deal without considering
national security, the deputy secretary of defense
replied, “We are very, very comfortable with the
decision that was made.”
Democratic Sen. Carl Levin of Michigan asked officials
to “raise your hand if anybody talked to the 9-11
commissioners” who investigated the Sept. 11 attacks
about the United Arab Emirates’ record on fighting
terrorism.
“No one did,” wrote the Los Angeles Times.
Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice visited the United
Arab Emirates on that day. In Washington, White House
political strategist Karl Rove told Fox News that
“there’s no requirement that (the deal) close”
immediately on March 2. The New York Times said Armed
Forces Committee chairman Sen. John Warner, R-Va, had
“quietly told” Dubai Ports World that “more time was
needed to derail Congressional action to block the
deal.”
The White House welcomed “a slight delay” of the deal,
but The Associated Press noted that New York
Democratic Sen. Charles Schumer said a “simple
cooling-off period will not allay our concerns.”
Schumer and New York Republican Congressman Peter T.
King introduced legislation to “temporarily halt the
deal” until the “45-day investigation required by law
when a foreign government is involved in a deal” is
completed. The Feb. 24 Los Angeles Times reported the
state of New Jersey filed a suit to block Dubai Ports
World’s immediate takeover of a Newark port terminal,
and the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey
filed a similar suit.
Ranking officials said they had heard about the deal
from the press. The Feb. 23 Washington Times wrote
that not only had Bush claimed he didn’t know, but the
chairman of the Interagency Committee on Foreign
Investment in the United States, which made the
decision on the Dubai Ports World deal, Treasury
Secretary John W. Snow and a CFIUS member, Defense
Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld, declared they didn’t
know until after the deal was approved. The Times’
“Chertoff unaware of ports deal until after OK,”
reported the following day that a third Cabinet
official, Homeland Security Secretary Michael
Chertoff, did not know either, “until this story
started to appear in the newspapers.”
What is “more noteworthy,” the Times said, is that
it’s Chertoff’s department that “headed the CFIUS
review and is in charge of security at all U.S.
ports.”
Carter backs Bush
Former President Jimmy Carter, a constant critic of
Bush’s policies, gave the president a boost when he
told CNN, “I’m sure the president’s done a good job
with his subordinates to make sure (the Dubai Ports
World deal) is not a threat.”
The conservative Heritage Foundation posted a memo,
“Security and the Sale of Port Facilities: Facts and
Recommendations” online on Feb. 22. It noted that
“outsourcing” of U.S. ports is “not the issue” …
“security standards” for ports, governed by the
International Shipping and Port Security Code, are not
the problem; Dubai Ports World is “a holding company”
and “not a terrorist gateway” and the United Arab
Emirates is America’s ally. Yet the memo argued, that
since Congress never reviewed the CFIUS procedure
since its implementation in 1988, it should take 45
days to review the deal.
It concluded, “The country needs confidence in the
procedures meant to ensure that foreign investment
does not harm national security and its reasonable
delay for review is the way to provide it.”
Will Bush heed this advice?
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published March 1, 2006