A scholar posits in Foreign Policy Research Institute Online, “History
teaches above all that there is no such thing as history, only
historical interpretation.”
Interpreters of history describe events or the development of human affairs, explain
them, analyze their causes and effects, and attempt to make sense of
what has occurred. Some present their vision of a historical trajectory
and venture to forecast what may be expected ahead.
A brand new book on my desk, “The Next 100 Years: A Forecast for the 21st
Century” by George Friedman, founder of the acclaimed world’s leading
private intelligence and forecasting company, Stratfor, draws on an
exploration of “hundreds of years” of history and geopolitical
patterns, and concludes we are “at the dawn of a new era.” Friedman
says he’ll be delighted if in 2100 his grandkids will say, “Not half
bad.”
Man is influenced by, among many things, the values (respect for others) and
beliefs (the Golden Rule) he has acquired through political
socialization since childhood, by the opinions and interests he has
formed through learning, and his personal and collective experiences in
life. They, together with his political and ideological inclinations,
mold his attitudes and shape his perceptions and foretell his actions.
Last month, Linda Elder, president of the Foundation for Critical Thinking,
an organization concerned with fostering fair-minded critical
societies, wrote in the Christian Science Monitor’s “Are you a critical
thinker? Quality thought is vital,” that “much of our thinking, left to
itself, is sloppy, distorted, partial, uninformed, or prejudiced.”
This past spring break, my son, a social studies teacher, reviewed three
binders of Western journal and newspaper articles I compiled more than
30 years ago, and was intrigued to read what reporters wrote about
events in Cambodia in 1970, much of which is not reflected in what
contemporary writers say today.
Elder urges us to take our reasoning to “a higher level” — “weighing information
to come to a logical conclusion” vs. “making snap judgments without understanding
the information.”
She named a few who “became some of the greatest thinkers by not accepting
information at face value, but by thinking deeply for themselves,
asking questions, and refining their thinking over time.”
She advises, “we can all start by beginning to think about how we think.”
“We can question our purposes, our assumptions, our ideas, and our
inferences. We can question whether we are considering the views of
others to understand them, or to dismiss them. We can open our minds to
the larger world with all its complexities,” she wrote.
Lest we forget, how to think well can be learned.
There’s something to learn from the March 27 speech by the foreign minister of
Singapore, George Yeo, at the University of Cambridge’s 800th
anniversary: “Human civilizations learn from one another more than they
realize, more than we realize.”
Yeo says that at any point in time there are “a number of possible
futures.” Referencing Austrian economist Joseph Schumpeter’s philosophy
of economic downturn, a process that marks the reallocation of
resources in which “the old gives way to the new,” and Charles Darwin’s
theory of life as “a struggle with old forms giving way to new forms,”
Yeo submits that “human society is part of this struggle.”
He argues, “Whatever trajectory history takes within that cone of
possibilities in the coming years, there will be a great re-pricing of
assets, of factors of production, of countries, of ideas.”
“No one can be sure” how the economic re-pricing will play out, Yeo
reasons, while “billions of Asians and Africans” are willing to “work
for much less,” hence, “directly or indirectly” hold down the wages and
salaries of Americans, Europeans, Japanese and others. A “multi-polar”
world will emerge after the current crisis, with the United States
retaining “the pre-eminent pole for a long time to come,” but “power
will have to be shared,” he said.
“Like biological species, human ideas and systems are also subject to
selection through wars, revolutions, elections, economic crises,
academic debates and market competition,” declares Yeo.
“Those which survive and flourish should, we hope, raise civilization to a
higher level,” Yeo asserts. He reminds of “our university tradition of
being skeptical without losing our moral sense” — “Only by being
skeptical can we be objective, can we see ourselves critically and
learn from others. Only with a moral sense will we be motivated to work
for a larger social good.”
He cited “China’s corruption and inability to learn from others” — the
Qian Long Emperor declared in 1793 China “had nothing to learn from the
West” — as marking the start of China’s long decline.
Yeo recalled the heyday of “Third World solidarity” in the 1950s, when
Indians had a saying, “Hindi-Chini, bhai bhai,” or Indians and Chinese
are brothers, and ended his Cambridge address with these words: “In
these confused times, we need to learn from one another on the basis of
a deep respect for each other as human beings.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the University of Guam, where
he taught political science for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.