USAToday.com has posted, since Jan. 19, an Associated
Press article, “Study: Collegians lack skills.” This
should spark an interest to check it out — if people
read a newspaper.
Personally, I came to America with practically no
English, toughed it out, received a doctorate from one
of America’s top schools and taught in U.S.
universities. So I was troubled to read that college
students are not performing. The March 14 Pacific
Daily News’ editorial, “54 years, University of Guam
must receive funding to ensure success rate,” led me
to this column.
The PDN says the University of Guam, viewed as the
Pacific’s jewel, “has had to put projects on hold” for
a few months as its budget allotments were not
provided; it’s “still owed” half a million dollars
from last fiscal year’s budget; a “crisis” exists in
Guam’s elementary and secondary schools as graduates
“can’t read at grade level”; and that UOG offers
remedial math and English courses to “hundreds of
students who aren’t yet ready to participate at the
college level.”
Yet, “education” and “people” are two important
elements of power anywhere.
The AP article tells of “sobering findings” in The
National Survey of America’s College Students, by a
nonpartisan, nonprofit research group, American
Institutes for Research, conducted in 2003 and
released Jan. 19. The study included a sample of 1,827
graduating students from 80 randomly selected two-year
and four-year public and private colleges and
universities across the United States.
The study finds 20 percent of graduating students at
four-year colleges and 30 percent at two-year colleges
“have only basic quantitative literacy skills” and
“are unable to estimate if their car has enough
gasoline to get to the next gas station or calculate
the total cost of ordering office supplies.”
AIR explains “basic skills” as skills “necessary to
compare ticket prices or calculate the cost of a
sandwich and a salad from a menu.”
AIR finds that 75 percent of students at two-year
colleges and more than 50 percent students at
four-year colleges “do not score at the proficient
level of literacy” and cannot perform “complex
literacy tasks, such as comparing credit card offers
with different interest rates or summarizing the
arguments of newspaper editorials.”
Washington lawmakers have proposed spending billions
to interest students and teachers in math and science
fields, and political and business leaders call for an
education that can help Americans meet “global
competition.” In President Bush’s words, “We’ve got to
have kids (who) are the best in science and
engineering and math. Otherwise, jobs are going to go
where the work force (has) those skills.”
Dr. Stephane Baldi, who directed the AIR study, agrees
that, “A knowledgeable work force is vital to cope
with the increasing demands of the global
marketplace.”
Parents, teachers and business and political leaders
should want to know where Guam students stand in this
competitive world.
The March 3 Christian Science Monitor’s “Dropout rates
high, but fixes under way,” reported a finding that
only 35 percent of dropouts say they were failing in
school, while top reasons for dropping out are:
classes were boring (47 percent); missed too many days
and could not catch up (43 percent); spent time with
people not interested in school (42 percent); too much
freedom and not enough rules in life (38 percent).
In the Feb. 8 Associated Press story, “Poll shows
divide among parents, teachers,” parents expect
teachers “to challenge and reward” their kids while
teachers look to parents “to instill manners, respect
and motivation.” Yet, a “natural partnership” is not
always there.
At the university level, New York University professor
of education Jonathan Zimmerman argued in the March 14
Christian Science Monitor’s “It’s time to give
teaching more weight,” that until there is “a serious
method to judge — or to reward” faculty’s work in the
classroom, student evaluations, occasional faculty
observation of one another in the classroom, the
“almost always … rave reviews” faculty give each
other, will not “improve college teaching.” There is
“no reward,” just “lip service,” given to classroom
instruction, and excellence in teaching can hold back
a career and does not assure tenure, as “research”
would.
There’s work to go all around to help prepare students
to enter the contemporary world of global competition:
for students, teachers, parents, community, business
and political leaders.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published March 22, 2006