A Feb. 5 article on the front page of the Washington
Post described a U.S. senator who “took off in a
sprint” as he “fled down stairways at the Capitol” to
avoid reporters’ question on a resolution opposing
President George W. Bush’s troop surge.
Read the Post’s Dana Milbank’s “The Upshot of the
Debate: No Debate” (Feb. 6) that said perhaps “too
much was expected” of a Senate that began its “morning
business” at 2 in the afternoon; even Sen. John Warner
(R-Va.) voted against debating his own resolution.
Returning to morning business at nearly 6 p.m.,
senators dealt with tax gap and minimum wage.
Milbank’s “Congress Has So Little to Do, And So Much
Time to Do It,” (Feb. 8) quoted a Capitol Hill
newspaper’s front page: “Members Resist Five-Day
Workweek.” Milbank sighed, “The poor dears.”
Slate online’s John Dickerson’s “All Talk and No Talk”
(Feb. 6), reported that senators “had to debate the
order of debating the debate” and in the end, “the
Senate debated nothing” — Senate Republicans, except
two from Minnesota and Maine, “stuck with their
party”; Democrats worried senators “would have simply
voted to support the troops” in Sen. Judd Gregg’s
(R-N.H.) resolution. “Because neither side could risk
an unfavorable outcome, they embraced stalemate.”
Also on Slate, Christopher Hitchens’ “Appointment in
Mesopotamia, Iraq’s problems existed long before 2003”
(Feb. 6) asserted, “If there is a sectarian war in
Iraq today, or perhaps several sectarian wars, we have
to understand that this was latent in the country, and
in the state, and in the society all along.” The
“habit of viewing Iraq as a crisis that only began in
2003 — a lazy habit … conditioned by the needs of
the impending 2008 election — is an obstacle to
understanding.” It’s “futile” to argue whether to
blame the Iraqis or the coalition.
He quoted al-Zarqawi’s February 2004 letter to bin
Laden. Fareed Zakaria also quoted it in the Feb. 12,
Newsweek: “The only solution” to prevent Iraq’s
democratic heresy is “to strike the religious,
military, and other cadres among the Shia with blow
after blow until they bend to the Sunnis.” Hitchens
advised we face “this central truth.”
Last year’s National Intelligence Estimate warned:
“perceived jihadist success (in Iraq) would inspire
more fighters to continue the struggle elsewhere”; and
“should jihadists leaving Iraq perceive themselves,
and be perceived, to have failed, (the 16 U.S. spy
agencies) judge fewer fighters will be inspired to
carry on the fight.”
Now, a new NIE predicts Iraq’s “overall security
situation will continue to deteriorate” within the
next 12 to 18 months, but sees U.S. forces in Iraq as
“an essential stabilizing element,” which, if
“withdrawn rapidly,” would almost be certain to result
in a “significant increase of scale and scope” of
sectarian conflict; open intervention by Iraq’s
neighbors; probable “massive civilian casualties and
forced population displacement”; al-Qaida’s use of
Iraq for “increased attacks in and outside the
country.”
The Feb. 6 Post editorial, “A Detached Debate, Have
the senators arguing over Iraq war resolutions read
the National Intelligence Estimate?” stated: “Nothing
that has been proposed would help in any material way
in Iraq.” It noted senators say they want to “‘end
this war’ — whatever that means,” and it posited,
“however much … senators might wish it, the war in
Iraq will not end before the next president takes
office.” America “needs a strategy for defending its
interests in Iraq for years to come. That perspective,
and not the American political calendar, is what
Congress ought to be focused on.”
Singapore’s Lee Kuan Yew wrote in the Jan.-Feb.
Foreign Affairs magazine, “I am not among those who
say that it was wrong to have gone into Iraq to remove
Saddam and now advocate that the United States cut its
losses and pull out.” He opined, “If the United States
leaves Iraq prematurely, jihadists everywhere will be
emboldened to take the battle to Washington and its
friends and allies.”
The Jan. 13-19 London Economist’s “Baghbad or bust,”
editorializes: President Bush “rejected” the Iraq
Study Group’s advice, “intends to defy world opinion,
American opinion, congressional opinion, much military
opinion, and even the advice of many members of his
own Republican Party by reinforcing rather than
reducing America’s effort in Iraq. Some will call this
reckless. Some will say the president is in denial.”
“We don’t admire Mr. Bush,” the editorial says, “but
on this we think he is right.”
The Dec. 9-15 Economist’s cover page showed a U.S.
soldier on a U-turn path over a faint U.S. flag. Its
headline: “Don’t do it.”
Opinions differ. Each of us has an obligation to learn
as much as we can about this (or any) issue and make
an informed decision.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published February 14, 2007