The U.S. military, with 1.4 million personnel on
active duty, is the world’s most powerful, with
unrivaled power projection capabilities. America ranks
second in active troops; China ranks first, with 2.2
million and India third, with 1.3 million.
The door to serving in the U.S. military is open to
noncitizens, although an immigrant cannot serve more
than eight years, nor become an officer, nor get
access to classified information.
President George W. Bush’s July 2002 executive order,
granting expedited citizenship consideration to
noncitizen-soldiers on active duty during the war on
terrorism, presented an additional incentive for
immigrants to enlist and their numbers rose in
2002-2003.
Of the 34 million immigrants in the United States,
about 10.5 million, or one-third, come from Mexico.
About 10 million immigrants are illegal residents, of
whom about 6.3 million are Mexicans.
The Dec. 6 Pew Hispanic Center survey dismisses the
myth that Mexicans cross the borders illegally because
of social-economic conditions or unemployment back
home — they come because of family connections and
better job opportunities here. Improved social and
economic conditions in Mexico may not, thus, stop the
flow of illegal immigration to the United States.
Statistically, immigrants with green cards form 7
percent to 8 percent of America’s total active
fighting force. Their numbers have risen from 28,000
in 2000 to more than 37,000 today, the largest
percentage being Hispanics. Noncitizen-soldiers,
excluding foreign contractors after Sept. 11, came
from more than 100 countries. As of last spring, some
8 percent of total American casualties in Iraq and
Afghanistan were noncitizen-soldiers.
A “fast track” to citizenship may induce some
immigrants to serve. But the March 11, 2003, St.
Petersburg Times’ “Foreign citizens help shoulder
military duty” and the Nov. 13 Washington Post’s
“Serving the Country Not Quite Theirs” observed that
immigrants joined the military for the same reasons
young Americans do — patriotism, money for college,
free job training, adventure, a chance to travel
abroad.
In a volunteer army in wartime “most born-and-raised
Americans can remain utterly cocooned from any
sacrifice,” says the Post, but immigrants are playing
a “striking role.”
Noncitizen-soldiers are “patriots in blood if not
ink,” says the Post’s Style Section’s lead article,
which featured a handsome 21-year old Cpl. Joseph J.
Brown of Liberia, a tank driver, who raked Iraqi
insurgents on the attack in Sadr City in April 2004
with his .50-caliber machine gun to save his comrades.
Brown suffered spinal injuries, nerve damage to his
leg and post-traumatic stress disorder. Now he is a
disabled veteran.
Brown said he enlisted to say “thank you” to a country
that took him and his family of 13 into its fold in
- “People like us coming from disaster to a
peaceful land, we should give back,” said Brown, whose
father was a captain in the Liberian militia. “I
didn’t have money to give. I gave myself.”
In August, Brown leaned against his cane and recited
America’s oath of allegiance to become a citizen.
In the July 5 Christian Science Monitor’s “Noncitizen
soldiers: the quandaries of foreign-born troops,”
libertarian Cato Institute defense analyst Charles
Pena spoke of “many stories” of young men and women
who enlisted because they wanted to become Americans,
but who were killed on duty. Pena asked: “Was their
ultimate sacrifice worthwhile?”
“Many observers say foreign volunteers tend to be
exemplary in the line of duty,” wrote the Monitor,
which quoted Homeland Security’s Christopher Bentley:
“(Foreign-born U.S. soldiers) identify with the ideals
of the United States and they are willing to fight and
protect those ideals, even before they’ve secured all
the liberties of citizenship.”
U.S commanders told the St. Petersburg Times: “Many
immigrants have a finer appreciation for the ideals
the military purports to fight for — freedom and
democracy — than many native-born Americans” and that
“they have a personal experience from living in an
area where they didn’t have that freedom and liberty”
and “They’re a lot closer to the American founding
fathers than the average American might be.”
This column ends with a salute the good people of Guam
who offer their blood, sweat and tears to serve under
the U.S. flag in many military conflicts, even though
they can’t vote for an American president whose
decisions affect their lives.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published December 21, 2005