On March 18, Dr. Amina Wadud, Islamic studies
professor at the Commonwealth University in Richmond,
Va., led a mixed-gender Friday noon prayer, or Jum’ah,
at Synod House of the Cathedral of St. John the Divine
in New York City. The prayer was preceded by a call to
prayer by another Muslim woman, who wore no headscarf,
and was followed by a sermon on how Muslim men and
women should treat one another as equals, and not to
presume Allah to be male.
A photo of the Muslim prayer in the March 19 New York
Times article, “Challenging Tradition,” showed the
woman imam leading the prayer.
About a third of the congregants were men; some women
did not wear scarves and were in prayer in long pants;
newspaper reporters, photographers and television
cameras surrounded them. More than two dozen police
were outside, where protesters raised signs and
shouted against the break with tradition inside.
The Times noted a study by the Council on
American-Islamic Relations that in about two-thirds of
the mosques in America, women pray behind partitions,
curtains or in separate rooms from men. The Times
quoted Professor Khaled Abou El Fadl, a specialist in
Islamic law at the University of California, Los
Angeles, that the practice is not dictated by the
Koran, but is the result of social traditions.
However, Imam Ahmed Dewidar, of the Islamic Center of
Mid-Manhattan, declared, “I have never heard of (a
woman imam) before.” He claimed that “even the wife of
the Prophet Muhammad did not lead the prayer.”
The Muslim service was to have been held at a SoHo
gallery, but a bomb threat moved it to the Synod
House. Three New York mosques declined to host the
sermon, whose lead-organizer was Asra Q. Nomani, a
former reporter for The Wall Street Journal and author
of a recently published book on women in Islam.
Andrea Elliott of the Times claimed that Nomani had
stirred up a tempest last year when she entered her
mosque in Morgantown, W.Va., through the front door,
which is reserved for men, and insisted on praying
with the men. Last month she asked Wadud, who had
given a sermon and led a mixed-gender prayer in South
Africa in 1994, to lead the prayer and deliver a
sermon in New York.
On the day the mixed-gender prayer was held, the
Washington Post ran a column, “A Prayer Toward
Equality” by Mona Eltahawy, a New York-based columnist
for the pan-Arab publication Asharq al-Awsat: “I can
tell you what a thrill … to stand before God as the
spiritual equal of the male congregants — praying
together, not behind the men and not in another room
— with a woman leading us.”
Eltahawy cited one of her favorite stories from
Islamic history: After Muslim women complained about
the revelations the prophet had received addressed to
“believing men,” the prophet began receiving
revelations that addressed both “believing men” and
“believing women.”
“If God included us in the narrative, who has kept us
out?” Eltahawy asked.
The Muslim world is large and diverse, Eltahawy
reminds. In Saudi Arabia, a woman cannot be admitted
to a hospital without a male guardian’s signature; in
Malaysia, women recite the Koran on national
television. She also notes that Muslim women were
given rights more than 1,400 years ago that “made them
the envy of women in Europe’s Dark Ages.”
Eltahawy called on women to change Islam and bring it
into the 21st century, and lamented that “we have
wasted time and energy circling the same old subjects”
— how much of a woman’s body should be covered, and
can men and women shake hands.
While Americans remain divided over the war in Iraq,
the struggle among the 1.3 billion followers of Islam
for its soul intensifies. Iraqi secular and religious
leaders fight to write Iraq’s constitution that will
shape the rights of women profoundly. Under this
light, one should read such articles as “Iraq’s Hidden
War” in the March 7 Newsweek, about the shooting of
Iraqi women activists in the streets and private
murders; and about suicide attacks that have focused
on Iraqi civilians.
Look beyond the war in Iraq. Among the crises that
dictate the world’s future is the outcome of the
struggle within Islam.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., retired from the
University of Guam where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published March 30, 2005