British Premier Tony Blair’s vow to confront the “evil
ideology” of the Islamic extremists “head-on, without
compromise or delusion,” was followed by his July 26
declaration not to “give one inch” to the terrorists.
Pan-Arab newspaper Asharq al-Awsat’s New York-based
columnist Mona Eltahawy wrote in the July 24
Washington Post that the July 7 London bombings “rid
me of all patience with the George Bush or Tony Blair
‘made me do it’ excuse” for suicide bombings. To
non-Muslims who accept the Bush/Blair excuse, Eltahawy
asked if they “think Muslims are incapable of
accepting responsibility,” and if it is not “bigoted
to think that Muslims can only react violently?”
Eltahawy says she was opposed to the Iraq war, but
she’s done with the Bush excuse. She says she “never
bought” the argument that U.S. foreign policy “brought
on” the Sept. 11 attacks; or the Iraq war is behind
the London bombings. She admits many people around the
world have opposed U.S. and British foreign policies,
but they did not rush to fly planes into buildings or
blow up buses and the Underground trains in London.
She ridicules the 22 imams and scholars who met at
London’s largest mosque to condemn the July 7 London
bombings but declined to criticize all suicide
attacks. “Suicide bombings are the Muslim weapons of
choice,” she writes. “They are killing Muslims and
non-Muslims alike.”
But she says she is “not done with Islam,” and the
clerics and the terrorists will not take Islam away
from her. “God belongs to me, too.”
David Ignatius’s “Revolt of Privilege, Muslim Style,”
in the July 27 Washington Post recalled the “revolt of
the rich kids” in America in the 1960s, as he
discussed Muslim terrorists whitewater rafting in
Wales before the London attacks. “They have risen so
far, so fast in the dizzying culture of the West that
they have become enraged, disoriented and vulnerable
to manipulation.”
Muslims suffering
Just as a counter-revolt by the poor kids in America
“derailed” the rich kids’ revolt, Ignatius thinks poor
Muslims “simply can’t afford the rebellion of their
wealthy brethren” that destroys the House of Islam.
Make no mistake, says Ignatius, the “people suffering
from jihadism are mostly Muslims.”
He cannot imagine the poor Iraqis whose families are
killed by suicide bombings feel affinity for the Saudi
jihadists.
On July 28, some 130 North American Muslim
organizations endorsed the religious edict, fatwa, by
the 18-member High Council of North America,
condemning terrorists as “criminals, not ‘martyrs’,”
declaring, “all acts of terrorism targeting civilians
are ‘haram’ (forbidden) in Islam,” and Muslims have a
“civic and religious duty” to help law enforcement
authorities to “protect the lives of all civilians.”
In “How to Stop The Contagion,” Newsweek’s Fareed
Zakaria says, “radical Islam is a phenomenon of the
educated class … extremist ideology is a
leisure-time pursuit.”
He reminds that if anyone had cause for rage, it
should not be the suicide bombers, none of whom lived
in “hellish ghettos,” but their parents, who migrated
to Britain, were dirt-poor and “probably ostracized
and persecuted” but never became murderers.
The Iraq war may have enraged many Muslims and
radicalized some deeply, he admits, but there is
“something deeper at work” when a Briton like Germaine
Lindsay, who never visited Iraq, kissed his pregnant
wife and child goodbye to blow himself and others up.
This is fanaticism, Zakaria says. “Radical ideologies
of hate and violence have often seduced disaffected
young men searching for some great cause.”
Zakaria sees as good news that this ideology is not
doing well in the Muslim world. While he accepts as
true the cliche that “ultimately only Muslims can win
this fight,” he argues that Western countries can do
more by presenting a “positive vision” for Muslim
societies. “This is battle, not an academic seminar.
We have to discredit, delegitimize and dismantle
barbaric ideas.”
Zakaria quotes the director-general of Al Arabiya TV,
who asked why Britain granted asylum to Arabs
convicted of political crimes or religious extremism,
or who were sentenced to death. The director-general
sees extremism as an “infectious” disease; a “small
dose of carriers can spread the infection like
wildfire.”
Zakaria concludes: “Let’s start by making life as
difficult as possible for the carriers of this virus.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published August 10, 2005