In my March 30 column, I wrote about Dr. Amina Wadud,
a Commonwealth University in Richmond professor of
Islamic studies, who went against Islamic tradition by
leading a mixed-gender Friday noon prayer in New York
City. A former reporter at The Wall Street Journal,
Asra Q. Nomani, author of “Standing Alone in Mecca: An
American Woman’s Struggle for the Soul of Islam,” was
a lead organizer of the event.
A week later, Nomani led her own mixed-gender prayer
service at Brandeis University, which was followed by
a Muslim woman who applied to be the first female imam
of a mosque in Tuscany, and then another mixed-gender
prayer service in April in Toronto.
Jihadist Internet messages called for Wahud’s murder
and death for those who participated in the New York
City prayer.
The front page of the June 5 Washington Post’s Style
Section carried a lengthy article about Nomani, “The
Woman Who Went To The Front of the Mosque,” complete
with photos of the “first woman to be allowed (in
2004) to enter her mosque in Morgantown through the
main door,” which usually is reserved for men only.
She was told then to sit at least 50 feet from the
men, but she refused.
Born in Bombay, Nomani, now 39, emigrated to the
United States with her family when she was 4. Her
family moved to Morgantown, W.Va., when she was 10. In
1981 her father, Zafar, helped found a 200-member
mosque, the Islamic Center of Morgantown. But Nomani’s
challenge to tradition has led some 30 members to seek
to banish her from the mosque.
Nomani launched the Muslim Women’s Freedom Tour this
spring, traveling from city to city to urge Muslim
women to be more assertive in their mosques. She
argues that the practice of gender separation at
mosques has no basis in the Koran, a view supported by
religious scholar and historian Reza Aslan, who said,
“What (Nomani) has done is perfectly in line with
Islamic values, traditions and the prophet’s own
desire to have men and women working side by side,
praying side by side and even fighting side by side.”
No overnight change
Some critics say they have no problem with Nomani’s
gender politics, but they have a problem with her.
Some have accused her of wanting to change a
conservative community “overnight,” which cannot be
done. Her supporters, like Pakistani American lawyer
Asma Gull Hasan, author of “Why I am a Muslim: An
American Odyssey,” says Nomani is “fighting the good
fight.”
Hasan lamented that there are Muslim women “who don’t
like the conservative attitudes of the mosques” but
either they keep attending the mosques “blindly and
ignore the rhetoric” or they just stop attending
altogether, like in her own case. She said she doesn’t
go to a mosque because she is irritated at how women
are treated.
The Post reported that two days after Nomani’s
appearance on “Nightline” to talk about her fight to
change her mosque, a death threat was made in a
message in Urdu to her cell phone: “If you want to
stay alive, keep your mouth shut,” or be slaughtered
halal style (by having her throat cut). The Post said
Nomani has started to lock her doors now and has
contacted the FBI and the local police, but won’t be
shutting up.
Nomani and her father still go to the Morgantown
mosque. She doesn’t wear a head scarf, but she covers
her head with her “fuchsia hoodie” over her hair, and
she calls it her “ghetto hijab,” an irritation to “the
powers that be” at the mosque. She walks through the
front door, takes off her shoes, and finds herself the
only female among 100 or so men praying. She said she
used to attend the mosque every day, “but it feels so
unfriendly, so inhospitable. So now I just come on
Fridays.”
Her father expressed grief that Islam gave rights to
women 1,400 years ago and the prophet was “one of the
greatest feminists,” (but) “when I see Islam today and
the way people behave toward women, I am very sad. I
am for women’s rights, respect (and) women’s equality.
Islam teaches that.”
Nomani’s fight continues, and she will face many
objections and rejections.
Change does not occur overnight.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published June 22, 2005