Twenty-five anti-Vietnam-War protesters who
demonstrated outside President Lyndon Johnson’s Texas
ranch in 1965 gave birth to an antiwar movement that
eventually prevented Johnson from seeking re-election.
This summer, on the evening of Aug. 17, more than
1,600 separate vigils were held across the United
States, participants calling for an end to U.S.
involvement in the war in Iraq.
The nationwide vigils were ignited by 48-year-old
Cindy Sheehan of California. Sheehan’s son, Army Spc.
Casey Sheehan, 24, a father of twin girls, enlisted in
the Army in 2000 and was killed in Sadr City on April
4, 2004, along with six other soldiers, on a voluntary
mission to rescue injured soldiers. Cindy Sheehan
began her protest on Aug. 6 and vowed to remain
outside of President George W. Bush’s ranch in
Crawford, Texas, until he meets with her and other
grieving families. She said she might follow Bush to
Washington, D.C.
In an open letter to Bush on Nov. 4, 2004, Cindy
Sheehan called the Iraq war “illegal and unjust” and
charged that Bush’s “reckless and wanton foreign
policies killed my son.” She wants to tell Bush
personally to bring U.S. troops home from Iraq now.
Peter Beinart, editor of the New Republic and guest
scholar at the Brookings Institution, who admitted he
supported the war, wrote in “When the War Won’t Stay
at Bay,” in the Aug. 18 Washington Post that Bush “is
right to refuse” to bring U.S. troops home now, “since
it would be a disaster for national security and a
betrayal of our responsibilities.”
But Beinart noted that while “another politician” such
as former President Bill Clinton or Sen. John McCain
“probably would have met with Cindy Sheehan long ago,”
this is Bush, whose “defining quality is his aversion”
to being challenged, as aides “scrupulously” shield
him from criticism. Beinart felt that Bush seemed
constitutionally unable to grant a simple request to
meet Sheehan before her grief was turned into a
national cause.
First meeting
Bush did meet the Sheehan family two months after
Casey died. In “From our archive: Bush, Sheehans share
moments” in TheReporter.Com of Vacaville, it is noted
that the Sheehans were among 17 families invited to
have face-to-face meetings with Bush at Fort Lewis
near Seattle. Cindy Sheehan was quoted as saying she
was unhappy with the war, but the Sheehans decided not
to use the 10 minutes of face time with Bush to ask if
Casey’s death “would make the world a safe place.”
TheReporter.Com says the Sheehans enjoyed meeting
other families of fallen soldiers, that they “laughed,
joked and bickered playfully” as they toured Seattle
and “felt whole again,” as Cindy Sheehan was quoted as
saying. “That was the gift the president gave us, the
gift of happiness, of being together,” Cindy Sheehan
said.
Christopher Hitchens of Vanity Fair, and author of a
book, “Thomas Jefferson: Author of America,” quotes
Cindy Sheehan’s statement to the editors of ABC’s
Nightline on March 15, in Slate.Com: “Am I emotional?
Yes, my firstborn was murdered. Am I angry? Yes, he
was killed for lies and for a PNAC Neo-Con agenda to
benefit Israel. My son joined the army to protect
America, not Israel. Am I stupid? No, I know full well
that my son, my family, this nation and this world
were betrayed by George Bush.”
Hitchens disputes Maureen Dowd’s conclusions in her
article, “The moral authority of parents who bury
children killed in Iraq is absolute” (The New York
Times, Aug 10).
Hitchens asserts that one “must deny to anyone the
right to ventriloquize the dead” and notes that Casey
Sheehan joined the military “as a responsible adult
volunteer.”
“Are we so sure” that Casey would have wanted his
mother to declare “he was killed in a war for a Jewish
cabal?” Hitchens asked.
Time Magazine quoted a White House aide who asked
rhetorically, if President Bush meets with Cindy
Sheehan again, should he have a second meeting with
“every mother or wife who asks for one?”
“A fair question,” says Time, but “There is a risk.”
Remember the 25 anti-Vietnam-War protesters who
started an antiwar movement in 1965?
But for now, Cindy Sheehan’s mother’s stroke pulled
her away from protest at Crawford. She will try to
return, she says.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published August 24, 2005