What we do, or don’t do, can affect the world.
Environmentalists’ charge to “think globally, act
locally” calls for local actions to protect Mother
Earth. Former Indonesian President Abdurrahman Wahid’s
call to members of every faith to engage in “nothing
less than a global struggle for the soul of Islam,” is
an effort to stop what he sees as the “terrible danger
(that) threatens humanity.”
Political discourse polarizes people. In “The
right/left lobe,” the Jan. 26 Los Angeles Times
editorial referenced neuroscientists’ findings that in
political argument and reaction, the part of human
brain that deals with rational thought shuts off, and
the part that deals with unconscious emotional thought
takes over.
“The West’s Last Chance: Will We win the Clash of
Civilizations?” by Tony Blankley, the Washington Times
editorial page editor, outlines the problems facing
the West and what to do. He suggests the United States
declare “war on the Islamist jihadists,” as America
faces “a challenge of immigration, cultural
aggression, and a conflict of values, religions and
lifestyles.” Blankley’s views have many supporters and
opponents.
John Hughes acknowledged in the Jan. 18 Christian
Science Monitor that much is written about the
“conflict between Islam and the West.” But he thinks
“the debate that will actually determine the future of
Islam lies within Islam, between Muslim and Muslim.”
The direction Islam will follow in the contemporary
world will affect its stability. Opposed to Wahid is
one of many terror groups, Jemah Islamiyah, and its
spiritual leader, Abu Bakar Bashir. They seek to make
Indonesia an Islamic state. In the Muslim world, the
generally more docile moderates struggle with virulent
Islamic extremists to control the future direction of
Islam.
Muslims are searching for their individual and
collective identities. The Jan. 31 Monitor’s, “He
traveled to Mecca in search of himself,” reported on
how a Moroccan-born, self-described “secular Muslim,”
Abdellah Hammoudi, a faculty member at Princeton
University, wrote in “A Season in Mecca: Narrative of
a Pilgrimage,” that he has found “tears, joy, crowds
— and more questions” about Islam and Muslims in his
1999 journey to Mecca.
On Jan. 30, the Monitor reported in “Pakistani women
defy threats, run mixed marathon,” about how Pakistani
women, in their traditional salwar kameez
(loose-fitting tunics) and shawls, joined more than
15,000 runners in a marathon in Lahore, running and
walking alongside the men — their husbands and
children — “to make a statement” rejecting the
“Taliban past” despite religious groups’ oppositions.
The Jan. 31 Monitor editorializes that “the real issue
may be less secular versus Islamic rule and more a
battle over who speaks for Islam.”
In Hughes’s article, “To progress, Islamic countries
must advance women’s rights,” he refers to women’s
rights as a significant benchmark. But just how do
women in a Muslim world ruled by Islamic theology, the
sharia, emerge to contribute to economic and political
progress?
Isobel Coleman, the director of the Women and U.S.
Foreign Policy program at the Council on Foreign
Relations, posited persuasively in “Women, Islam and
the New Iraq,” in the January/February Foreign Affairs
Magazine, that it is futile to avoid the sharia, the
Islamic law based on the Koran and the Sunnah, the
recorded traditions of the Prophet. But Muslim women
are not at dead end.
“In fact,” Coleman wrote, “sharia is open to a wide
range of understanding, and across the Islamic world
today” progressive Muslims seek — “within an Islamic
framework,” using theology to fight theology — to
“reinterpret its rules to accommodate a modern role
for (Muslim) women.”
The Koran says, “Marry those women who are lawful for
you, up to two, three, or four, but only if you can
treat them all equally.” Later, the Koran also says,
“No matter how you try you will never be able to treat
your wives equally.”
Progressive Muslims have used both verses to show
Islamic belief in monogamy, despite al-Qaida leaders
who have many wives. Coleman urges Washington to help
educate Muslim women to know what their rights are,
“both under the constitution and under the sharia.”
Though critical of President George W. Bush’s
policies, the Feb. 1 Los Angeles Times editorialized
that “Bush was correct” to assert that “the only
alternative to American leadership is a dramatically
more dangerous and anxious world.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published February 8, 2006