When German political theorist Hannah Arendt
(1906-1975), a Jew who became a naturalized United
States citizen, reported for The New Yorker on Nazi
war criminal Eichmann’s trial in Jerusalem in 1961,
(reporting she later compiled in book form as
“Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of
Evil”), she examined whether evil is radical or simply
a function of banality.
Jim Hoagland’s “Banality Of the Bombers,” in the July
31 Washington Post, sees a parallel between Eichmann’s
“words and appearance” during his trial and the
police’s surveillance photos of the London terrorism
suspects: “The face of evil as all too human and
surprisingly mediocre … one of petty criminality and
hatred that we can easily recognize.”
Arendt described Eichmann as the bureaucrat of
genocide and the banality of evil forces that would —
whether through ignorance, frustration,
thoughtlessness or intent — destroy human beings.
Hoagland cites Professor Bethania Assy’s work on
Arendt, which described Eichmann as having an ability
not to think seriously about what he was doing. To
Hoagland, the Baghdad, Bali or London bombers and
their acolytes are no different.
Because suicide bombers continue to kill
indiscriminately, and it is only a matter of time
before America is struck anew, it is important to
identify and find ways to stop them.
Some political analysts have sparked debate on
profiling. The New York Times carried two articles on
July 28: “When the Profile Fits the Crime,” by Paul
Sperry, a Hoover Institution media fellow and author
of “Infiltration: How Muslim Spies and Subversives
Have Penetrated Washington”; and “When You Have to
Shoot First,” by Haim Watzman, author of “Company C:
An American’s Life as a Citizen-Soldier in Israel.”
Sperry ridicules New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s
order to search randomly the bag of one of every five
New York subway riders, without regard to race or
religion, as doomed to failure. Sperry sees it as fact
that it was the “young Muslim men,” and not the Girl
Scouts or grannies, who bombed the London Underground
and who attacked New York with planes. Searching the
Girl Scouts and the grannies wastes resources. He
refers to the Department of Homeland Security’s Jan.
2004 handout that advises certain “suicide bomber
indicators” that include, “short haircut,” “shaved
beard or moustache,” “praying fervently,” smelling of
“herbal or flower water” (to prepare for Paradise).
Watzman argues that the London policeman who killed
the 27 year-old Brazilian electrician “did a horrible
thing. But he also did the right thing.” There is an
essential difference between us and the suicide
bombers. The bombers “perpetrate gratuitous horrors”
while we do “terrible things” to prevent something
worse from happening.
In the July 29 Washington Post, Charles Krauthammer’s
“Give Grandma a Pass, Politically Correct Screening
Won’t Catch Jihadists,” calls it “nuts” to try to
catch terrorists through random checks on 83-year-old
grannies from Poughkeepsie.
Krauthammer denies that he is stereotyping people and
calls it “fact” that jihadists from Bali to Casablanca
to Madrid to London to New York to Washington were
“young Muslim men of North African, Middle Eastern and
South Asian origin.” Sure, there was a mixed-race shoe
bomber, but Krauthammer argues the “overwhelming odds
are that the guy bent on blowing up your train traces
his origin to the Islamic belt stretching from
Mauritania to Indonesia.”
I am an Asian, a Muslim, a naturalized American since
- My spouse is an American woman of Irish descent.
True, I felt funny that as we walked through airport
security it was I who was stopped and searched while
my wife, who bears the same last name, walked through
without a hassle. I have learned to act pre-emptively
and willingly removed my shoes, my belt, my watch, and
anything metal, before walking through security. No
hassle.
But Colbert I. King’s “You Can’t Fight Terrorism With
Racism,” in the July 30 Washington Post comments on
each of the three articles, which he sees as
“insulting, offensive and — by thought, word and
deed, whether intentional or not — racist.”
Yet, the question remains: When America is attacked
anew, what may be the chances the attackers will be
Islamic extremists from certain countries, and not
grandmothers and youngsters who are randomly searched
in a (well-intentioned) “one in five” policy?
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published August 17, 2005