Media reports of the release last week of the Pew
Research Center’s “first-ever, nationwide, random
sample survey” findings on America’s estimated 2.35
million “highly diverse” Muslims, “Muslim-Americans:
Middle Class and Mostly Mainstream,” confirm my
oft-repeated contention that it’s necessary for all of
us always to read more and learn more. A glass half
full and a glass half empty may look the same, but the
expression of the image makes a difference.
The May 22 Pew report sees Muslim Americans as
“largely assimilated, happy with their lives, and
moderate with respect to many of the issues that have
divided Muslims and Westerners around the world.” It
sees Muslim Americans as “decidedly American in their
outlook, values and attitudes,” with 71 percent
believing that hard work pays off in the United
States, that Muslims coming to the United States
should try to adopt American customs, and by 63
percent to 32 percent — nearly two-to-one — Muslim
Americans see no conflict between being a devout
Muslim and living in a modern society.
Shouldn’t these findings be used in the fight against
radical Islamism?
Five days before the Pew report, Dr. Steven Kull of
the University of Maryland’s Program in International
Policy Attitudes (PIPA), and WorldPublicOpinion.org
editor, testified before the House Committee on
Foreign Affairs on “Negative Attitudes toward the
United States in the Muslim world: Do they matter?”
Kull noted decades of the Muslim world’s “resentments
about U.S. policies” — Muslims see the U.S. favoring
Israel, exploiting Middle East oil, supporting
dictatorships. Now, a new perception is added: the
United States is seen as warring against Islam.
Backtracking to March 6, Kull’s testimony on
“America’s Image in the World” affirms “people around
the world” don’t have problems with “the value of the
principles the U.S. has tried to promote in the
world,” but have problems with U.S. policies.
The Pew findings released last week indicate that
“Muslim-Americans reject Islamic extremism by larger
margins than do Muslim minorities in Western
countries” and “fewer native-born
African-American-Muslims than others completely
condemn al-Qaida.” It gives figures.
And yet The Associated Press runs “Some U.S. Muslims
justify suicide attacks,” and Reuters said “Poll Finds
Some U.S. Muslim Support for Suicide Attacks.” The
headlines and the news grab attention: 13 percent of
U.S. Muslims, particularly those younger then 30, say
suicide bombings of civilians “can be” justified — 5
percent said it is justified “rarely,” 7 percent say
“sometimes,” and 1 percent, “often.” But 80 percent
said it is never justified.
Then I read conservative Townhall.com’s Michelle
Malkin, who complains in “Tiny Minority, Big Problem”
about “the spin” of The Associated Press headline
writers’ “Most U.S. Muslims reject suicide bombings.”
I accept Malkin’s concerns: “A few fringe jihadists
here (in America), a few fringe jihadists there (in
Europe and elsewhere), and soon you’re talking about
bloody real numbers.”
Those bloody real numbers were presented in the April
27 conservative National Review Online’s “200 Million
Minority” by Raymond Ibrahim: Even if only 20 percent
of Muslims are radicals, that means “200 million, are
hell-bent on destroying the West — how is that
supposed to be any comfort to us?”
The May 23 Washington Post presented some Pew data to
go with its article, “Survey: U.S. Muslims
Assimilated, Opposed to Extremism.”
It reported that while 9 percent of African Americans
(who form 20 percent of the U.S. Muslim population)
express a favorable attitude toward al-Qaida, and 36
percent an unfavorable one, 3 percent of foreign-born
Muslims (who form 65 percent of the U.S. Muslim
population) are favorable to al-Qaida, and 63 percent
are “very unfavorable.”
In 2005, Iranian-American professor Reza Aslan, author
of the book, “No god but God: The Origins, Evolution,
and Future of Islam,” rejects the idea of an “original
vision of Islam” and argues that Islam, like
Christianity and Judaism, is in a constant state of
evolution, adaptation and interpretation. He sees
Islamic terrorism as a 14-century-long internal
conflict within Islam for the future of Islam.
But Robert Spencer, director of Jihad Watch and author
of the book “The Truth About Muhammad” disagrees with
Aslan, and continues to cite some Koranic verses and
Hadith popularly used by Islamist jihadists to justify
terror and violence in Islam.
Today’s nonprofit Free Muslims Coalition, with
chapters in several states and in several Middle
Eastern countries, and the Center for Islamic
Pluralism think tank, with headquarters in Washington,
D.C., present themselves as anti-militant Islamists.
Declaring “there can NEVER be a justification for
terrorism,” the FMC says, “No holy war needs to be
waged; there is no clear and present threat to Islam;
the only war that needs to be waged in the modern
world is one against terrorists and extremists.”
It expresses on its Web site its belief “in the
re-interpretation of Islam for the 21st century” and
that religion is “a personal relationship between” an
individual and God, among other things.
The FMC’s Press Corner on the Web has an article
“Islamism, not Islam is the Problem,” by M. Zuhdi
Jasser, a former U.S. Navy lieutenant commander, and
chairman of American Islamic Forum for Democracy,
based in Phoenix. His views on “who or what defines
Islam, and under what authority?” should be read.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published May 30, 2007