People don’t like to be wrong. Others don’t necessarily agree with them. It’s no revelation that to any argument there are counterarguments.

My theory is, to a thesis there is an anti-thesis, and in time a synthesis of the two emerges and a new thesis develops. So learn much and know much. Increased knowledge enhances one’s perspective and the foundation from which good decisions are made is secured.

Knowledge is acquired through formal and informal learning, through reading, listening, new encounters and new experiences. A study shows that when it comes to emotionally charged political issues, the rational part of one’s brain shuts down and the emotional part takes over. Haven’t you observed in such a situation that civility stops and invectives begin? Yet, this “other guy” with whom one argues may have a valid point.

I wrote in this space before about Nat Hentoff, an authority on education, free speech and the Bill of Rights. In the July 13, 2006, USA Today’s “What you don’t know can hurt you,” he noted an American Bar Association poll showed fewer than half of Americans had any idea of what “the separation of powers” means.

I also wrote about Boston College political science professor Alan Wolfe, who wrote in “Wise Up, Voters,” in the Sept. 10, 2006, Los Angeles Times, that “Americans may be divided by party, but they are united in ignorance.” Wolfe asked: “Does ignorance matter?”

He wrote that throughout much of the 1970s and into the 1980s, “voter ignorance, however disturbing to people who teach about politics, did not interfere with how democracy worked, because Americans were centrist in their views.” But in today’s “more ideological times,” Wolfe argues, “voter ignorance, far from being a relatively harmless quirk, becomes a serious problem for democratic performance.”

“All politicians try to ‘spin’ the truth to their advantage,” Wolfe wrote, and “Americans frequently respond not by informing themselves about events but by concluding that they were correct to distrust politicians in the first place.”

Wolfe believes that this situation “creates a vicious cycle in which ignorance breeds manipulation that then justifies further ignorance. Why pay attention to politics, Americans ask themselves, if politicians are just going to ignore what we want?”

Last week I quoted the Newsweek Poll of early May that put President George W. Bush’s approval rating by the public at an all-time low of 28 percent. A month earlier, the April 9 Gallup News Service revealed Americans’ approval of Bush was at 38 percent, but the United States Congress’s approval rating was 33 percent, and 33 percent of Americans said they are satisfied with the way things are going in the nation.

A blogger observes that a problem with polls is that if the public sees “bad news about a particular subject, then the public opinion will probably be dismal. It cries out to be manipulated.”

Last month, in the April 25 Townhall.com’s “The will of the uninformed,” conservative writer Jonah Goldberg began his column with “Huge numbers of Americans don’t know jack about their government and politics.” He asserts that Americans “are often quite ignorant about the stuff politicians and pundits think matters most,” though they “may know piles about their own professions, hobbies and personal interests,” and “get their clocks cleaned on Fox’s ‘Are You Smarter Than a 5th Grader?'”

Goldberg sees polls as the “seductiveness of populism. It means never being wrong” because “the people” are always right.

The May 4-6 USA Today/Gallup Poll shows 59 percent of Americans want a timetable for withdrawing American troops from Iraq regardless of what happens.

In the May 15 Washington Post’s “Running Out of Time in Iraq,” David Ignatius notes Gen. David Petraeus will report on Iraq in September, but “the core issue remains the need for a political reconciliation” between Iraq’s warring factions. He quotes Adm. William Fallon, head of the United States Central Command: “Reconciliation isn’t likely in the time we have available.”

The May 7 Washington Post’s Department of Human Behavior’s Shankar Vedantam’s “Wariness, Not Hatred, Keeps Civil Wars Raging,” sees research by political science professor Barbara Walter of the University of California at San Diego, as “discouraging to both supporters and critics” of President Bush’s surge.

Walter’s study found that civil wars invariably last longer, become protracted and claim more lives than wars between nations not because in civil wars “people just hate each other,” but opponents who lay down arms before peace is reached must rely on a new government to protect them from one another; and since the stronger faction has an upper hand in the government, the weaker one is left with no recourse should a peace deal be broken. So the argument to “let Iraqis figure out the solution to their civil war themselves,” Vedantam argues, is what “Walter’s research shows, … precisely what adversaries in civil wars are unable to do.”

As two Democratic analysts, Daniel Byman and Kenneth Pollack, of the liberal-leaning Brookings Institution, warn in “Things Fall Apart: Containing the Spillover From an Iraqi Civil War,” to ignore the potential consequences of a U.S. withdrawal from Iraq is to hide one’s head in the sand.

A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the University of Guam, where he taught political science for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.

 

Originally published May 23, 2007