In the world of government and politics, political
leaders have the power to appoint people, usually
supporters and members of their political party, to
public positions. It’s political patronage. It rewards
and enforces loyalty.
However, an appointment to public office of
long-standing friends without regard to their
qualifications is cronyism, and an appointment that
favors relatives and personal friends without regard
for their abilities to perform is nepotism.
Yet even in the United States, few presidents have
entirely escaped being accused by someone, sometime,
of cronyism and nepotism.
University of Guam political science students in my
PS101 classes would remember learning about the
president as overall chief of the federal government’s
approximately 3 million civil servants, some 80
percent to 90 percent of whom are employed in cabinet
departments. The president may appoint some 3,000
people to high-level positions, including federal
judges and legal officers, diplomatic officers and
high-level management personnel.
Students also have learned that the island’s chief
executive, Guam’s governor, has the authority to
appoint many to positions of responsibility.
Theoretically, an appointment of people who are
qualified for the jobs, even if they are relatives or
longtime friends, is not cronyism or nepotism, despite
accusations. Didn’t President John F. Kennedy appoint
his brother to head the Justice Department, President
Bill Clinton put his wife in charge of his domestic
health-care initiative, and President Jimmy Carter
make his old friend his budget director? The term
“Bush Gardens” was used to refer to the Commerce
Department when President George H.W. Bush implanted
many of his friends there.
But the terms cronyism and nepotism carry particularly
negative connotations when those appointed to plum
positions possess neither the qualifications nor
abilities for the jobs they have accepted to perform.
President George W. Bush’s appointment of John G.
Roberts Jr. as the 17th chief justice of the United
States Supreme Court was approved by the Senate with a
solid majority from both political parties. Roberts is
viewed by people from different political perspectives
as highly qualified and competent to take the bench.
But then there was Michael D. Brown, appointed by Bush
as director of the Federal Emergency Management
Agency. Even Brown’s official biography was
questionable; his expertise was with an Arabian horse
sporting group and he clearly lacked competence and
understanding in handling one of America’s worst
natural disasters, Katrina. His inexperience caused
the people of New Orleans even greater tragedy and
affected Bush’s over all job-approval rating as
president.
In “How Many More Mike Browns Are Out There?,” the
Sept. 25 Time Magazine found in an inquiry that “at
top positions in some vital government agencies, the
Bush administration is putting connections before
experience.”
To the question I posed in my Sept. 14 column in the
Pacific Daily News, “What do we on Guam learn from the
lessons of Katrina?” a reader e-mailed his reply:
“nothing, zero,” and lamented that the voters “keep
electing the same incompetents to high office” on
Guam.
On that day, Thomas L. Friedman’s “Singapore and
Katrina” — which I highly recommend for you to read
— in the New York Times reminded that Singapore’s
strong belief in good governance led it to fill senior
positions in government with “the best-qualified and
least-corruptible people.” The island pays its prime
minister a $1.1 million-a-year salary, with cabinet
ministers and Supreme Court justices having salaries
of just under $1 million. With a population of 4
million people and a territory notably lacking in
natural resources, Singapore has built reserves of
$100 billion.
In areas critical to survival, like defense, finance
and ministry of home affairs, “we look for the best
talent,” the dean of the Lee Kwan Yew School of Public
Policy said. “You lose New Orleans, and you have 100
other cities just like it. … We lose Singapore and
there is nothing else … (so) the standards of
discipline are very high. There is a very high degree
of accountability in Singapore.”
And so, be aware of the cost of cronyism and nepotism
to the people and the country. While an elected
government is a good step in nation-building,
competence and effectiveness in government are
essential. This the people of Guam must demand from
their leaders, who should know that if they cannot
provide competent service, they should not accept
public offices.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published October 12, 2005