A columnist asked somewhere whether persuasion is “dead.” His question has remained in my thought. He referenced how many books people check out from the library or buy from a bookstore to reaffirm their views, not explore new perspectives.

I wrote in this space earlier that one should not disillusion oneself to believe one’s conclusions are final: there are counterarguments to any argument. Given time, argument and counterargument are synthesized, producing a new thesis. America, a free market of ideas, lets “a hundred flowers bloom” and does not mow them down, as Chairman Mao did when his flowers bloomed wildly.

A study that showed that in a debate on hot political issues, a person’s rational brain shuts down and the non-thinking part takes over, supports an observation that in such a situation, the level of insults and lack of civility tend to increase. The debate deteriorates from hearing and understanding this other “guy” to personal attacks.

Look around. Don’t we see this happen more and more in both local and national settings?

There are problems with ourselves, our values, our personality, and with insufficient knowledge and information.

My writing in this space usually finds its way to a theory that we are who and what we are because important factors have shaped us: socialization from infancy through adulthood and until death, with family, friends, school, religious faith, job, the media and significant specific environmental socializing agents. They take us through important experiences, guide the formation of our opinions and thoughts, instill in us our values and beliefs, and shape our personality.

The values and beliefs we acquired, the information we learn formally or informally, and our experiences in life present us with some kind of perception of reality. This perception influences us to act, or not.

There is not one reality, but two. One reality is what we can measure, weigh and count, such as the 300 million Americans and 1.3 billion Chinese in the world. The other reality is what we perceive, such as Guam as a “paradise” despite the problems the island confronts, if we bother to read the Pacific Daily News.

Learning more, knowing more and experiencing a lot are essential for our development and individual growth.

Like a circle, agents of my socialization indicate what perception I may have and why, and my perception reveals which socializing agents may have influenced me.

Returning to the columnist’s persuasion is dead, referenced above, it depends on us. Maybe I’m too idealistic, but I’m inclined to believe that even if men are not angels, they have opportunities, through socializing agents, to improve, to know and to be “good” — that we aren’t totally hopeless under karma’s dictates; that we can make some choices in life and are responsible for them.

I like old sayings, but I cherry-pick them. They say we cannot teach old dogs new tricks, but I believe the socialization process we experience since birth, that ceases only in death, never stops molding us, even when we are old and gray. We can learn more and know more until our intelligence capacity has failed us. We can adapt to new circumstances, and as necessity dictates.

The saying, we can take the horse to the water but we can’t make him drink, is one that I used often. Let me present a way to a fountain of knowledge, but no one can be made to go there or do a certain thing after getting there — unless in Pol Pot’s country. I like the Chinese proverb: “A teacher opens the door, but you must enter by yourself.”

The right socializing agents help a student enter the door. Family is the most important socializing agent; eventually, the “village” can give a hand.

The Greek philosopher Aristotle said, “All men by nature desire knowledge.” Men can learn, unlearn and relearn. A teacher can and should develop a thirst for knowledge in his students. But it’s the students who take an intellectual journey to where they think best.

Polish-born theologian Abraham Joshua Heschel said, “Knowledge, like the sky, is never private property. … Teaching is the art of sharing.” For British cleric Thomas Fuller, “If you have knowledge, let others light their candles.” French philosopher Simone Well said, “The most important part of teaching is to teach what is to know.” And there is plenty to know.

Irish dramatist George Bernard Shaw said, “the sole hope of human salvation lies in teaching.” And French-born educator Jacques Barzun echoed: “In teaching you cannot see the fruit of a day’s work. It is invisible and remains so, maybe for 20 years.”

Don’t expect learning, unlearning, and relearning to bear fruit in one semester.

I’m reminded of a principle that has governed the life of Nobel Laureate Elie Weisel, a Holocaust survivor of Auschwitz. A Jew from Romania, he’s an American citizen. In 1992, he told graduates at Boston University that he walked in the footsteps of those who lived before him, that he’s “the sum total of their experiences, their quests. And so are you.”

Weisel declared, “The knowledge that I have must not remain imprisoned in my brain. … I need to pay back what was given to me. Call it gratitude.”

Happy July Fourth!

A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the University of Guam, where he taught political science for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.

Originally published July 4, 2007