I don’t do StoryChat in the Pacific Daily News because participants seem inclined toward a debate that seeks to oppose another’s point of view, belittles or deprecates the other person, rather than seeks to understand and learn from one another as in a dialogue. And sometimes no matter what the topic of a column is, someone is posting the same template.

At the end of last year, my column, “Develop positive thinking for 2008,” brought an e-mail from a reader in a progressive public school system in the Washington Metro area: it’s “a great idea for reflection – and trying to put into action — for the coming year.”

Another reader from the National Institutes of Health rushed to e-mail me, “I’m not done reading this article yet but I already love it!”

But a reader posted in StoryChat that my column “is pure lunacy.” He asked whether I am “naïve or think ignoring corruption will make it go away,” and he expressed his outrage.

Last week, following my column, “Thinking is the basis to building a future,” a reader from Guam e-mailed to say my “positive thinking” column got her through the finish line of the Tokyo marathon, and that last week’s column “is even more encouraging as it teaches” her to focus on “high-quality thinking. Thank you.”

But another reader’s posting opened my door for further discussion on the important topic of critical and creative thinking needed for a higher quality life. He quoted Tim Hurson’s advice “not to rush to answers” in my column, and asked if Guam’s unresolved Ordot dump issues are related to that: “We’ve suffered over 20 years of ideas, inspirations, and insights.”

He closed his posting with a verdict: “Incompetence … I think.”

Hurson’s advice: even when an answer “seem(s) so clear, so obvious, so right,” as when many people on Guam would concur that “incompetence” as a clear explanation for many of the island’s problems, we should not settle on it but “keep asking new questions … resist the urge to answer, the urge to know … (because those) who ‘know’ … don’t need to learn because they already have the answers.”

To “keep asking new questions” is to keep the road to knowledge clear and open to that “vast panorama of possible answers,” which allows a better understanding of the situation. As the Foundation of Critical Thinking posits, we cannot be good thinkers but poor questioners, because “a mind with no questions” is intellectually dead; the mind does not proceed nor process. The Foundation pleads that we “think through” and “ask essential questions” on “what is necessary, relevant, and indispensable to the matter at hand.”

Concluding that the answer to local problems is “incompetence” or “corruption” puts an end to a search

for possible answers to important problems. It raises questions of why and how incompetent and corrupt officials are able to find themselves every 2, 4, 6 years on Guam in positions to continue the rituals that some vocal residents and activists disdain.

Education on Guam is not worse than in other countries in the world. To the contrary, many countries are in worse shape than Guam educationally; yet some have reorganized, developed themselves, and competed successfully with others in the modern advancing world.

There are on Guam students who have won scholarships and awards nationally, attended some of America’s top schools, and have demonstrated competitiveness against Ivy League students. What has happened to those intelligent and motivated young men and women at the University of Guam who spoke and wrote about change and the island’s future? Maybe after this column someone will write to set me straight.

I write often that in this new age when “shifts happen,” learning about anything can be done by anyone anywhere as long as there’s a willingness to do so.

Some use sources on the Internet to learn how to do destructive things. The same Internet could be a source of information for those who seek to learn how other communities have resolved problems similar to those confronting Guam’s citizens.

Let me return to the world-famous playwright George Bernard Shaw’s words: “Imagination is the beginning of creation. You imagine what you desire, you will what you imagine, and at last you create what you will.”

Of course every one of us can imagine; or try to read widely to learn from others about how they solved the same problems we have. Then think positively that if others have done it, so can we. Then put one foot in front of another and start walking the walk.

As I have continued to question, I had to laugh at an e-mail someone sent me. As I tried to understand its content, I have found it worth sharing, and think there is a truth to it.

It’s about an interesting organism called Gv on the island. It comprises lepton-like particles, peons, which surround an atomic mass of 312 particles. At their head is the chief neuron, assisted by 25-88-198 sub-neurons of different names, and all 312 are held together by forces called morons. The organism grows in size over time, with sub-neurons trading places, and some morons becoming sub-neurons, to form what is called isodopes.

Eventually, Gv has to radiate great energy as it becomes an organism with half as many peons but twice as many morons.

The sender of this satirical e-mail is an otherwise sensible person, and his humor reminds me to keep an open mind and continue to inquire. The questions will, I hope, lead me to a long list of possible answers to help me build a better future.

A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the University of Guam, where he taught political science for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.

Originally published February 27, 2008