British Premier Tony Blair’s Dec. 21 remarks in Iraq when insurgents blew up a U.S. mess tent in Mosul, killing 22 and wounding over 60, were unambiguous:
“Whatever people’s feelings or beliefs about the removal of Saddam Hussein and the wisdom of that, there surely is only one side to be on in what is now very clearly a battle between democracy and terror,” Blair said. “On the one side you have people who desperately want to make the democratic process work, and want to have the same type of democratic freedoms other parts of the world enjoy; and on the other side people who are killing and intimidating and trying to destroy a better future for Iraq.”
On Dec. 22, the Washington Post editorialized the insurgents want to create a “fundamentalist Islamic dictatorship” and that “this enemy offers Iraqis, and the world, a stark choice between those who would seek to build a new political order based on tolerance and democracy and those who would replace Saddam Hussein with another totalitarian regime.”
Columnist Thomas L. Friedman of The New York Times initially supported the invasion of Iraq, but has become a strong critic of George W. Bush and his conduct of the war. On Dec. 23 in “Worth a Thousand Words,” Friedman described the picture on the front page of The Times of a man kneeling with his arms behind his back, waiting to be shot in the head and another man lying on his side on a Baghdad street.
Friedman called the gunmen murderers: “You don’t often get to see the face of pure evil.”
Friedman argued there are Muslims “in the heart of the Arab-Muslim world who — for the first time ever in their region — are trying to organize an election to choose their own leaders and write their own constitution.” He warned: “Do not be fooled into thinking that the Iraqi gunmen in this picture are really defending their country and have no alternative.”
He quoted Johns Hopkins foreign policy expert Michael Mandelbaum: “These so-called insurgents in Iraq are the real fascists, the real colonialists, the real imperialists of our age.”
Friedman wrote: “However this war started, however badly it has been managed, however much you wish we were not there, do not kid yourself that this is not what it is about: people who want to hold a free and fair election to determine their own future, opposed by a virulent nihilistic minority that wants to prevent that.”
Last week, Osama bin Laden branded anyone taking part in the elections “an infidel” and deputized al-Zarqawi, leader of Iraq’s most violent insurgent group, as the “emir” of al-Qaida in Iraq.
Iraq’s Shiite leader, Grand Ayatollah Ali al-Sistani, had earlier issued verdicts making participating in the elections a “religious duty.”
A Dec. 10 New York Times column from Cairo by Neil MacFarquhar, “Muslim Scholars Increasingly Debate Holy War,” spoke of a Cairo seminar, “Islam and Reform,” where Muslim intellectuals called for a reinterpretation of Islamic holy texts to “untangle” Islam from the “increasingly gory violence” committed in its name.
A 65-year-old Syrian civil engineer was quoted as saying, “When you take the political Islam, you see only killing, assassination, poisoning, intrigue, conspiracy and civil war, but Islam as a message is very human, sensible and just.”
Newsweek’s Fareed Zakaria wrote in “Who the Devil Really Was,” that “bad American policies” have caused problems in Iraq, but insisted “a more decent, pluralistic Iraq would make a huge difference in the Arab world.”
Zakaria agreed with Larry Diamond, a specialist on democracy and a short-time advisor for Bush in Iraq, in an exchange in Foreign Affairs Magazine that Diamond had with another scholar, Tony Smith. Smith accused Diamond of having made a pact with the devil.
Diamond disagreed: “I do not regard the post-war endeavor as a pact with the devil. Let Smith and other critics visit Iraq and talk to Iraqis who are organizing for democracy, development and human rights. Let them talk to the families that lived under constant, humiliating Baathist rule. Let them see some of the roughly 300 mass graves of opponents of the regime who were brutally slaughtered in the hundreds of thousands. Then they will find out who the devil really was.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., retired from the University of Guam where he taught political sciencefor 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.