John Dillin wrote in the April 12 Christian Science
Monitor’s “America, Iraq, and the question of total
war,” that Iraqi “insurgents are waging their own
version of ‘total war,'” targeting American and
British forces, and “mosques, churches, open-air
markets, restaurants, shops, government buildings,
street corners — anywhere people gather. The carnage
is spreading.”
The United States “could win the war in Iraq if it
wished,” Dillin argues; it has won in all “total” wars
it has fought in the past 150 years. But in Iraq it
fights a “one-handed campaign” with “restraints put on
U.S. troops.”
Dillin acknowledges many Americans say the United
States “should not have attacked Iraq in the first
place. Afghanistan is where the real enemy was.” He
sees this as an argument for historians to settle,
“But the piecemeal way this Iraq war has been fought
has added the injury on all sides.”
He observes that debates in Congress as well as Bush’s
indecisive leadership show that the United States does
not have “the same moral conviction today to win the
war in Iraq” as the “Allies felt a moral imperative —
an absolute duty — to crush the fascist powers” in
World War II.
Under the caption, “Win — or go home,” Dillin writes:
“Perhaps the message to Mr. Bush, Congress and the
American people should be: If this fight is worth
doing, if America truly has an unquestionable moral
imperative to win, then wage it with everything you’ve
got. Otherwise, why is America there?”
A Newsweek Poll in early May finds President Bush’s
approval rating sinking to an all-time low of 28
percent — the same level for former President Jimmy
Carter in 1979.
The May 4-6 USA Today/Gallup Poll shows 68 percent of
Americans think a “full-scale civil war” would occur,
causing the death of “tens of thousands of Iraqis,” if
U.S. troops withdraw from Iraq next year, compared to
47 percent if U.S. troops remain; 66 percent of
Americans think Iraq would be used by al-Qaida for
terrorist operations if U.S. troops withdraw, 47
percent if U.S. troops remain; 52 percent think a
“broader war involving several countries in the Middle
East would break out,” if U.S. troops leave Iraq; 42
percent hold that view if U.S. troops remain; and 55
percent of Americans think there would be “new
terrorist attacks against the United States, like the
ones that occurred on 9/11” if U.S. troops withdraw,
51 percent if U.S. troops remain.
Americans are very divided.
But majorities of Americans have spoken: Whether U.S.
troops stay or withdraw, a full-scale civil war is
expected, al-Qaida would use Iraq as a base for
terrorism and new attacks against America, like the
9/11 attacks, would occur.
So 59 percent of Americans want a timetable for
withdrawing U.S. troops from Iraq regardless of what
happens and 36 percent want to keep U.S. troops in
Iraq until the situation gets better.
Asked how much the view that the United States “lost”
the Iraq war would bother them, 33 percent of
Americans say it would bother them a “great deal,” 19
percent said “not much,” and 24 percent said “not at
all.”
It sounds like a “bye-bye Iraq” prelude.
In January, Gen. David Petraeus was confirmed
unanimously by Congress to be the U.S. top commander
in Iraq. In April he asked for more time for the
“surge” — “Success will take continued commitment,
perseverance, and sacrifice,” he said — but in the
face of increasing pressure from the public and
Congress for the U.S. withdrawal, promised to give an
assessment of it by September.
“September will be the month of reckoning,” writes
conservative Tony Blankley in the May 9 Washington
Times — the reckoning that “may wreck the world’s
chance to stave off a Middle East disaster.”
He thinks Petraeus knows better than anyone that
“successful counterinsurgency is measured in years,
not months”; congressmen “will get an earful on Iraq
from their voters” during their August congressional
break; the new fiscal year’s military budget will be
voted on in September.
Blankley knows the public wants out of Iraq. “Cynical
or foolish politicians will reflexively give the
people what they want. Even most sincere and
thoughtful politicians will rarely find the strength
to long resist the urge of the public,” he writes.
“But when the people abandon common sense for wishful
thinking, they are not likely to be led back to safety
by their leaders. (And it is the people who pay the
price in blood. The leaders rarely die with their
boots on),” says Blankley.
In the April 23 Newsweek’s “The Perils of Pulling
Out,” Christopher Dickey and John Barry discussed how
everyone talks about withdrawing from Iraq, “But is
anyone actually planning for that day?”
They referenced Brookings Institution’s Kenneth
Pollack’s 130-page report, “Things Fall Apart,” on the
consequences of a U.S. withdrawal, and former Central
Intelligence Agency officer Frank Snepp’s “Decent
Interval” on the 1975 fall of Saigon, among others,
and they noted that in “almost every case” when major
powers suddenly withdrew from foreign fights … what
they left behind at the end of the day was carnage and
chaos.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published May 16, 2007