Senior researcher Lao Mong Hay, of the Hong Kong-based Asian Human Rights
Commission, wrote “Khmer Rouge Trial: Time for soul searching,”
published several months ago in UPI Online. It’s a thought-provoking
piece, valuable for people of all faiths.
As the Khmer Rouge trials proceed, Mong Hay suggested “the need for the
Cambodian people themselves … to do some soul searching.”
Theravada Buddhism, a state religion under the kingdom, the republic, the Khmer
Rouge and today’s autocracy, is based on three founding concepts: the
“dharma” — Buddha’s teachings on right actions and beliefs; the
“karma” — a person’s present and future life as determined by his or
her own deeds and misdeeds, the sum total of his acts and omissions in
all his incarnations past and present; and the “sangha” — the ascetic
community within which a person can improve karma (and become a
superior being).
Buddhists who seek enlightenment practice compassion, which is the root of
Buddha’s dharma teachings. Compassion, kindness, tolerance and
forgiveness are the essence of Buddhism.
Cambodia has more than 4,000 monasteries and more than 50,000 monks. Up to 95 percent of the population are Therevada Buddhist.
Mong Hay asked, if “the overwhelming majority of Cambodian people were
Buddhist” before the Khmer Rouge’s rise to power, “how could these
Buddhists among the Khmer Rouge help kill some 1.7 million of their
fellow countrymen” from 1975-1979?
“Cambodians need to do some deep soul searching as to how Buddhist they were prior
to the Khmer Rouge times, and even in current times, where crimes are
no less ruthless,” he writes. “Was Buddhism just skin deep, and were
Buddhist ethical values — such as respect for life, loving-kindness
and compassion — not the Cambodian people’s strong deep-seated core
values as these people might have thought?” he asked.
People in general like to talk. Talking the talk makes some people feel
knowledgeable and even pious, and many do this. But walking the talk is
less common, for it’s harder to do. We “talk the talk” on autopilot; we
don’t internalize the belief system the words espouse.
More than a decade ago, in 1996, Harvard political science professor Daniel
Goldhagen’s book, “Hitler’s Willing Executioners,” stirred
controversies about a German mentality containing “eliminationist
anti-semitism” that originated in medieval attitudes and developed for
centuries. Growing from Goldhagen’s doctoral dissertation, which won
the 1994 Gabriel Almond Award in comparative politics from the American
Political Science Association, the book argues that the ordinary
Germans knew about the Holocaust, did not oppose but supported it.
Someone has compared the Khmer Rouge’s three years, eight months and 20 days of
brutality “as awful and unfathomable as events in Nazi Germany,
Stalin’s Russia, Rwanda, Yugoslavia and Darfur.” Goldhagen’s book
should provide food for thought for Cambodian historians.
After all, were the monsters Khmer Rouge not among the Cambodian Theravada
Buddhists who followed Buddha’s dharma teachings? So what snapped? Did
Pol Pot have his “willing executioners,” in and out of Cambodia, who
knew about atrocities, did not oppose them and even welcomed them? Are
some such executioners in the government today?
Someone asked, why has Cambodia’s Buddhist clergy not spoken out against atrocities, bloodshed and violence, past and present?
Remember there have been Buddhists and non-Buddhists who put their lives on the
line fighting Pol Pot since his victory in April 1975.
A few decades ago, I read a Cambodian statesman’s political analysis of
Khmer history. A nationalist and Buddhist, he wrote of Khmer valor, the
Khmer Empire and the builders of Angkor. The Khmer race was “pouch neak
chambang” — a warrior race — at a time the Hindu influences were
paramount. Then came Buddha’s doctrine of peace, kindness and
compassion to replace the old ways of combativeness and valor, and
Cambodia began her decline, he wrote.
I have asked myself since about a “dichotomy” within a person with an
inner tug-of-war between the combative warrior personality and the
peaceful Buddha-like personality. I was reminded of statues of Hindu
gods such as Brahma (Preah Prum), Vishnu (Preah Noreay), Siva (Preah
Eysor), among others, in Cambodia’s public places — and not many
statues of Buddha.
When I read in another article by Mong Hay, “The history of extremism runs
deep,” in The Phnom Penh Post of Dec. 7, 2001, that “many of our
actions have an extreme aspect” — he drew examples from social in the
family contexts to politics in society — the thought of “pouch neak
chambang” in conflict with the little Buddha seeking enlightenment
recurred. Can the conflict be bridged through learning, relearning and
unlearning?
The deep wounds inflicted on Cambodians, their culture and society by the
brutal Khmer Rouge require no less than justice — the rendering of
what is due to the accused and the victims — before national
reconciliation and healing can be reached.
But the way the Khmer Rouge trials have been conducted put justice beyond
reach. Many who manifest the warrior spirit of Cambodia’s history may
not rest until the accused are thrown in the tigers’ den.
Michael B. Ross, an American inmate on death row, writes men can stop the pain
and heal only by willing to work for it: “Forgiveness … doesn’t erase
what happened, but it does allow us to lessen and perhaps even
eliminate the pain of the past. … It is letting go of the past so
that we can move on.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the Universityof Guam, where
he taught political science for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth