An Oct. 31 to Nov. 2 AP-Ipsos poll found 37 percent of
Americans approve and 59 percent disapprove of
President George W. Bush’s handling of his job, with
20 percent saying they “strongly approve” and 42
percent say they “strongly disapprove.”
A Nov. 7 to 9 AP-Ipsos poll found four in 10 Americans
say Bush is honest while six in 10 think he is not.
USA Today quoted former national Republican chairman
Rich Bond: “Iraq is a roadside bomb in American
politics.”
The relative degrees of approval and disapproval, as
the number of fallen U.S. soldiers in Iraq reached the
grim milestone of 2,000 in late October, led me to a
letter in the Christian Science Monitor during the
Bush-Kerry campaign that asked if anyone can be 100
percent wrong 100 percent of the time. I am still
asking if a disagreement has to be followed by efforts
to demonize.
A quote from Robert Kagan, world affairs columnist for
the Washington Post, takes me back to my graduate
school days at Georgetown University, where I was
introduced to the school of realpolitik: “I think most
Americans believe that although it’s better not to use
military force if you can avoid it, that the world
simply doesn’t provide us the luxury of giving away
military force as an important tool of foreign
policy.”
Kagan, who has a master’s degree in public policy and
international relations from Harvard University’s
Kennedy School of Government and an undergraduate
degree from Yale, is a senior associate at the
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. He’s
author of the book “Of Paradise and Power: America and
Europe in the New World.” He was the principal
speechwriter for Secretary of State George P. Shultz
and worked at the State Department Bureau of
Inter-American Affairs. He is considered a
neoconservative foreign policy analyst and is a critic
of the Bush administration’s bungling in Iraq.
Kagan’s “On Iraq, Short Memories,” in the Sept. 12
Washington Post, started: “If you read even
respectable journals these days, including this one,
you would think that no more than six or seven people
ever supported going to war in Iraq. That’s not the
way I recall it.
“I recall support for removing Saddam Hussein by force
being pretty widespread from the late 1990s through
the spring of 2003, among Democrats and Republicans,
liberals and conservatives, as well as
neoconservatives.
“We all had the same information, and we got it from
the same sources.”
Kagan said his judgment was not based on American
intelligence, before or after the war, but on
information from the U.N. weapons inspectors, Rolf
Ekeus and then Richard Butler, and from senior Clinton
administration officials, especially former President
Bill Clinton, former Secretary of State Madeleine
Albright, former Secretary of Defense William Cohen,
and former Vice President Al Gore.
Kagan brought up that a Senate resolution, passed with
98 votes and cosponsored by Sens. Joseph Lieberman and
John McCain, provided $100 million for Hussein’s
forcible overthrow.
“It’s interesting to watch people rewrite history,
even their own,” Kagan wrote. His father, he said,
recalled for him a line from Thucydides, an ancient
Greek historian and a general, to Pericles, who led
Athens in the 27-year war that ended in Sparta’s
victory and who spoke the line to Athenians: “I am the
same man and do not alter, it is you who change, since
in fact you took my advice while unhurt, and waited
for misfortune to repent of it.”
Not everyone agreed with Kagan.
In “It Wasn’t Just Miller’s Story,” in the Oct. 25
Washington Post, Kagan argued that “the Times, along
with the Post and other news organizations, ran many
alarming stories about Iraq’s weapons programs before
the election of George W. Bush.” He pointed to the
Times editorial page “from 1998 through 2000” that
warned of the danger of Hussein. One Times editorial
said: “(Washington) cannot give in to a man who
specializes in the unthinkable.”
“The Times was not alone, of course,” wrote Kagan, who
also spoke of the Post’s editorials.
Kagan concluded: “As we wage what the Times now calls
‘the continuing battle over the Bush administration’s
justification for the war in Iraq,’ we will have to
grapple with the stubborn fact that the underlying
rationale for war was already in place when this
administrative arrived.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published November 16, 2005