A June 4 New York Times article, “Refugees in a State
of Limbo: Ordered Out of the Country, but With Nowhere
to Go,” quoted figures used by the Catholic Legal
Immigration Network’s data, drawn from the Department
of Homeland Security, showing 1,225 immigrants from
more than 100 countries in long-term detention in the
United States as of March. But thousands more, known
as “lifers,” were ordered deported, and could be
expelled at any time. Until then, they live under
parole-like supervision.
The article recounted the story of a Mogadishu-born
Somali refugee, Keyse G. Jama, 26, who came to the
United States legally in 1996, but was ordered
deported in May 2001 because he stabbed three people
in a drunken knife fight in June 1999. He was jailed
for one year and released, but ended up back in jail
because he violated his parole, and has remained in
jail since.
The Times noted a January 2005 Supreme Court ruling
(5-4), that deportation law requires no consent from
the receiving country. This means that regardless of
Somalia’s lawlessness or Jama’s security, Jama could
be returned to his native land.
The Times traced Jama’s first deportation: He was
transported from Minneapolis on a private jet that had
been chartered by the immigration service, accompanied
by private security guards. Somali airport officials
rejected Jama’s papers and turned him away. Jama ended
back in the Minneapolis suburb’s county jail.
In May 2005, Minneapolis federal Judge John R. Tunheim
was outraged at the failed attempt to deport Jama and
ordered Jama released by May 23. He asked the
government to “carefully and thoroughly plan a lawful
and safe deportation” for all Somalis subject to
deportation. But an appeals court halted Jama’s
release, as the government argued that Jama was a
flight risk and that he was “on the brink” of being
removed. Thus, Jama waits in his jail cell, said to be
at a taxpayer cost of $81.11 per day, until he will be
deported, again.
Jama’s lawyers question how a second deportation would
be different from the first, and argue that Jama’s
long-term detention or his return to Somalia without
assurance for his safety trample on Jama’s human
rights. With a Supreme Court precedent that forbids
detention beyond six months unless deportation is
imminent or there is a specific danger in a release,
the government set June 8 as the date to expel Jama.
The Times called Jama’s situation one of the
“stickiest political and moral quandaries” confronting
the U.S. government: “What to do with people who have
no legal right to stay, yet no political route out.”
It quoted a Cleveland lawyer on the board of the
American Immigration Lawyers Association: “It’s a
serious problem because there’s nowhere to send them,
and if there’s nowhere to send them, they go into this
strange limbo.”
Of the detainees without a country to return to for a
variety of reasons, The Times listed Asians from
India, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, China, the Philippines and
Vietnam. Although only 10 long-term Somali detainees
are listed, some 4,000 Somalis in the United States
are facing imminent deportation. According to
estimates, between 8 million and 10 million
“undocumented” immigrants are in the United States.
Statute of limitations
In a June 14 Washington Post column, “We Need a
Deportation Deadline,” Professor Mae M. Ngai of the
University of Chicago sees merit in the Ted
Kennedy-John McCain bipartisan bill introduced in the
Senate to deal with America’s illegal immigrants. She
argues for the restoration of the statute of
limitations on unlawful entry as a humane way of
addressing illegal immigration. Ngai, author of
“Impossible Subjects: Illegal Aliens and the Making of
Modern America,” urged recognition of the reality of
illegal immigrants: That they settle, raise families,
acquire property, become for better or for worse
members of America’s economic and social fabric.
Today, America needs to answer whether it has the will
to detain illegal immigrants for long duration, and
the will to expel unwanted guests from U.S. soil to
the native countries that they left, that in many
cases do not want them back.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published July 13, 2005