My column, “Assimilation is key in solving our illegal
immigration problem,” brought an e-mail from a reader
in Anchorage, who called for U.S. borders to be
“secured and illegal aliens captured and deported.”
Another e-mail from a reader in Ft. Lauderdale, gave
me links to
www.freerepublic.com/focus/news/1620198/posts?page=1
and to www.alipac.us/ftopict-20052.html, to show me
his view that, “This is not assimilation into our
society.”
Just how did protesters, as seen in the photos, want
to “assimilate” into American society, as my column
suggested, he asked.
Statements and photos, like those in the Web links,
are useful illustrations of Americans’ discomfort and
feelings of being threatened by the “browning” of the
United States.
Last week, in the townhall.com conservative Web site,
Michelle Malkin’s “The victims of illegal
immigration,” talked about a “notorious illegal alien
serial killer,” Angel Resendiz who, for seven years,
has been “perched comfortably on Death Row — eating
chocolate cream pies, watching Spanish-language
television, whining about depression and selling locks
of his hair on Internet auction sites.”
Who wouldn’t be upset with the story?
Then there was an e-mail from Cpl. Joseph J. Brown, an
immigrant from Liberia who came to America in 1999
with his family of 13 people, about whom I wrote in my
Dec. 21, 2005, Pacific Daily News column,
“Noncitizen-soldiers choose to risk ultimate sacrifice
despite restrictions.”
To say “thank you” to America, Brown, 21 years old,
“gave myself” and became a tank driver in Iraq. With
his .50-caliber machine gun, Brown fought insurgents
during the attack in Sadr City in April 2004. He was
wounded, but he saved his American comrades. In August
2005, he took an oath of allegiance to the American
nation.
In his e-mail to me, Brown, a disabled veteran, said,
“If a guy like me wasn’t given an opportunity to live
in this country, my U.S. soldier friends in Iraq would
not be alive today. Each person should be given a
chance to live somewhere in this world. (America) is a
fair country.”
Much has been written on illegal immigration. No
ethnic or political group speaks with one voice. Each
argument has its counter.
I learned a bit from the conservative Heritage
Foundation, a think tank in Washington, D.C. “The Real
Problem with Immigration … and the Real Solution,”
by Tim Kane and Kirk A. Johnson, reminded that when
three out of every 100 people in America are
undocumented, “there is a profound security problem”
and presented 14 economic principles in crafting an
“effective” guest-worker program.
In “Permanent Principles and Temporary Workers,” by
Edwin Meese III and Matthew Spalding, four broad
principles to guide U.S. immigration policy include:
the consent of the governed; national security; the
rule of law; and patriotic assimilation.
Meese and Spalding assert that it is “more accurate”
to refer to America not as a nation of immigrants but
as “a nation where immigrants are Americanized,
sharing the benefits, responsibilities and attachments
of American citizenship.”
An excellent piece, “Making Citizens: The Case for
Patriotic Assimilation,” by Spalding, is a must read,
whether one belongs to the law enforcement camp or the
give-immigrants-citizenship camp.
It begins with a quote from George Washington:
“Citizens by birth or choice, of a common country,
that country has the right to concentrate your
affections. The name of AMERICAN, which belongs to
you, in your national capacity, must always exalt the
just pride of patriotism, more than any appellation
derived from discriminations.”
The Statue of Liberty was presented to the United
States by France in the nineteenth century. The
inscription, “Give me your tired, your poor, your
huddled masses yearning to be free,” shown at its
base, welcomes all to America’s shore. And many
immigrants have come.
America’s national motto, “e pluribus unum” — “out of
many, one” — means that a free government on a free
land cannot be established through a policy of
homogeneity or a policy of multiculturalism, because
the tired, the poor, and the huddled masses need to be
tied together with a common thread that makes everyone
an American, a topic that needs to be examined next
week.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published May 3, 2006