Five years ago, I spoke to an august gathering like this one about Khmer politics and change. It was gratifying when some let me know that my remarks had made them reconsider their thinking and perspective. There were others, I was told, who thought I was too “theoretical” while they wanted an “activism” that takes the fight against the Yuon and against Hun Sen.
The comments of those who were dissatisfied with what I had to say caused me to reflect. In some respects, their preference for a prescription, for specific direction about how to proceed, confirmed my view about what I believe is a deficiency in the acculturation and education of us Cambodians. I began to focus my own research and writing on the topic, “How we think determines our future.”
This year, I’m happy to be here to speak on “Building A Stronger Khmer Community and Lasting Independence and Peace in Cambodia.” I see many Khmer sons and daughters with good experiences, expertise, and knowledge in the five key areas selected by conference organizers. Conferees will take home a lot of information. But such information is only the foundation for knowledge.
Today, Google puts information at our fingertips. Most of us probably feel assaulted by the volumes of data that pelt us every day. What separates us is our individual capacity to distill all that information into something on which we can act. That something is knowledge, and it is developed from information that is filtered through our own past experiences and beliefs and is directly affected by how we have learned to think. As a political scientist, I’ve been taught to think through a method that leads me to describe what is, then to analyze causes and effects in order to forecast what is likely to happen in the future.
Knowledge provokes us to be more curious, not to be satisfied with what is, to never stop questioning until we reach a panorama of answers from which we can choose. Knowledge promotes intellectual growth and encourages our capacity for change.
Today’s question is how to build “lasting independence and peace in Cambodia.” My own framework for attaining that goal is action-oriented and begins with an understanding of power and how to develop it.
Power is our ability and capacity to produce impact, psychologically or physically, on the behavior of others in conformity with our goal. As a nation, our power is strengthened through four elements: our national core, our national infrastructure, our national economy, and our national military.
For our purposes today I suggest we focus on the number one determinant of power, national core. It is the essence and the soul of a nation-state. It includes the nation’s people; their education, health and morale; their political readiness (in terms of competence and leadership skills); their collective reputation (how do others perceive us, our ability and capacity and will to act).
The four determinants of power are interrelated. A strengthened national core helps to achieve the other three determinants of power. But today, where we are, the national core is something we can address.
A country’s people form the national core. I believe that people should be inspired, energized, and motivated to participate in their society and politics; that they should be moved through effective truthful communication; that hundreds and thousands of Khmer should be encouraged to help build a new generation of leaders with the capacity to plan and organize. The one element essential to our success is trust. All good relationships are built on trust, a belief in reliability, truthfulness, ability, credence.
I believe that if we are well educated, we are able to think ideas through. Ideas have the power to energize and motivate us. Emotion can distort our thinking and may cause us to react, alone or in a crowd, in ways we otherwise would not. In fact, two individuals who have greatly influenced Asian thinking agree that the power to affect change is within each of us as individuals. Lord Buddha teaches that nothing is permanent. Asia’s great statesman, Mahatma Gandhi, told us, “You must be the change you want to see in the world.” Thus, Buddha teaches that life is change. Gandhi tells you that you are the agent of change.
American President John F. Kennedy reminded us, “A man may die, nations may rise and fall, but an idea lives on.” For Lord Buddha, an idea is nothing until it is put into action. Buddha teaches you to think, to apply your thoughts, and finally to make your world. To make it easy to remember, here are three words: Think, Act, Become.
Now, I choose to believe that each of us in this room has developed the capacity to think, to be moved by ideas. Let me suggest a useful, simple framework for action that will have a positive impact on our national core:
- First, study the world in which we live. Decide on principles and values to guide us as we adopt and define our goals. A goal is long-term. “Lasting independence and peace” may take decades to attain. In order to advance toward our goal, there will be short-term objectives to be fulfilled. For example, the attainment of the goal of “lasting independence and peace” may require negotiations, entering pacts, treaties, alliances, et cetera. New objectives will develop as we work to address others. Outline our objectives in pursuit of our goal.
- Second, we need to find the means to carry out our objectives to reach our goal. Four important means include manpower, money, materials, and management. Where and how do we secure those means? We need to apply and relate those means to strengthen and build appropriate determinants of power of which I spoke earlier. Outline the sources of the means we can seek out and develop relationships with like-minded colleagues who can network to expand the resource pool.
- Third, we need to decide if the cost required to attain our goal and objectives is commensurate with the result. In market-speak, we are asking what is our potential return on this investment of time and resources? Conventionally, we reach our goal through communications, diplomacy, economic, and military actions. But we can use our imagination and creativity to employ our determinants of power to reach our goal. We need to be smart. What we say and do should have as priorities the building of our strength through winning friends and disarming of enemies in a course of action to attain our goal. Cursing the Yuon and denigrating Hun Sen and the CPP day after day may make some feel better, but I see actors engaging in such activities as being weak and having no strong cause, and as a failure of politics since after demonization nothing positive has occurred.
Remember the political adage: “In politics, there are no permanent friends or enemies, only permanent interests.”
What we should want is to gain, maintain, and defend.
What does it mean to be smart? For our purposes, I’m advocating the importance of critical thinking. To think is not the same as to offer an opinion. Anyone can offer an opinion, whether informed by knowledge or not. An opinion can be a fleeting thought. To think is not to daydream. To think is to observe, to imagine, to inquire, to compare, to calculate, to interpret, to assess, to analyze… Anyone can voice an opinion, but not everyone thinks well. As you work to advance your goal, align yourself with others who think critically, not those who are driven only by their emotions.
And consider the power of thought. How we think determines the kind of future we will have. A positive attitude combined with imaginative and innovative thought, can help us build a quality life. No problem big or small, including problems in dealing with the Yuon and Hun Sen’s autocracy, can withstand continual attacks by our positive attitude, imagination and creativity. We need to let go of our traditional self-piloted reproductive thoughts and habits. You’ll recall Albert Einstein’s definition of insanity – what the Khmers call ចំកួត — doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result.
The act of thinking well, of critical thinking, asks us to be quiet, to reflect, to determine what relevant and necessary questions need to be asked and answered in order to address the goal we pursue. A thinker must be inquisitive. The act of critical thinking is, itself, a component of the national core. The Foundation of Critical Thinking asserts that “To achieve knowledge in any domain, it is essential to think critically,” and defines critical thinking as a “core social value” and “a requirement for economic and social survival” in today’s “world of accelerating change, intensifying complexity, and increasing interdependence.”
Unless change occurs, our lives are likely to continue as they always have, reinforcing French critic Alphonse Karr’s famous statement, “Plus ça change, plus c’est la même chose,” or “The more things change, the more they are the same.” Many talk of change, but as Americans say, many “talk the talk but don’t walk the walk.” You cannot call for unity and send away people with different opinions. President John F. Kennedy once said, “The unity of freedom has never relied on uniformity of opinion.” As Khmer elders taught us through a saying, anything and anyone has a place in this world: អាវៀចយកមកធ្វើកង់ អាត្រង់យកមកធ្វើកាំ អាសាំរញាំយកមកធ្វើអុសដុត Curved wood makes wheel, straight wood makes spoke, crooked and twisted wood makes good firewood. Thus, our Khmer elders taught us the importance of inclusion, a basis for national unity and strength. There is room for all of us, but we must work together to make the most of all our talents.
It would be hypocritical of me not to express my disappointment that the invitation to Khmer M’Chas Srok to participate at this conference was rescinded by conference organizers. If 100% agreement is required of all who join forces to fight for Cambodia’s independence and nonnegotiable territorial integrity, and for Khmer citizens’ rights, freedom, and justice, I am afraid the struggle already is lost. Exclusion weakens us. Inclusion gives us strength. I disapprove of the decision to exclude, but have chosen to see this as a teaching moment, because accepting exclusion is not smart. It is simply dumb.
Time has been long pressing for Khmers to revise or discard some of their mindsets.
Denial and blame are universal traits. But Boun Chan Mol’s Charet Khmer tells us we Khmers are very much prone to deny our own responsibilities and blame others for all unpleasantness, forgetting that as our index finger points at others, three other fingers point back at ourselves. As Lord Buddha says, “Pay no attention to the faults of others, things done or left undone by others. Consider only what by oneself is done or left undone.”
The Khmers’ dependency syndrome includes a propensity to run to others for solutions to their problems. Historically, this has been costly. Year after year since the signing of the 1991 Paris Peace Accords by Khmer warring factions and by nearly two dozen self-interested foreign governments, Khmers still appeal to foreign signatories to help implement the Accords. I have yet to see one foreign government declare its intention to implement the Accords.
Lord Buddha has taught humankind to “Work out your own salvation. Do not depend on others”; and “No one saves us but ourselves. No one can and no one may. We ourselves must walk the path”.
And today, Year 2017, how many Khmers still talk of waiting for ស្តេចសតូចស្តើង to come and rescue them from difficulties and suffering, and how many still pray for the arrival of ព្រះបាទធម្មិក or the “Just Ruler”?
Six years ago, in my article titled “The people must no longer wait for Preah Batr Dhammik [ព្រះបាទធម្មិក] to come to their rescue,” I cited the writing of a former Khmer Buddhist monk named Monychenda, whom I met at the Khmer-Thai border in 1981-82. Monychenda, who later received a master’s degree from Harvard University, explained that ព្រះបាទធម្មិក is just a “title” for one who upholds Buddha’s ten virtues of charity, morality, self-sacrifice, honesty, kindness, self-control, non-anger, non-violence, tolerance, conformity to the law. Monychenda pleaded: Not just the king or ruler, but any person, “can and should be” ព្រះបាទធម្មិក in contemporary Cambodia!
Although today many Khmers seem alienated from Buddha’s teaching, those teachings and Khmer wisdoms are relevant and comprise a force that can propel Khmers forward.
A former Commander of the Khmer People’s National Liberation Armed Forces during my time in the Nationalist Resistance, Meak Marin, alias Subhana Rachana, has shared on the Web some of Buddha’s teaching principles and shared “15 Don’ts” that he appealed to Khmers to embrace: don’t lie, don’t slander, don’t inflame, don’t rely on swearing an oath, don’t denigrate, don’t engage in vulgarity, don’t gossip, don’t be contemptuous of adversary, don’t discriminate, don’t brag, don’t think of oneself as better than others, don’t think of others as inferior to oneself, don’t use empty words, don’t be afraid to ask for clarification, don’t be afraid to accept fault and ask for pardon.
These 15 don’ts are actually components of what both Lord Buddha and his younger counterpart the great Chinese teacher Confucius called Humility, the solid foundation of all virtues, a low view of one’s own importance. Lord Buddha and Confucius advocate being modest, neither prideful nor vain. These qualities oppose the I, Me, អាត្មាអញ orientation that is a source of friction, disharmony, disorder and discontent, whether in the family, the workplace, one’s community, or in the wider world.
Why not employ Lord Buddha’s common sense and Khmer elders’ advice in the development of a more productive and effective national core?
Critical thinking along with Buddha’s teaching should allay Khmers’ fear that Cambodia may disappear as a nation. Khmers are in control of their destiny, if only they will believe it to be so and step up to the charge. I have suggested re-orienting Khmers’ centuries old culture of obedience, service, defense, and loyalty to individual leaders. Allegiance should be to high ideals and principles, not to individuals. None of us has the luxury to sit back and let others do the hard work of rebuilding our nation.
On a lighter note, many of us in this room who have children graduating from schools this summer, should be familiar with the book, Oh, the Places You’ll Go! By Dr. Seuss. His advice to graduates is relevant to us here: “You have brains in your head. You have feet in your shoes. You can steer yourself any direction you choose.” Dr. Seuss, who wrote dozens of books for children as well as this wise but light-hearted manual for young adults, reminds graduates, “You’re on your own. And you know what you know… With your head full of brains and your shoes full of feet, you’re too smart to go down any not-so-good street… So be sure when you step, Step with care and great tact and remember that Life’s A Great Balancing Act.”
I wish conferees well, and I wish the Summit success!
OVERSEAS KHMER SUMMIT
Saturday, July 8, 2017
Gaithersburg, Maryland